ElCocko and Ironic have found this thread... just going to be filibustered now.

Quote by Buz
If you owned a printing business. would you print pamphlets for Nazis or The Ku Klux Klan? Should it be your right to turn their business down.
Explain how being gay is the same as a hate group who incites violence.
When was the last time gays committed genocide of millions of people?
Quote by DanielleX
This is the exact reverse of the Irish gay cake case, where the Supreme Court ruled that it was the message of gay marriage that the baker objected to. They openly had no problem in selling a cake to a gay couple.
But that is pretty much discriminating without calling it discrimination. Legal discrimination directed to only one group.
It's like saying, look, here on lush we object to men typing up stories or posting in the forum or even typing in chat rooms. It's not men that are problem, they're cool, just what they type that isn't so cool. So the outcome would be no men are allowed to participate on lush but lush saying, well we aren't discriminating against men, just men typing.
Like what, are the gay couple going to buy a straight cake for their gay wedding? I mean this is just a technicality, this whole notion that it's not about the customers, it's only about the customers wanting a gay cake. Plus what makes it a gay cake? Too many flowers? Two groom dolls? Like could they buy a regular cake and buy two groom toppers off the shelf? Or would that make the baker a participant in the gay wedding now?
Give me a break.
Do you think they would rule the other way around in Ireland? Like say people not providing services to catholics, not because of catholics themselves... but just about what they believe.
Quote by Just_A_Guy_You_Know
The distinction I see is between making a cake according to someone's preferences vs. selling them a cake that's already been made by you. If I own a bakery, I don't care what your politics are, I'll sell you a 'happy birthday' cake. What you do with it afterwards is your own business. But I won't custom-bake you a 'happy birthday dead baby Hitler cake' because you don't like the cakes I've already got or the designs I'm willing to provide. As the old saying goes, "Sorry, Mario, but our princess is in another castle." You want that particular cake, go somewhere where you can get it (or learn to make it yourself then fill the gap you've identified in the cake-baking world and get rich), but you can't expect that a place run by bigots, homophobes, and assholes is going to have what you need or be interested in providing it for you.
Yeah but still, it's about who the customer is, not what's on the cake. That just seems to be more discrimination than anything else.
And how are people able to tell which cake maker is a bigot?
I mean the most shocking thing to me is that someone who chose cake making to be their livelihood is prejudiced against gay people. I mean come on.
Quote by Just_A_Guy_You_Know
I can see Chryses' PoV. If you rearrange the situation, let's say you're a Jewish baker, and a customer comes in and wants a cake decorated with swastikas. It makes sense that you would refuse to bake a custom cake with swastikas. None of the cakes you've baked already that are on display have swastikas on them. It's the swastika that's objectionable, not the sale. Creativity is also freedom of speech. In this situation, to force the baker to bake a swastika cake, you limit their freedom of speech by forcing them to adopt speech that they are morally opposed to.
Except people wanting nazi cakes is not a thing. Gay people getting married and wanting a cake is. It's not like the cake has two guys sword fighting or anything obscene on it. It's just a cake for gay people. There is a big difference between discriminating against Nazis or a baker not wanting to make like a dead baby cake or something crazy and just a cake for a gay couple. The right for a business to not make something obscene or copyrighted has always existed. This is literally about not making a cake because of who the customer is and not what is on the cake. That's discrimination, not free speech.
You know damn well that if businesses would stop providing services to christians like they do to gay people that all of a sudden the laws would change and it would not be a free speech issue for the businesses. It would all of a sudden be a free speech issue on the side of the christians who are being discriminated against.
Quote by Chryses
I'm not a subject matter expert on this topic. See a professional.
Oh you're cornered with logic again.
Because you said that a cake maker can discriminate if someone comes in wanting a custom gay cake but not if the customer just wants one of the cakes that's in the display case.
Quote by Chryses
Were you to refuse service to anyone wearing a cross, I would expect you to be successfully prosecuted for discrimination, as not wanting "them doing anything funny" with your wine seems to me to be an inadequate basis for you refusing to serve members of the public,
I think it wise to review that sales strategy with a local lawyer.
edited
Okay so I can only discriminate if they want a custom label on the wine that seems to be gay?
Quote by Chryses
Hate crimes are hate crimes. You do, of course, enjoy the freedom of speech to say what you believe.
That’s right Chryses, a hate crime. When the right wing is constantly villainizing gay people, calling them pedophiles then it stirs up hate. Then the dumbest of you, act on it.
Bud light made a can for a trans person… the right wing are still constantly screaming about it.. that trans person has received endless harassment and death threats. And for what? Because a dude is dressing like a girl. The right wing, the useful idiots like you who try to sanitize and spread their hateful messaging, are the actual villains.
Constant hateful rhetoric from the right wing’s leaders ends in hate crimes.
Quote by Chryses
And the real estate tax reduction on another empty building, and the lost tax on the ex-employee income(s).
Damn, San Francisco is going to have to lay off half of the city now that they aren’t getting that Gump payday. And no one else will be able to use the building for a store or service that people actually want/need.
Vote Republican.
Quote by Chryses
There is no right to discriminate to be defended. There are several natural rights included in the First Amendment. One of them is a right to free speech that has been successfully defended.
Conservatives: it’s our first amendment right to refuse service to gays!
Normal people: okay well we are going to put rainbow flags at our businesses so gay people feel comfortable shopping here. That’s our first amendment right
Conservatives: no not like that! 😡
Quote by ElCocko
The owner of Gump's knows more about running a business than you do.
https://sfstandard.com/2023/08/14/gumps-owner-slams-san-francisco-in-letter-downtown-crime-homeless/
He's warning that if the problems that prompted other SF businesses to leave the city, he'll make an anti-bad business decision and move Gump's out of the city too.
Is that what you want?
I don’t care if Gumps moves out, like why would I? Only people it affects is the owner and suits. Oh gee what will people do? No where else to buy overpriced trinkets.
There are homeless people in SF, the location Gumps is at isn’t great at the moment. If the place is good and the people who run it are such business experts then they should be successful elsewhere. Maybe in one of the Carolinas or like Montana or somewhere is more suited for their vision of overpriced frivolous items.
Maybe they should buy up all the housing like other companies did BUT instead of being greedy and gauging people on rent they will set it at an affordable price so that the price of housing doesn’t put people on the streets.. even if california would try to make it illegal like it is in other developed countries for Zillow to buy up all the housing it would be seen as some government socialist woke overreach by republicans.
A ceo of a place like Gumps should know how capitalism works… hard to feel sorry for a business that sells crap at an extreme markup.
Quote by sprite
this is not really about free speech, tho, is it. it's about the hatred and fear being fostered by the far-right against the LGBTQ+ community and their allies. they're pretty much opening the doors for people to commit violence and murder against those who belong to either group and then claiming that they can do that because, hey, free speech... so maybe it is a "free speech" issue. the freedom to incite hate and violence against anyone they don't like,
You said it better than I did.
"Free speech" is just their way of wrapping their bullshit in the flag.
Quote by Chryses
[Edited. See above^]
Republican rhetoric, propaganda and policy leads to violence.
Hateful conservative dumbasses interpret the ruling as open season on gay people and people who support gay people.
You now have DeSantis saying he wants to shoot people at the border because he is making up a fantasy that they are working for the cartels. The dumbest of you will interpret that as a call to violence as well.
Quote by Chryses
This tragedy was another example of an individual killed defending her First Amendment right to free speech.
Man kills shopkeeper in US state of California after disparaging Pride flag
You said this wouldn’t happen. You laughed at the notion of conservatives getting violent after the free speech ruling where you were happy that it became legal for business owners to discriminate against gay people.
I told you conservatives would be too stupid to understand that it works both ways and that it would lead to violence.
Congrats on proving what hogs you people are.
Told you this would eventually end in violence. The “free speech” thread was locked where I was met with the usual posters denying the right wing’s violent tendencies.
The ruling that conservatives cheered on that now allows businesses to deny service to gay people would cause businesses to counter react and of course a conservative got violent.
“A business owner was fatally shot on Friday after someone allegedly took issue with a Pride flag she had displayed at her clothing store in Lake Arrowhead, California.
Deputies responded at 5 p.m. to the shooting at the Mag Pi clothing store, where owner Laura Ann Carleton was pronounced dead at the scene, the San Bernardino Sheriff's Department said in a news release. The suspect, who was not identified, fled the scene on foot.
“Through further investigation, detectives learned the suspect made several disparaging remarks about a rainbow flag that stood outside the store before shooting Carleton,” the news release said.
The suspect was armed when confronted by deputies and was killed in "a lethal force encounter," the sheriff’s department said. An investigation is ongoing.”
https://www.nbcnews.com/news/amp/rcna100849