Dinner was done cooking, but needed to rest a while before cutting into it, so Kathryn and I chatted some more.
“I'm glad you enjoyed having sex with me,” she told me, awkwardly.
“Ummm... yeah,” I replied. “It was a bit of a shock you asking, to be honest.”
“I know, I'm not very tactful. Sometimes I just blurt stuff out.”
“So, you didn't really mean it?”
“Oh, yeah, I meant it, I just didn't know how to gracefully ask, so it just kind of came out.”
“Well, it worked out well enough.” By that, I meant that just minutes before, I was gratified, shooting my load of cum into her snug little cunt. But I didn't want to assume it was good for her too, so I added, “well, for me.” Remembering my manners, I added, hopefully not too late, “and for you?”
“And for me, yes. It really felt good. I hear about the first time being bad, but this was really good. And when you called out my name when you had your orgasm... well, that was nice.”
“Umm, I did? Well, I guess that was spontaneous. Did you... well... were you able to, like... were you, did you....”
“Are you asking me if I had an orgasm?”
“Yeah, that.”
“No. But it's fine. I didn't expect it, and I just wanted to have the feeling the first time without any conditions.”
“So... that's why you let me finish so fast?”
“Yeah, and I wanted to feel sexy. I really don't feel sexy very often. Well, I don't try really, but sometimes I sure want to. But when we started intercourse and you were getting into it, it felt sexy for you not to be able to control yourself.”
“Like... you were in control?”
“No... like I was wanted, desired.”
“So... you were using me?”
“And you were using me. No shame in that. We were using each other but letting each other. That's what casual sex is, right?” Casual. Yeah, that's just what I needed this to be – there wasn't any desire on my part for any kind of romantic or emotional relationship.
Dinner was ready, so we turned our attention to serving it up and digging in, enjoying most of the rest of the bottle of wine with refilled glasses. As our plates and glasses got emptier, our conversation turned to other things, including typical nerdy things, some of which were over my head, but it came back around to sex.
I had been wondering about something, so I had to ask. “So, you seem like you're comfortable talking about sex.”
“Sure, why not? Especially since we did it.”
“When we started doing it, and I was going to go slow but you were like, just put it in...” She looked at me blankly. “You said you had had practice. What do you mean?”
“Ummm, well, I do it to myself.”
“Like, not just your fingers, outside... like rubbing I know, but...”
“Insertion?” she offered impatiently. I realized I was almost talking down to her, and that I could be a little more candid. “Sure, of course. I really got to like masturbating a lot, and got to the point where I figured if I was going to do it with a guy, I didn't want it to be painful or bleed all over. So I started inserting things into my vagina. And not just fingers.”
I was a little shocked, but kind of turned on. Being face to face with a chick talk about fucking herself is pretty fucking hot, no matter how nerdy she is. She went there, so I figured I'd push it. “Like... what? Do you have a vibrator?”
“No, not a vibrator, just a dildo. And not even a big one. I wanted it to be realistic, not buzzing or stretching out my vagina. But that was more recent. The first thing was, my junior year in high school... I found my cousin's condoms one day and stole one. I ended up putting it on a little pump bottle of hair spray that looked like about the size of a penis, and I guess it was because it fit right.”
“So... how was that?” I had to suppress visions of a nerdy younger Kathryn on her back, eyes closed and mouth open to show her braces, skirt hiked up and panties wound around her ankles, with a little bottle lodged in her swollen cunt.
“It hurt. And it bled some. But I tried again a few days later, and after a couple of times, it didn't hurt and felt really good.” She told me about other objects, like, of course, the standard hairbrush, buzzing herself with an electric toothbrush, inserting carrots and other vegetables, lollypops, kitchen utensils. “But I'm not a pervert, I swear.” We both laughed. “Well, maybe a little.” I grabbed the wine bottle and poured the rest for us, distributing it between our glasses. “Oh, and a wine bottle.”
“Um, a wine bottle... you mean...?” She nodded, looking down shyly. I set the bottle down, and couldn't help imagining her, bottomless in a tight t-shirt, squatting on the kitchen floor, sliding her nerdy horny wet cunt down over the neck of the bottle. Like they say, it's always the ones you think are so innocent.
When we were finished with dinner, I helped clean up and put things away. We talked about watching a movie or something, but I wasn't sure about staying. I remembered her saying something about having sex again later since I finished so fast, but I didn't know if I really wanted to, or if I did if should push my luck. I kept thinking that I came over here with the faint hope of getting in Nikki's panties, and I kind of feel bad about it. It's not like I settled for Kathryn, I tell myself. I could call it a night, satisfied enough with tonight but looking forward to something else another time... or, while I'm here, I could see if Kathryn was serious or just spouted that off without thinking.
Sitting on the couch with her, I thanked her for dinner, and we both finished off our last couple of swallows of wine. “When we were doing it earlier, you really didn't mind finishing so fast?” I asked her, starting my leading questions.
“No... we've been over this. I wanted it that way.”
“You said something about... again some time, I think.”
“Uh-huh, yeah.”
“Okay, just checking. That's how you felt at the time... not that I'm asking for it, but... do you still feel that way? I mean, if I did want to again sometime, it's not out of the question?”
“Well, yeah. But I'm not sure you have that exactly right.”
“Um, okay...”
“What I said was, 'we can do it again later.' 'Later' doesn't mean 'sometime', it's, well, sooner than 'sometime'.”
“Like, the same day?”
“Perhaps. I've read about how long a guy takes to recover after ejaculating. It varies of course, but, having sex as early as we did gives us, well, enough time for sure, if that's what you're asking.” She sees right through me. Yes, I sure was asking a newly-deflowered nerdy chick if she wanted to fuck twice in one night. Sticking my dick in her pussy earlier was better than I would have thought, so if she was willing to go for round two, I was up for it.
Speaking of up, my pecker was starting to come alive again, so I leaned in and kissed her. “We'll see how this goes.” She kissed back, with tongue. Hey, if I did things right this time, not only could I feel good about being the first guy to give her an orgasm, but I could also get some more of those titties.
She sealed her wine-flavored mouth on mine, French kissing more comfortably than before. “Yes... we'll see how it goes...” In short, it went well. In no time, she started tugging at my shirt and I let her pull it off. I unbuttoned her shirt, and both sets of pants soon followed. Feeling my dick through my boxers, she told me, “Ooo, you have an erection again. I wondered when you'd be ready.”
“I guess... you're ready too? I mean, since you didn't have an orgasm earlier?”
“Nothing gets by you, does it?” It was almost offensive, but hey, that's Kathryn. And since she was providing more pussy, being reprimanded was a small price to pay.
I unclasped the front of her bra, the cups flapping open while the straps stayed on her shoulders. My boner poked through the fly of my boxers, and she handled it while I put my hand in her panties. We masturbated each other for a minute, my fingertips getting coated with the warm slick moisture that her snatch was producing. She pushed my boxers down, and I pulled her panties off, naked naughty parts ready to interact for a second time.
“If you go get another condom, we can put your penis back in.”
“How can I refuse such a kind offer?” Momentarily disappointed by presumably losing the opportunity for a nerdy blowjob, I retreated to the bedroom. Snagging another condom from the box, though, I counted myself lucky for being offered another fuck, and returned to the living room to the sight of Kathryn spread open on the couch. She was fingering herself, alternating actually inserting her middle finger and diddling her clitoris, and her open bra was giving the access her other fingers needed to pull at her stiff nipple.
I put the condom on in between hurried kisses, then knelt on the floor in between her legs, facing the couch. I pulled her forward a bit, then pressed the head of my cock into her furry slit and flipped it up and down. Having my first good view – as the earlier session was just quick and to the point – I noticed her large labia, gnarled but not unattractive swollen flappy pussy lips, cradling my tip. As I pushed in an inch and then withdrew and flicked side to side, they were like curtains parting slightly, first one side then the other, to reveal peeks at the glistening pink flesh inside. I wanted to spread her wide open with my fingers and explore, but the way things were going with her, I figured I may just get to that before too long.