The next weekend, Amy invited Allison over for dinner. It was very cool to watch them kiss when Allison arrived. It was a quick kiss, but it still made my cock hard. Allison was wearing a green top, a neat, black skirt, and some simple, black sandals. She wasn't near as thin as Amy, but she still had beautiful legs.
Amy was barefoot, and wore her normal jeans--she had about six pairs of the same jeans--but for once wasn't wearing one of my t-shirts. She had on a white top that showed off her shoulders. No bra, of course--her little nipples wear pressing against her top all night.
We cooked steaks outside on the grill, and they drank a little wine. Amy & I had talked about the three of us all having some fun, and her idea for the night sounded pretty good. Ok, it sounded like the sex dream of my life. Throughout dinner, Allison couldn't keep her eyes off of Amy's nipples and their attempts to break through and escape. I kept catching her staring at them, but she'd just smile. Amy acted like she didn't notice Allison staring at them, or me watching Allison stare at them.
When dinner was done (and it seemed to take forever), Amy asked me to wait in the living room. When she came back, she kissed me—long and wet and deep—as she fondled my cock through my jeans. My poor cock had gotten hard about nine times throughout the meal, and it was definitely ready for some attention. I could tell by the way she kissed me, and the mad gleam in her eyes, that she was extremely turned on.
Amy led me back into our bedroom. She had lit all the candles (we only had seven or eight of them), but more interestingly, the big chair that is normally in the corner was pulled close to the bed. And, oh-by-the-way, Allison was sitting in it. A blanket covered her up, and I realized she was tied to the chair--neck ties around her wrists and ankles. I don't think she had any clothes on underneath the blanket.
I sat down on the bed as Amy went into the closet. When she came back, I asked, "Why the blanket?"
"So you're only looking at me, silly."
She handed me a black leather collar.
"So, you want to be my slave?" I asked.
"Yes,” she said, eyes looking into mine. I knew a big fantasy of hers was to be put through her paces as my slave while someone watched.
"Take off your clothes."
She slowly unbuttoned her shirt, and took it off. Her nipples were hard on top of her perfect, little breasts. I kept glancing at Allison, enjoying the hunger in her eyes and watching her watch Amy. She unbuttoned her jeans, and slid them off, her ass towards Allison. Her cute, white thong followed. She gave Allison a quick glance, as she stood there nude, waiting for me to tell her what to do.
I ordered her to kneel down in front of me.
"Who owns you?" I asked her.
"You do."
"What do I own?"
"You own everything. My mouth. My cunt. My ass. My lips. My tits. My nipples."
"And you’re mine? To do with as I please?"
"Yes. I'm your slave."
“Get me one of the butt plugs,” I told her. This was not part of her plan, and she stopped short, eyes questioning me. I gave her a stern look. She frowned, but then walked into our closet, where we keep the toys.
“Which one?” she asked.
“The blue one, I think.” It was the medium one, uncomfortable but not near as bad as the big red one. I only used that when she had really annoyed me.
“And the lube?” she asked, really hoping I’d say yes. I did.
I had her kneel down between the bed and the chair, so that her left foot was near Allison’s right foot, which was tied to the chair. Then I had her put her head on the floor pointed towards the door, lifting that wonderful ass up, giving Allison a great view.
“Spread your cheeks, slave.”
She reached back and did, exposing herself to me, and to Allison. I wondered what emotions were flowing through her, what was going through her mind. I uncapped the lube, and dribbled a little down her crack. She twitched a little as it ran down. I glanced at Allison, causing her to glance at me, then she went back to watching Amy’s ass.
“Lube up your ass for me, slavegirl.” She took her left hand off her cheek, and I put mine on it, to keep them spread. Her delicate, long middle finger ran up and down her crack, gathering more lube, then I heard her suck in a breath as she slid her finger into her own ass. Deep into her own ass. One of my favorite things in the world.
“Good girl,” I said, meaning it.
She slid her finger out, knowing what was coming next, and held her cheeks wide again, her hand touching mine as she did so.
I kneeled behind her, the middle finger of my left hand against her asshole.
“Give yourself to me, baby. Show Allison who owns you.”
She did, pushing back, slowly forcing my finger into her ass.
“Good girl. A little further now, take it all the way.” She moved a little on her knees, then pushed back again, burying my finger all the way to the knuckle. I moved my finger around inside her, and then slid it in and out a few times, as I watched Allison watch, her eyes wide, and maybe a little scared.
I took my finger out of Amy, then dribbled more lube up and down her crack. She knew what to do, and what was coming, so it took a little prodding, but she again took her middle finger and, after collecting more lube, slid it again into her own ass. Why that turns me on so much, I don’t know, but it does. Something about her long, elegant fingers. And her giving herself to me in such a deep way.
When she had completed her little task, I kneeled behind her again, this time with two fingers lined up on her most intimate spot.
“Do you want to be my slave?”
“Yes, sir. Very much, sir.”
“Show Allison. Give yourself to me.”
She did, again shuffling a little, taking a deep breath, and then pushing back against my fingers, her warm ass swallowing them up. One finger was easy, two much more of a challenge, but she did it, wiggling her glorious ass back and forth, working them in, showing us how much she wanted it.
Then, of course, came the butt plug.
For the third time I had her lube up her ass, giving her a bit more lube to work with this time aorund. I was also a bit crueler, making her fuck her own ass with her finger. Watching it slid in and out, and watching Allison watch it.
I wasn’t very far from coming, my cock hard and straining in my jeans. Patience, I told myself.
Then it was time for the plug. I lined it up on her asshole. “Ok, baby. It’s time. Give yourself to me. Give your ass to me. Show Allison what a hungry ass you have, how much you want to be my slave.”
I could hear her breathing hard, working up to it. I slid my right hand down, and used my fingertips to tease her pussy, spreading her lips and rubbing just inside them. She was dripping, literally. I reached over—it was a stretch—and rubbed my fingertips on Allison’s lips before pushing them into her mouth. She sucked on them, closing her eyes.
“Allison seems to like your taste, slavegirl. And she can taste how wet giving yourself to me makes you. What a naughty, naughty girl you are.” I pulled my fingers out of her mouth, refocusing.
“Ok, baby, show us, show us both how much you want it. How naughty and dirty you are.”
She pushed back, pushing the first half of the plug in, spreading her cheeks wider than even the two fingers had. I twisted it, sending a shiver through her. She wiggled her ass, shuffled her knees back, and pushed a little more against it. It was almost to the widest point.
“It’s too big,” she whispered.
“Nonsense, slave. It’s been there many times before. Even the red one fits. Should I get the red one, make you take it? Make you stand in the corner with it in your ass, while I amuse myself with Allison?” I let the blue one slip out of her ass, watched her asshole slide back towards normal (and tiny).
“No, please,” she said, pushing back and moving her ass around, trying to find the tip of it.
“Okay, baby, you need to show me what a good slave you’re going to be.”
“I’ll be very good.”
I reset her body, pushing her forward again, getting her ass nice and high again. I didn’t let her lube up again, just set the tip against her and waited.
“Okay, baby, show me.”
She did, pushing back, slowly but methodically, working it in, arching first one way and then the other, until the widest part was almost in.
“Almost, baby, just a little more.”
She pushed back, and it popped in, causing her to gasp.
“Good girl,” I said, as a twirled it slowly in her ass.
I picked up the leather collar and moved closer to her head. She moved her hair out of the way, and I fastened it around her neck. It was a cool picture—her ass in the air with the plug, the collar on her neck, and Allison sitting there watching, breathing through her mouth, her eyes wondering how cruel I was going to be to her.
I pulled Amy up so she was standing next to me as I sat on the bed. I rubbed my hand against her pubic hair--she shaves it down to a little vertical strip about two inches long. "Why is your pussy shaved like this?"
"That's the way you like it."
"What happens when you're naughty?"
"It gets shaved off--all of it."
I took my thumb and rubbed it through the entrance of her cunt. She was really wet. Then I took my thumb and put it in her mouth. She sucked on it, tasting herself.
"I think a massage would be a good way to start," I said. Amy had mentioned what she would like to do that in front of Allison. She had not mentioned the butt plug.
As I was sitting on the bed, Amy unbuttoned my shirt with her tongue and mouth, and kissed my chest as she went down. She pulled the shirttail out of my jeans, and then slid it off my arms. She asked me to stand up, then kneeled down in front of me, unzipping my pants with her teeth. I could smell her excitement. She managed to rub my cock as much as possible while doing this, which felt good. When my pants were undone, she slid her hands down my back and into them, squeezing my ass. She pulled them down to my ankles, along with my boxers. My cock popped free, the cool air feeling good. I looked at Allison. She was taking in my hard cock, and then she glanced up. She smiled.
Amy pushed me back against the bed, so I would sit down. She pulled off my jeans and boxers, then pulled off each of my socks. I was nude in front of Allison. It didn't seem fair that I couldn't see her.
Amy moved a pillow into the middle of the bed, and I rolled on top of it so it was under my hips. She poured body oil on her hands, and rubbed them together to warm the oil. Kneeling next to me on the bed, she started with my neck, kneading and rubbing, then moved up to massage my temples and run her fingers through my hair. She went over each shoulder, then down each arm. She took her time on my hands. She put more oil on her hands, and started at my shoulder blades and worked down my back. I love her massages—how much pleasure she gets out of making me feel good and touching my body. When she got to the top of my butt, she moved further down, and started on my left foot. She massaged it, and worked her way up my leg. When she got to the top, she teased my balls lightly with one finger, and then went to my right foot. After she was done with my right leg, she started again at my neck, did a wonderful job on my shoulder blades, and worked down my back again.
This time, instead of stopping at the top of my butt, she rubbed down my back and across my ass. She kneaded the muscles in my back, and then my ass. As it did every time, it turned me on and my cock was super-hard and aching underneath me. She lightly trickled a finger down my crack. Then she massaged my thighs, working up until her fingers were lightly rubbing my balls.
Amy dribbled more oil down the crease of my ass, and worked that into my ass cheeks. She spread my legs, kneeling between them. I felt her lean over on the bed, then felt her hair flow across my ass. Her tongue found my balls, and she licked them from behind. I lifted up, and she took one ball into her mouth, sucking gently on it. I started humping the pillow. She released it, and let me calm down as stroked my thighs and ass. She massaged my cheeks, in circles, so that my cheeks would spread apart and then back together. Her finger ran down the crease and across my asshole, teasing the edge of my asshole--flicking it with just the tip. Then the tip slid just in and out, causing me to moan. She did that a few times, then slowly started sliding her finger in deeper with each thrust. Her other hand cradled my balls, and she lightly massaged them and the base of my cock.
Soon her finger was sliding all the way in and out of my ass, and I wondered if she was looking at Allison while she was doing it. It was a little embarrassing to have Allison watching, but it felt so good I swallowed my doubts.
I wasn't going to last much longer, so I slowly rolled over. Amy kept her finger in my ass, and as soon as I was on my back, her mouth was on my cock. Damn her lips felt good. Heavenly. She pushed my legs wide, then straddled one, perhaps to give Allison a better view. She started rubbing against my calf, her clit and cunt wet against my skin. Allison and I made eye contact, then she went back to watching Amy suck my cock. Amy's finger continued to slide in and out of my ass as her other hand slowly pumped my cock into her mouth. Her lips were tight around the head of it, letting it slide in and out of her mouth, her tongue flicking back and forth across the bottom of it. She took as much of me into her mouth as she could, then stopped and held it as her tongue slowly licked back and forth, driving me crazy. The oil on her hand and her lips made it feel hot and tight and awesome. She liked to go real slow when she knew I was close--to hold me at that highest point for as long as she could, to drive me as crazy as I liked to do to her, and to make me come harder.
I looked at Allison. The blanket had slid down her body, and her breasts were suddenly there. Hers were bigger than Amy's--nice and round and heavy--and her nipples were big and hard. Her ass was on the edge of the chair, and her legs were clamped around the blanket, as she slowly tried to hump it.
Allison watching Amy suck me—the idea of it, the reality of it--pushed me over the edge. I growled and moaned, and Amy let out a little moan as I started to come in her mouth, and she started pumping fast with her hand on my cock, just the head in her mouth, and her finger pumping my ass. I came and came and came, the sound of her swallowing turning me on even more, as she swallowed and swallowed and swallowed.