Quote by Chryses
I think you and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia are not referring to the same thing. The court was asked to determine if the District of Columbia’s defacement ordinance was sufficiently selective to have violated the First Amendment.
“This case is about the District’s alleged discriminatory enforcement of its defacement ordinance. The ordinance prohibits “willfully and wantonly … writ[ing], mark[ing], draw[ing], or paint[ing]” on public or private property, without the consent of the owner or the public official controlling the property.1 D.C. CODE § 22–3312.1.”
The court ruled unanimously that the District had acted unconstitutionally.
Nope, though it is a deft evasion of the facts of the case, which I was discussing (see my last paragraph).
Still, I'll allow it.
Below is a less sensationalistic summation of the case. Note the first sentence says the panel ruled to revive the lawsuit, not decide the outcome of the lawsuit. "A U.S. appeals court on Tuesday revived part of a lawsuit claiming that the District of Columbia enforced an anti-graffiti law against anti-abortion protesters in Washington but not racial justice demonstrators in 2020."
The case USCA Case #21-7108, which you refer to, is an appeal. It is not a final ruling. The court ruled unanimously that the suit can proceed, not that the district had acted unconstitutionally, as you state,
