Quote by noll
Nope. The reality of human biology is simply not binary as there are folks who don't match that binary division. It doesn't mean it applies to most folks or not.
Our culture has been very binary focussed for ages, and therefore people have been pushed to adhere to this binary division. Transgender identities were largely hidden and intersex physiologies were most often surgically changed to match the binary.
It's only recently that we've started to see that change slowly, and I expect it'll take another while before we get a clear grasp of how far off the binary divide really is.
We can hold on to the strict division, and have a growing group of people be treated as second class citizens by excluding them from sports, or we can try to fit the non-binary reality in the binary division, which seem silly hacks. Or we can do away with the binary divide altogether and come up with something better, like categories based on abilities related to each specific sport. That takes more effort, of course, especially for those who think using different pronouns is already too much to ask.
I have a gray hair, I guess that means I'm not a brunette.
Look, one of the reasons people push back against trans people is bigotry yes, but also when they do shit like go and dominate women's sports. You're never going to convince me or anyone rational that men competing against women is fair. Or the other way around either. Like a female gymnast is just better than man at certain things. Of course there are exceptions and there are some people that have messed up genetics. That is not even close to being the norm to go and be like well every single athlete needs to be evaluated and put against another athlete with exact same size and strength blah blah blah. That is so stupid.... so so stupid.
I take it you don't have daughters? One of mine is tall, she's 10 but plays with the 12 year olds because she's extremely strong and fast for her age. They played a team with a straight up boy a few months ago and that boy got like every rebound, muscled the girls around so much they wouldn't even get close when he had the ball, they just gave up. It was such total bullshit because these girls work hard to try and win these tournaments then get totally deflated by nonsense like that. Not to mention the rest of the parents are just visibly super annoyed but everyone stays polite during the game but afterword everyone agrees it's not right. It juts feels like cheating. And it's not just the parents, the kids feel it too. It's bullshit.