Quote by BiMale73
Here's one for you. Put it on!
All you did in that last post was reword what I said you big dummy.

Quote by TheAngryishLover
Not really, because that was stupid. Believing that sounds don't exist without the ability to convert vibrations into sound is...science!
Quote by avrgblkgrl
I'm one of those touchy/feely types that the more techie/scientific types abhor.
It's a bit narcissistic to think that something so apathetic would depend on our presence in order to exist.
Quote by TheAngryishLover
Yeah, but that isn't what sound is.
Some creatures don't hear at all, and convert those vibrations into something else (like 3d sight).
You are talking about vibrations as if they are sound, when they aren't. It's just what your ears convert the vibrations too. I would argue that we aren't disagreeing over the word sound (we can't, or at least I didn't think we could, as it's clearly defined for us), rather you have misunderstood the concept of a vibration
Quote by TheAngryishLover
as I've said, in every single post I've made on this subject, yes it does. It creates vibrations through the air and ground, both of which have the potential to be converted to sound
Quote by TheAngryishLover
Completely different.
Sound is, as Patokl referenced (although he miss read....) defined as the converting of vibrations to sound.
It's quite simply, by definition, not possible for sound to exist without something there to perceive it as sound.
The guy who first asked the question (I've looked it up...) was a philosopher of perception....at a time when philosophy and science meant the same thing! And sound is exactly that, a perception. It doesn't exist unless someone is there to perceive it
This is the last time I'll say this, as if it can't be grasped (or refused to be understood or believed) then there is nothing else I can do, but sound is the converting of vibrations into a sound. It's converting the movement of air from a falling tree (in this question), into sound.
No ear, or nothing mechanical to convert it to sound, and there is no sound
The movement of the air still exists, and the possibility of sound is still there, but there can't be actual sound if there isn't something, organic or otherwise, to convert/perceive it as sound.
The whole point of the moon is a bit like Schrödinger's cat- ie if you can't see the moon, is it 'alive' or 'dead'. Well....we don't technically know, but we DO know that if a tree falls and no one is around to hear it fall, that it doesn't make a sound!
Quote by seeker4
I have very little enthusiasm for the DC universe as it is shaping up. Deadpool seems far more promising as a darkly humourous anti-hero take on superheroes. Jared Leto's Joker holds no appeal for me. Only the prospect of a live action Harley holds out much hope for this movie in my books.
The only DC movie I am really getting hyped for is Wonder Woman. Gadot looks fantastic in what we've seen so far and there has not been a good live action WW since Lynda Carter (and that was cheesy as all hell in retrospect).
Affleck doing a solo Batman movie also interests me but there is not much known about that one, yet. Alas, it will likely include Leto in some way.
Quote by TheAngryishLover
I'd love to know what scientist believes a sounds exists without an instrument to turn the wave into sound?
Please point them out to me....
Albert Einstein is reported to have asked his fellow physicist and friend Niels Bohr, one of the founding fathers of quantum mechanics, whether he realistically believed that 'the moon does not exist if nobody is looking at it.' To this Bohr replied that however hard Einstein may try, he would not be able to prove that it does, thus giving the entire riddle the status of a kind of an infallible conjecture, one that cannot be either proved or disproved.
Quote by RavenStar
Who originally asked the question doesn't matter. For the purposes of this thread, it was asked by Trinket, and she placed no limitation on the subject of the response.
So, TAL can be correct with his science and you can be correct with your philosophy.
WE'RE ALL WINNERS!!!!
Quote by TheAngryishLover
Technically, it doesn't make a sound unless someone, or thing, is there to hear it.
I don't know who first asked the question, but the scientific answer is no, it doesn't!
Quote by TheAngryishLover
Sorry magical....this really sounds arrogant, but I'm not THINKING about the answer, but I KNOW the answer.
The movement of air, from a falling tree, is a wave. A wave is not a sound. Sound is simply a perception of that moving air. So you would need something to convert that wave into sound, as above.
The use of the human is simply an illustration of something that can convert those moving particles of air. As I said earlier, even if a human wasn't there, SOMETHING would be converting to the waves into sound. But this is the meaning of question, and why it is an interesting one. And this isn't my theory, it's the answer....
Quote by TheAngryishLover
Just saw this
I'm a bit of a science geek and this stuff interests me, so I'm not trying to sound argumentative or arrogant here, but 'sound' doesn't travel in air or matter, but rather shock waves travel through air and matter.
So you are right in that the shock waves will travel regardless of a human presence or not, but only when an ear, or a mechanical instrument capable of doing the same thing, converts those waves to sound, does it actually become a sound
Hence, if a tree fell and no one was around, would it make a sound?
No.
But, you could argue that even if a human wasn't there, then there would be plenty of other creatures able to convert the waves into sounds!
Quote by miketabcdefg
I would say that sound doesn't need a measuring device (ear or otherwise) to exist, excepting that we needed to have such devices to know that sound exists in the first place. This also accepting that sound will always occur when anything moves through a gas or the gas moves relative to other masses (of whatever matter phase). Also accepting that there isn't some as yet unforeseen phenomena that can provide an exception, such as something causing a vacuum around a falling tree. Ridiculously unlikely, just highlighting that nothing is ever 100% certain.
However the question was whether a tree makes a noise (which is not how the question is usually couched in terms of sound). A noise is an unpleasant sound. Unpleasantness is an intentional state requiring a conscious entity and so therefore if there is no intentional being around to detect the tree falling, and that also doesn't like the sound of the tree falling (a logger might quite enjoy it) then it won't make a noise, just an unrecognised or recognised pleasant sound.
But as per always with these type of arguments, they get bogged down in semantics.