Quote by DamonX
Banning guns in one state doesn't really do anything. How hard is it to transport guns across state lines? By increasing accessiblity of guns in the country, you increase the risk of guns falling into the hands of people who will use them for criminal activity. Nobody is claiming that registered gun owners in Montana are more likely to commit crime. Its when they filter down into inner city areas and low income areas that problems arise. And the majority of crimes are committed by unregistered guns and unlicenced gun owners so stats about gun ownership are not really relevant.
I think you guys are mistaken about our position. Nobody is claiming that simply because you own a gun, you are more likely to commit a crime using that gun. You are taking an individual approach: "I have a gun and it makes me feel safe."
We are using a broader, sociological approach. Your society has easy access to guns, and...your rate of gun crime is off the charts. Or course, this is just correlation and not direct causation, but it seems pretty clear. If you feel the need to have a gun for protection...ok. Your society is already flooded with them, so it makes sense that you would want one for protection. But wouldn't you rather not need to carry one in the first place?
And how many of you have guns simply for protection? I know Ladyx does, but it seems that most of you guys just like guns because they're fun. I get that. I used to like guns too. I grew out of it when I turned 15, but I can see the appeal. But try and view things from a broader perspective. You can obviously post news articles about homeowners shooting invaders, but these are isolated incidents and don't really paint the proper picture of the state of your society.
Do I think that the government should take away your guns? No.
Would your rate of gun crime be lower if you had restrictions similar to the rest of the western world? Yeah, probably.
It would be refreshing to hear someone say "I like guns because they're fun!" and not try to justify it by stating the 2nd amendment or try to convince everyone else that "an armed society is a safe society."
I'm trying to figure you out. Your post is full of hyperbole, half-truths, and untruths. Are you being dishonest by accident? Or are you being dishonest deliberately?
First, we don't have "easy access" to guns. It's not like you can walk down to the corner grocer and pick up a gallon of milk, a loaf of bread, and a 9mm. Second, our "gun crime" rate is NOT off the charts. As has been shown earlier, our rate of gun crime is much lower than many places in the world where gun ownership is not as prevalent. And as long as we're on that subject, why do you insist on separating "gun crimes" from crime overall? Does it matter to a victim whether she was at gunpoint, at knifepoint, or by simple brute force? Does the fact that her attacker only had a knife mean that her is not as serious, or as damaging? You've never addressed the idea that criminals will commit crimes whether they have access to firearms or not. You only want to address "gun crime" without even identifying what you mean by that term. Despite all this, though, you admit that a greater presence of firearms does NOT mean there will be a greater amount of "gun crime" committed. You can't have it both ways - either you assert that more guns equals more crime, or you look at the statistics already presented, and admit the opposite.
Looking at things from a sociological point of view... there are countries with many fewer privately owned firearms, and in those countries, the crime rate is greater than the United States. There are also countries with fewer privately owned guns, where the crime rate is less. There are countries where the ownership of guns more closely mirrors the United States, and the crime rates in those countries may be greater or less than ours as well. What does that tell you?
The answer is that crime is not a factor of how many guns are in circulation, but of how many criminals are.
