Sometimes I wonder about this great classic.
First off, how come there's not a single non-white inmate in that jail?
Then, it's not a bit insulting to the viewer's intelligence the idea of a man eating 50 boiled eggs? Any person would die.
And last, just a psychological comment of the character of Paul Newman, dont you think he was a bit passive-aggressive? The guy just refused to accept the system, but didn´t seem to have a plan or a philosophy of his own, I dont think the guards were the "bad guys", they just did their job, he only got beaten-up after his second run away attempt, so it's not like the guards were abusive thugs,IMO.
What you think about this?
PS, Dont get me wrong, I loved the movie, it's just I find those little details a little bit out of place.
Unfortunately I can't help with all your issues but at the very least I can put one to bed. The reason you only see white men in the farm is because during the time the movie is set, prison work farms like much of america was segregated. If you watch the movie Life (similar situation, though vastly different movie) you'll notice only black inmates until the movie shifts time periods to the 90's.
As far as the 50 eggs there are internet rumors of such a feat happening, but obviously you take such things with a grain of salt. I too would be doubtful that such a thing was possible in an hour.
Movies (especially good ones) will always be subject to perception and interpretation. In many movies depicting criminals and cops you will have conflicting view points as to who the "bad guy" is. A perfect movie that illistrates this is Heat. Some see Al Pacino as the hero where as others think De Niro was the good guy. People with a persecution complex generally empathise with criminals. Cool Hand Luke was shot with a more antiestablishment slant (which was popular at the time given the nations overall view of the handling of vietnam) and thus leans toward villifying the guards, but I think the movie does a fantastic job of depicting many of the guards as simply doing their job.
I feel that Luke wasn't passive aggressive, infact I would say that his multiple escape attempts made him a very aggressive opponet of the system. But I agree that he was doing so blindly without any real plan. Coming from the army where his every move was dictated into the prison farm where that was even more so the case forced him into a minset where he didn't care what he did, as long as he got to do it his way. Like a dog chasing a car, he wouldn't know what to do with it if he got it, but he just can't help himself. This is demonstrated at the end where, after successfully escaping with a HUGE headstart, he simply stops and waits in a church.
Again I think the movie is completely meant to be individually percieved without a right or a wrong, so your views are completely valid and endlessly interesting.
Ok Sage, thanks for your reply. The whole movie is on youtube, with lots of interesting comments from the viewers, I am learning a lot, now I even know the name of the blode washing the car in front of the chain gang, Lol.
What one can learn so much from YouTube (or YouPorn for that matter) is amazing!
I had actually just watched part of Cool Hand Luke the other day - and watched it thru the eyes of when the film was made - not as in today's PC world.
Go back and view some other classics, such as To Kill a Mockingbird, Guess Who's Coming for Dinner, (and countless others) on the society of the day. One cannot condemn what was appropriate at the time.
anyways .....
We have come along way baby - as a slogan from the 60's said about a woman smoking a cigarette. (Virginia Slims is a brand of cigarette manufactured by Philip Morris. The brand was introduced in 1968 and marketed to young professional women using the slogan "You've come a long way, baby." )
Van
btw - Paul Newman was absolutely gorgeous then in Cool Hand Luke, and when I met him in NYC when he was in his early 70's .... I was astounded by his handsome smile and amazing twinkle in his eyes .... (swoon).
You are right, VG, I just love to read the comments. When I am watching some good old porn , if the video has no coments, I dont even bother watching it.
In Cool Hand Luke, people started posting comments like " just enjoying this movie here, boss". Makes the whole thing an interactive experience.