Quote by JohnC
I will go against the grain here and say YES, a girl can be too tight. But this is not from the penis standpoint, but of the vagina. When you are not matched up physically you can cause the girl discomfort and for ME, that is "too tight". While it may feel good on my cock, knowing it is hurting her ruins the whole thing for me. Now a little pain is fine now and again, but when the whole experience is just too uncomfortable, it is "too tight".

With that said, yes, most girls will adjust pretty well with the proper attention and care. But as with all things, you have those (both cocks and pussies) that are outside the "norm".