On my drive home, I confirmed my plan in my head. I was going to act completely normal as if nothing had happened and I had been sick last night as I had told her I had. I had gone as far as to make myself vomit in the upstairs trash can to make it seem real. I am a conniving man when I need to be.
I stopped at the store and bought lobster tails and filets with a good bottle of Sterling Chardonnay. I would cook us the anniversary dinner I had planned before the debacle as if nothing had happened.
I had a gift I would give my wife in the hotel so that I would give it to her over dinner. We would cuddle by the fire pit and finish the wine. Then to bed, and I would make passionate love to her. All the while, Sara Anne would be dying inside. Guilt would consume her, and she would not be able to understand if I knew she had cheated, how I could be so loving. It would confound her and make her wonder if I was The Phantom.
That is exactly what I wanted to do.
All the while, it would take every bit of restraint and love I had in me to touch her, speak to her politely, and put my cock in her where twenty-four hours ago, another man's cock had been. I am a strong-willed man, and I can do anything I want, which is what I want.
I need Sara Anne to feel the ultimate guilt. I need her to see me as the only man she can ever love and that what she has done was a vial, deceitful, humiliating, and destructive thing. It was marriage suicide that her loving husband saved her from.
I turned in the driveway and pulled into the garage. Before I could even close the garage door, Sara Anne stood at my car door. The look on her face was fear. She had no idea what I would say or do, which terrified her. That was exactly what I wanted. The rest of today and the night were going to be interesting.
As I got out of my car, Sara Anne looked at me for any signs. But I gave her none, just my warm, loving self.
"Hey baby, why the personal greeting?"
That caught her off guard. "Uhhh, I was worried about you after you got sick last night. I was so worried I came home a couple of hours later and found you upstairs hugging the trash can. I found it this morning, and you had used it, so you must have been sick."
"I told you I was. I wouldn't have left our special party or given up a hot night with my sexy wife otherwise. Did you think I was making that up?"
"Oh no, that's not what I meant. I was, ohhhhh God, I don't know what I meant. Sorry, I didn't sleep well last night."
"I am sorry. I would have thought after all your activity and excitement at the party; you would have been worn out. That is why I suggest you stay at the hotel and sleep in.
"Why did you come home?"
The look on her face was priceless. Confused, she struggled with my comment on the party's activity and excitement.
Once inside, I put the groceries in the fridge and pulled out a beer. It was strange; Sara Anne was following my every move expecting some wrath to come spewing out about her cheating, and it was clear my behavior had her totally confused. Perfect!!
I leaned back against the island and sipped my beer.
"So, Sara, did you have fun at the party? I thought it was an ingenious idea. I tried to find you but never did. Did you try to find me? I had no idea who anybody was, and when I got sick and left, I missed all the reveals. I bet that was exciting. Who was there that we knew?"
Sara Anne looked at me with surprise on her face. She saw me act completely normal like I didn't know anything had happened. I am sure Sara Anne wondered if I really did know that she had fucked Terrance. She was very confused, and I liked her being like that!
"Well, it was interesting, and I had a fun time. I did look for you, but I never did find you. Who were you?"
"Oh no, I'll never tell! You will just have to wonder. Will you tell me who you were?"
"No, not if you won't tell me."
"OK then, a stalemate we will never know, will we."
"You know the rules made the night more interesting. Especially the Free Night rule was supposed to be like a Hall Pass or something. Do what you want, with whoever you want, and all will be forgiven in the morning. Well, some people took that to heart. I saw many people fucking throughout the night in several of the bedrooms, and I am sure they were not fucking the spouses but someone else. "
"In one room, I saw Marie Antoinette fucking a guy. Then a little later, I saw her fucking another guy again, or it may have been the same guy again for the second time. I don't remember. The first time they were with George Washington, I'm not sure who, but they were both fucking on the same bed. That was pretty kinky. I am so glad I am not her husband."
I saw her breathing catch in Sara Anna's throat when I mentioned her costume and me not being her husband. She didn't know if I had looked in the box or not and she knew The Phantom had seen her. That threw her off. She got nervous and ran from the room to the bathroom.
I quickly followed. The door slammed, and I heard Sara Anne puking in the toilet. Boy, I must have hit a nerve. This had become a lot of fun for me and pure hell for Sara Anne, which she deserved.
I went back to the kitchen and waited. I finished my beer, got out another one, popped it open, and took a gulp. I got out the steaks and wanted to marinade them, so I poured Dale's marinade into a plastic bag and added the filets, and I covered them completely and put them back in the fridge.
I turned and saw Sara Anne watching me. I heard her return but ignored her as I worked on the food.
"Oh baby, are you OK? Maybe you should have stayed at the hotel, and you may have that same thing I got last night and deep pain in my gut. It hurt me so bad that I just had to leave the party, and I couldn't face people how I felt."
I was laying it on thick now, and it was really making Sara feel sick. She had turned an ash-white color.
"Sara Anne, you don't look good. You should lie down and sleep some. I'll get you a cold rag for your head." I took her arm and guided her down the hall to the guest room. You should probably stay in here until this all clears up. That way, I don't get it again."
The look on her face was pure fear and confusion. I laid her on the bed, pulled the duvet over her, and put a damp rag on her forehead. I kissed her cheek and walked away, stopping at the door. I looked back and saw a look of panic on her face now, not knowing what to do.
"Sleep now. Feel better. We have an anniversary to celebrate tonight because we couldn't last night. I need you well so we can do this up right. I love you, so please get over whatever has made you sick."
Her eyes filled with tears. I knew I had destroyed her for now, and it was my job to build her back up again.
I turned and closed the door. I stood outside, hearing Sara Anne start to sob.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I was so confused, and my nerves were like lightning bolts shooting through me. These were not good feelings and were horrible and confusing to me.
Did Andrew know, or didn't he? Was he The Phantom or not? If he wasn't, there was no way to learn what the black and white mask was doing in his underwear drawer. So many questions and no answers. The one thing I did know was Andrew had seen me fucking Terrance though he didn't think it was me.
It was like history repeating itself in real life. Marie Antoinette lost her head after a horrible relationship with the French people, and I could lose my married life over a cheating relationship with Terrance.
Fuck I was so stupid to ever start with Terrance.
It started on Wednesday afternoon. We had a staff meeting, and everyone was sent home early. A few weeks before, I had become part of Terrance's admin team as the Lead Closing Agent, reporting directly to him. I handled all the arrangements for contract closings. I worked for the company for three years, and my promotion was well deserved. I didn't know Terrance well, but I had become more involved with him over the previous months before my promotion. We had a cordial relationship.
On that Wednesday, he invited me and three others to have a drink to celebrate my addition to his team and my promotion. It was innocent enough.
I texted Andrew.
My text: "We broke early from our staff meeting, and Terrance and a few others invited me for a drink to celebrate my joining their team and my promotion. I will be home a little late."
Andrew's text: "Yes, enjoy yourself, bond with your new team members. Love you.
My text: "OK, I won't be too late. Love you too. Warm the bed for me."
Andrew's text: "I'll be waiting for you."
Five of us went for a drink at a new club. It was beautiful inside, with white tablecloths and shiny decor. It was pretty dark, so that you wouldn't have known it was only 4:00 pm. We had a few drinks and danced some.
As time passed, the other two women had to leave to get home to their kids. That left James, my counterpart, Terrance, and me. They were both single. I decided I could stay till 6:30 but had to go then, so I told them.
We danced a lot, and as I was the only woman, I was being shared every few dances.
I was enjoying myself and the time slipped away. James had a date, so he left, leaving Terrence and me. I looked at my watch; it was almost 6:30. I knew I needed to go.
I told Terrance I had to go, and he begged me to stay and have dinner with him. Part of me wanted to stay, and part wanted to go home and go to bed with Andrew.
"Terrance, only if it is OK with Andrew." I texted Andrew.
My text: They want to have dinner. Is that, OK? I promise not to be home past 9:30, OK?"
Andrew's text: "I guess that will be OK. I am lying here waiting for a long hard surprise for you. Don't be late."
Oh God, I was instantly wet and turned on thinking of Andrews's big hard cock.
I stayed, and we had a nice dinner. We talked about each other, and our backgrounds and things got a little more personal than I thought.
Terrance was an intriguing man. He had never married, and he was a confirmed bachelor. Terrance liked women and played the field. He had a big house with every amenity a man could want. He offered to have us over some time to see it. I liked him.
We danced several slow dances, and each became more personal. Terrance held me tight, and I let him. His body was hard, all of him, and I could feel it. I was already excited about Andrew, so Terrance was feeding my desire.
I went to the lady's room and looked at myself in the mirror. I looked hot and horny, and I knew I needed to leave. It was almost 9:00 pm, and I promised to be home by 9:30.
As I walked out, Terrance took my purse, dropped it on the chair, and pulled me onto the dance floor. He pulled me to him, and I felt his hardness press against me. He was just over 6' and fits with me at 5'7". The music was a classic, Barry White lust-filled song made for lovers. At that moment, I melted into Terrance's arms, laying my head against his chest.
We started to grind against each other. I spread my legs, riding against his thigh, as I felt Terrance's hard cock rubbing against my hip bone. The song ended, but we didn't. Then we realized the music had stopped. We separated and looked at each other.
My thoughts of Andrew disappeared for a fleeting moment. God, I was so horny I wanted to fuck Terrance right there on the dance floor for everyone to see.
But just as fast as that thought appeared, it disappeared. I looked at my watch. "Oh, Shit!" I blurted out! I panicked, it was 9:20, and I had a twenty-minute drive home.
"I have to go. I told Andrew I would be home by 9:30, and I will never make it."
"Please don't leave. We were having a great time together."
"Yes, but I have a husband and need to get home. I will see you tomorrow."
I raced out the door leaving Terrance standing there. I cursed myself for letting him dance with me that way. I cursed myself all the way home.
I got home, as horny as I had ever been. Andrew was in bed, and the sheet was barely covering him, propped up on a couple of pillows, with the TV muted, and Andrew was asleep.
I slipped into the bathroom and took a quick shower to be fresh for my husband. I didn't want him to smell Terrance on me. As I was washing, the shower door opened, and my beautiful husband stepped in. He pulled me to him, and we kissed. It was magical. His cock hardened quickly. I went to my knees, taking him in my mouth and feeding on him like a starving animal.
The hot water rained on me as I took his big hard cock deep in my throat. As I sucked, flashes of what Terrance's cock would feel like in my mouth made me shudder. Those were bad thoughts.
I stroked Andrew as I sucked his cock head. He put his hand against the wall, spread his feet, and started slowly fucking my mouth. I love it when he takes control and uses my mouth for pleasure, as with my other holes.
I stroked him as he fucked my mouth faster and faster. We were coordinated until Andrew started breathing hard and slammed into my throat one last time, tensing up as his balls in my hand tightened, and he shot three, four, five ropes of cum down my throat. I pulled back, keeping his head in my mouth as I sucked hard on him, making him groan.
"Oh, Fuck baby, you make me cum so hard! Take the last of it!"
The last weak salvos landed on my tongue, and I held them there as I let his cock out of my mouth with a loud pop. I stood and turned off the water. I looked at Andrew and opened my mouth, showing him the remainder of his offering. I slipped my tongue out, cupping it. Andrew opened his mouth and slid his tongue out. I rolled my tongue, letting the cum slip onto his tongue. Then we kissed as our tongues slithered together, playing with his cum.
My fingers were in my pussy, fucking myself, while my other hand gripped his cock, coaxing him hard again. We broke the kiss looking deep into each other's lust-filled eyes. Andrew spun around and pushed me over, so my hands rested against the wall. I gasped as his hard cock pushed deep into me and frantically fucked me, pounding his cock into my cunt like a jackhammer. I started to cum and came hard as each stroke slapped against my ass. I kept on cumming and cumming I lost control, surrendering completely to him.
I squeezed my eyes shut, and my mind whirled as an image of Terrance taking Andrew's place flashed through my mind. I came again as hard as ever. "Oh God, yes, fuck me, baby, fuck me." At that moment, I was unsure who I was urging on, Andrew or Terrance. Either one was fine; I just needed a big hard cock!
Finally, my knees buckled, and I slipped to the floor. Andrew stood over me, stroking his cock, and sprayed hot creamy cum all over my naked body.
"Take my cum, bitch! You are a fucking slut!"
I was shocked. Andrew had never talked like that to me.
I was consumed as my fingers began strumming my clit, flashing over it at rocket speed. I was cumming over and over. The pleasure was so intense I slipped back on the floor, fainting away.
The water sprayed on me again, washing all the cum away. I came too and lay there feeling the afterglow of the most incredible fucking I had ever had.
Andrew was on the floor with me, washing me, then cuddled under the hot water. God, this is what real love is. I was so happy.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
We were lying on the shower floor, recovering. My balls were empty, and Sara Anne's pussy was full of my cum, claiming her pussy back from Terrance. I don't play that cuckold game, but it was necessary to do this. It will settle Sara Anne down and relieve some of her concerns.
We sat up, kissed, then stood up. I pulled Sara Anne to me, walked her trembling body out of the shower, and dried her off. I pulled her to the bed and pushed her on, following her. She giggled and playfully flipped onto her back, and I was on her, and we kissed.
"Wow, that was amazing Andrew. What was all the nasty talk about?
"I was caught in the moment. I thought about you being out with your coworkers, and I bet you were flirting with the guys after drinking. So, who was with you and Terrance for dinner?"
Sara Anne looked at me and whispered, "It was just Terrance and me. All the others had to go home."
"Oh, I see, so I was not important enough for you to leave and come home like the others? When you texted me, you said, 'they want me to stay for dinner,' but there was no they, was there?"
Sara Anne dropped her head, shaking it, "NO, just Terrance and me."
"So, what was that about? Did it take you three and a half hours to eat dinner, or was there more?"
"Oh, Andrew, it was nothing. He was interesting, and I wanted to get to know him better. We had dinner, and then we danced a few dances." Sara Anne didn't want to tell me that, but she had to. She has never lied to me, at least not so far.
"You danced with him? You were getting to know him better. So, how much better did you get to know him?" I was after her now, and that had really pissed me off. I was waiting at home to make love to her, and she was dancing with another man, FUCK!
Sara Anne was struggling to try to answer my question. Just because there was a long pause, I knew more had happened.
"Andrew, we just danced. There were some slow dances, and he did hold me tight against him. I am sorry, but I did respond a little and pressed back against him. I couldn't help it. I was excited about coming home to you, and he was comfortable. I knew it was wrong, so I left and came home. I am so sorry. It meant nothing. As I drove home, I knew I should never have allowed it to get as far as it did. It will never happen again. Please forgive me for being stupid."
I could tell Sara Anne was sorry that she had let her guard down, letting Terrance affect her decisions. That concerned me, and Terrance had seen he could influence her, so now she must be careful.
She was sorry and caught in the moment. I had to make sure she would never let that happen again.
"Sara, I love you; I was waiting here to make love to you all night if you wanted, and you chose to be with someone else, expecting me to be waiting for you when you got home.
"Knowing that hurts me badly. The thought that after all our time together, you would choose to be with another man, not with me, is shocking. I guess I don't know you as well as I thought."
I stopped and looked at her with no emotion.
"OH NO, Andrew, it's not like that. I love you and only you. I want to be with you and only you. I let a simple drink turn into something that should never have happened. I am so sorry. Please, Please, forgive me. I am such a fool!" Sara Anne began to sob, leaning against me.
I let her lie against me but did not attempt to comfort her. She looked at me and fell back on the bed, curling up and sobbing.
I got up, put on a robe, turned off the light, and closed the door. As I walked down the hall, I heard Sara Anne weakly beg, "Andrew, please don't leave me."
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I had made a monumental mistake. I had given in to my boss staying with him for dinner, and then we danced, and I was grinding against him. I gave him the wrong message and had forsaken my husband. I was so stupid.
As I lay there, Andrew walked out and closed the door leaving me in the dark. I was confused about my attraction to Terrance. I love my husband with my whole self, but if I am honest, there was something about Terrance that had held me there tonight.
My thoughts of him even now, especially with my husband in the house, made me feel tingly. My pussy was wet from Andrew, but new wetness grew as I thought about Terrance.
That scared me. I had to see Terrance every day at work, and I had to work on projects right beside him. I may have to travel away with him, just the two of us. Oh God, how could I make this work without cheating on my husband?
I was shaking now. I pulled the sheet up over me and finally fell asleep.
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
I was genuinely concerned about what had happened tonight. I knew Terrance was a real threat to us. Sara Anne was very attracted to him, or she would have left when the others did. The fact that she had stayed for dinner with Terrance instead of rushing home to our bed was a real worry to me.
I really couldn't do much. I had to trust Sara Anne to figure out how to make it work, or she would have to quit her job. She had worked so hard to rise to her position she would not want to quit.