That's how things were for about a month. Almost every night together we kissed and made out, felt each other up, and so on. Eventually, we were comfortable enough to go completely topless, but our lips never ventured lower than our necks. Our hands, however, had free reign, except for that most precious of places, between the legs. Only her thigh went between my legs, and only mine went between hers. Nobody knew about it except for us. I don't know about Katie, but I found myself checking other girls out more and more, and started to think that I might actually be bisexual.
Nothing more happened between us, though, until the weekend after Steve dumped me. I was spending the night at Katie's again but got there late because of my job at a movie theater. They left the front door unlocked for me, and I noticed that all the lights downstairs were off except for the one in her dad's office, which shone through the door that was only open a crack.
I softly made my way upstairs and quietly rapped on the doorframe of Katie's room as I entered. She was already ready for bed, wearing just a light gray tank top and pink panties. She was sitting on the floor, watching the TV in her room. She turned it off and greeted me. She knew how devastated I was by the breakup and told me she got us some ice cream to drown our sorrows in. That perked me up. But first, I needed to get out of my popcorn-smelling clothes.
Katie watched me as I stripped down to my underwear. It wasn't the same feeling as when we'd get undressed in front of each other before, but it was now a comfortable feeling. Our love for each other outweighed any insecurity about judgement or anything.
As I reached behind my back to unhook my bra, Katie quipped, "What kind of bonehead dumps a hottie like you?"
That made me smile as I discarded my bra by the overnight bag I had brought.
"Well, aren't you sweet?" I stepped over to her and leaned over to kiss her forehead. She took the opportunity to playfully swat my hanging left boob. I stood back upright, a little flummoxed.
Katie laughed. "You brat!"
I pounced on her then, and we rolled around on the floor, half wrestling and half making out.
"Wait, wait, wait," she cried. "Ice cream first!"
"Yes. Ice cream. Definitely."
"I'll get it after I pee," she said as she got up.
"It's cool," I told her. "I got it." I pulled my t-shirt out of my bag and slipped it on.
She nodded. "Grab some drinks, too."
I quietly made my way back downstairs to the kitchen, flipping the light on. I dug two spoons out of the drawer and set them on the counter. I opened the fridge and looked around. I needed drinks that I could take up with everything else without spilling, so I grabbed two cans of Diet 7-Up and put them next to the spoons. Their freezer was a drawer at the bottom of the fridge, so I opened that up and bent over as I looked for the ice cream. Katie had gone all out. I found a tub of cookie dough and another of mint chocolate chip, my two favorites at the time.
"You know, Kristen," a masculine voice behind me said. I jerked up, squeaking in surprise clutching the ice cream tubs to my chest, and turned around. Katie's dad, Mr. Banks, was in the doorway with an empty whisky glass in his hand. I could see the open office door behind him. With the kitchen light on, I hadn't noticed the door open. Seeing that it was just him, I relaxed a little. He gestured at me with the hand holding the glass, one finger more or less pointing at me.
"Girls should be a little more careful traipsing around like that."
The fright faded, but was replaced with sudden insecurity as I realized what I was wearing. I was suddenly quite concerned with the length of my t-shirt. My back was to him and I was bending over the freezer drawer, after all. I suddenly wondered how long he was watching before he spoke up.
I stammered as I replied. "I was just getting some ice cream." I held up the tubs as if they were some kind of exonerating evidence before placing them on the counter with everything else. Some defiant part of me spoke up. "And I'm not just a girl."
I stood there as he looked at me. Looking around nervously, I kicked the freezer drawer closed. I noticed his eyes lower and I glanced down briefly. I quickly looked back up, refusing to acknowledge what we'd both obviously seen. My nipples were clearly hard beneath my baby blue tee. I told myself it was because I'd just been holding ice cream to my chest. Part of me wondered if it was because I was excited.
I'd always found Mr. Banks attractive, and even fantasized about him a time or two after the divorce. I'd never spent any time with him without Katie around, though.
"No, I suppose you're right. You're not just a girl anymore." He started walking toward me. He was still in his slacks and dress shirt, but his tie was long gone and his shirt was mostly unbuttoned, revealing a plain white tee underneath. My breath was shaking as he got closer.
"I hear you're no longer with that boyfriend of yours." He was speaking quietly, but intensely.
"No, we broke up."
"Shame." I backed away as he neared, but almost immediately hit the counter behind me. "Some guys don't know how good they have it."
I was stunned. Was he hitting on me? He was standing right in front of me now, as close as he could without us actually touching at all. I'd never realized how much taller than me he was. He looked down at me as I looked up at him. My breath was trembling. I heard him set his glass on the counter next to me. I had no idea what was happening. I had no idea what I wanted to happen! I was trapped between Mr. Banks and the counter. Part of me was screaming in fear that I was in danger, that he might grab me or kiss me or do something else. Another part of me was screaming in delight that he might grab me or kiss me or do something else!