Caught Red Handed! (Part 2)

Setting the stage for part two, this took place the summer after my 16th birthday. Myself and my firends were all heading into our Junior or Senior years in high school. We were hot and horny.

Our group started playing again and several times I would glance towards where the two older guys were sitting and saw that they were each with a lady. I was not sure if they were married or not though.

As we continued horsing around, I saw the guy with the big cock wink at me a couple of times, as it was obvious that he was watching me or me and the girl I was with (Cindy). Cindy then noticed me looking towards these other people and she asked me what was up. I told her that the two guys had seen her earlier when her bikini top had briefly come off and that when I went to get a snack they were in the locker room talking about seeing your tits. I told her that they asked me about you and commented on your good looks.

She was kind of blushing realizing when she glanced at them that they were both looking at her and that fact that we were talking about them seeing her naked tits, however briefly. She turned towards me and her face was red. She wondered how she was going to walk down the street now knowing that these guys might be coming out of a store or the post office and say something to her to embarrass her.

I think she was genuinely concerned and so I gave her a hug and told her I would take care of it and left it at that.

We continued playing around until it was time to leave. As we all headed for the lockers, the two older guys came in right behind me and my friends. We kind of glanced at each other several times as we got went into our individual cubicles to get dressed to leave. I was not sure that I wanted to talk to them again, so I kind of took my time hoping they would be gone before I came out. I also knew that I wanted to talk to them to kind of expand our understanding so that they would not say anything about or to Cindy regarding her little exposure.

When I finally opened the curtain of my cubicle to leave, wouldn’t you know it; the only people left in the locker were me and those two guys. They were over by the sinks rinsing out their suits. I started to walk towards the exit but decided to talk to them. I told them that my friend, Cindy, was very upset about what had happened and was scared that they might make fun of her or worse start telling stories about her around town. Before I finished I said that I had told her not to worry, that I would take care of it.

The guy with the big cock then spoke up and asked how I intended to take care of it? I was hoping that they would just say okay and we would be on our way, but that did not appear to be the case. He then asked what I planned to do so they would not bother her. The next words out of my mouth I regretted as soon as they crossed my lips. I said, “I will do just about anything.”

Both guys got big smiles on their faces. They whispered back and forth and then told me that they would promise never to say anything to Cindy nor about Cindy to anyone else if I would do what they wanted. Before I said anything they reminded me what I had said. So all I could say was okay.

At that, they both said well kid we will see you next week right here and they turned and walked out.

I was relieved at that moment, but knew that they would have a week to figure out what they were going to make me do. The only thing that kept me from getting upset about it was that if they kept their word, then Cindy would be happy.

I left and jumped into a car load of my friend for the ride home. Cindy sat right next to me and asked me what had happened in the locker room because she saw me come out right after the two guys we had been talking about. She asked if I had talked to them. I told her that I did talk to them and they were really cool about it and would not bother her nor say anything to anyone else. She put her arm around me and gave me a hug and a kiss. I did not say anything more to her on the ride home.

While I always looked forward to our town swim night, the next week was obviously a little different. The week flew past and my friends were asking who was going to drive to swim night. I could not believe that it was already here again. I was very quiet on the ride and even did not say much once we got into the pool. Cindy had ridden with a bunch of other girls and they had just gotten there.

She jumped into the pool nearly on top of me and was all smiles. She gave me a hug and another quick little kiss and thanked me again. All I could do was smile. As we started our games, I kept on eye on the entrance to the pool waiting for those two guys to show up. After about a half hour I thought maybe they were not going to show, then I looked up and saw them coming out of the locker room. They were carrying some pool toys and went to the far corner putting a couple of tables and several chairs together. Just then several kids went running over there and the women also went over there. It looked as though they must both be married and their whole families were with them tonight.

My first thought then was that they might not have me do anything too crazy since their families were with them. At that moment I felt someone grab my shoulders and dunk me under water. When I came back up I realized it was Cindy so I quickly chased after her, forgetting for the time being about the two guys.

Sometime later I had to use the restroom and got out of the pool heading into the locker. When I was finished and had washed my hands, I turned to leave and right there were the two guys. I was kind of startled and they told me to relax. Then they introduced themselves. The one with the big cock was Joe and the other guy was Steve. Joe told me that they were indeed married, but had been best friends since they were in grade school. Then Steve added that having been around each other for so long they had naturally done everything together, so why not sex too, in case I was wondering.

They told me how they had first started playing with each other after seeing one of Steve’s older sisters naked. Steve had asked Joe if he had ever seen a naked girl before and it just kind of progressed from there. They started masturbating together and then it moved to doing each other, then they tried many other things over the year. They found that they also liked girls very much and the only guys that they had ever done anything with were each other, that is until last week. Steve then added that was why they were so concerned over what had happened and what to do about it.

Joe then added that their wives knew all about them and they were cool about it. They even enjoyed watching sometimes and even participating. Steve then interjected saying, “I bet you would like to see that wouldn’t you?”

I could just stand there shaking my head yes.

Steve went on saying that they kept no secrets from their wives and since they were sisters, they did not keep any secrets from each other. I know my eyes must have gotten huge when he said that their wives were sisters and I had visions of the four of them going at it. Two guys sucking each other and two girls sucking each others’ tits and now knowing they were sisters! I can imagine how quickly my cock came to attention.

Joe then said, “It looks like someone likes what he is hearing!”

Again, I could just shake my head yes.

Joe added that since they did not keep any secrets from their wives that they had told them what happened last week with me. At first they were very scared about the consequences if anyone found out, but then when we told them what you told us about how you had just as much to lose they calmed down. Steve then said they started to ask about what it was like and Joe jumped in saying, “Yeah, Steves’ wife Karen thinks you are very cute!” Steve added, “Your wife was right there agreeing too dude!”

Now my cock was really straining to get out of my swim trunks. The visions running through my head of these four having sex and then adding that the two ladies think I am cute! That went straight to my head (both of them!)

Coming back into reality I finally spoke, asking them what we were going to do about the Cindy situation. I said I did not want her to worry about anything.

Steve spoke first and said they had told their wives about that too. Joe added that they had both thought only he and Steve had seen Cindy’s tits, but found out from their wives that they had seen her too! Both even commented on how sweet her tits looked!

I was really getting horny now and wished this conversation was over so I could go over to one of the stalls in the restroom and jackoff!

So I spoke up again and asked what they wanted me to do so they would not bother Cindy. Steve was the one that replied and he said that they had discussed this with their wives and the four of them had decided that whatever “it” was, that it would not be harmful to anyone. I was relieved by that, but it still did not answer my question.

Before I could say anything else, Joe spoke up. He said that what he and Steve would like first is to watch me jackoff again. “First?” I asked.

“Yes”, Steve added. He then went on to explain that after that they would like to jackoff and cum on me again.

I thought for a moment that this was going to be okay because we had already done this once. I turned and headed for one of the cubicles, undoing the tie string on the front of my suit as I walked. Steve and Joe followed me and pulled the curtain shut behind them.

I had my suit off and laid it on the bench before either of them had started to remove their suits. Before they did, Joe told me there was more. Their wives did not want to be left out of the fun and asked if they could watch us. My cock told me that was fine, the more the merrier, but my head thought this may be getting a little out of hand.

I told them I was not sure about this. They both assured me there would be nothing to worry about. Their wives would tell no one and they would tell no one. Besides, they were risking a lot here too, by bringing an underage boy into their sexual play.

So I agreed to do what they wanted. “Well,” Joe added, “I am not quite finished. “Do you think you could get Cindy to join us too?”

Now I was sure it had gotten out of hand. I told them that I could not speak for her and that I really wanted to keep her out of it. I then thought quickly what if I could get her to get naked with me at a pre-determined place where they could all watch. Would that be enough?

Joe and Steve both said okay to that for now, but that they would have to confirm it with the wives. Then Joe said, “But if you want to give just Steve and I little show right now, that would be okay too.”

My cock was still hard and I still had a hand on it, not realizing that through most of this conversation I had been slowly rubbing my cock.

I wrapped my hand around it and started masturbating while they both removed their trunks. Just like before, they stroked each others’ cocks while I continued stroking. Not only that, they were also playing with each others’ nipples, then moved down to their balls and even inserted a finger into each others’ ass. That was enough for me and I shot my load right then. Rope after rope five, six, seven or even more, I lost track.

Things changed a bit then as Steve leaned over and took Joe’s massive rod into his mouth and started sucking him. He stopped after a little while and Joe sucked him. They went back and forth a couple of times then finished each other off by hand, shooting their cum onto me. As soon as they finished, they did not waste any time in getting their trunks on and heading for the shower. I followed right after them.

We all finished and head back towards the pool. Steve then said that they would talk to their wives and let me know what was next!