Mine were 3rd for Short Erotic Story with "Rim Fire", 3rd for Seasonal with "Hung by the Chimney", and 2nd for Voyeur/Exhib. with "At Heaven's 'Bate".
Rim Fire was a bit of a surprise, because that was a far more competitive category with more SOL finalists. ( where most of the voters have historically come from ) Seasonal had fewer finalists, ( and one of them was another of my stories) and there were only three finalists in Voyeur, so placing in that one was a foregone conclusion. LOL
Nominations are already open for 2020, so no need to wait if you want to see someone from Lush recognized next year. Take note of the categories that have few finalists, and fill them up with worthy Lushies for next year. There are some where Lush's trend toward shorter stories give authors an advantage over the other big 2 sites where longer and epic length stories dominate.
I don't know about anybody else, but I saw noticeable bumps in reads, favorites, and votes on mine throughout the last month or so of nominations and final voting.
Are these awards based just on the number of public votes nominees receive in each category or is there some sort of review/judging process involved as well?
Nice to see so many familiar names on some of those lists. Lush completely dominated the Flash category, eh. Congrats to all the Lushies on there. I'm not going to list names because I probably missed someone or overlooked someone I don't know well.
I don't get poetry. I'm sure I'm not alone in that. My "not getting it" grows more pronounced the farther beyond simple rhyming couplets the form is. All I see most of the time is the most complex words possible rammed into a form that is utterly incomprehensible to me.
You'll still get a proportionally much larger response here than you will anywhere else. I took a look elsewhere, and when comparing poems posted vs. the absolute lowest traffic category on the site ( which is an unpopulated wasteland only really worth posting to if you're trying to hit every category ) during the same time frame, that wasteland category still had double the numbers of the poetry. Go with the most popular category on the site, and even a poor story can get as many votes in five minutes as a poem will get in a decade.
The most favorited story of all time has 71x the favorites, 44x the views, and 21x the comments of the most favorited poem. The poem was published five years before the story. That's the kind of disproportionate response I'm talking about elsewhere.
If you make the same general comparison here, using the main page popular tab, you have the most popular story clocking in at 3x the votes and 1.75x the comments of the most popular poem.
That's as close to apples to apples as I can get, because you can't search by favorite numbers here, and you can't search by vote totals there.