Quote by stephanie
Totally (kinda) off-topic...
Of course, Time Machines don't really exist. Although I did once date a girl who over-dosed on the Morning-After pill and woke up in 1865.
(You can have that one!)
xx SF
Quote by Buz
What if all of you got transported except your penis?
Quote by RejectReality
The person who has done the time-traveling is always going to be out of sync. If they're not at least reflecting on the differences between their time period and the one where they are, then what's the point of it being time-travel at all? Once you start doing that, the focus isn't on the past, it's on the sci-fi aspects.
The only way I see it remaining focused on the past is if the time-traveler isn't the POV character, and the time-travel aspects only appear at the end as a twist. BTTF 3 told from Clara's perspective.
Quote by NymphWriter
Please note... I never said anything about time machines (someone else said that.) I asked about time-travel. I never said HOW it would occur. It could be an enchanted piece of clothing, a special stone, a doorway, a vortex, a wormhole, or a hundred other things.
Quote by NymphWriter
You are making assumptions on stories that have yet to be written. I asked if it could be possible, but you and a few others seem to be all hung up on the time traveling element and nothing else. I've read a few stories where this plot device of getting them into the past is quickly dealt with and then... the rest of the story is about their being in the past. They don't have any "modern technology" screwing things up from the past nor do they do anything that makes it obvious they are from the future because the character (and the writer) are not idiots.
Please note... I never said anything about time machines (someone else said that.) I asked about time-travel. I never said HOW it would occur. It could be an enchanted piece of clothing, a special stone, a doorway, a vortex, a wormhole, or a hundred other things. And sure... it could be the twist at the ending too. So... I guess what I'm saying is before you completely shoot down an idea... you know what the person is talking about. A few others understood my idea... my thought.
I also know Nicola has the final say. If she says no... then it's over and I'll move on. It was a suggestion about an element within this potential new category. Nothing more.
Quote by stephanie
How we COMPLICATE things...
Here's my![]()
I think that a Time Travel story COULD, (if obviously taking place in the past...) be posted under HISTORICAL. That is, IF THE OBVIOUS ACCENT OF THE STORY CONCERNS HISTORICAL DETAIL RATHER THAN THE MECHANICS (?) OF THE TIME TRAVEL PROCESS ITSELF...
Indeed, if THAT SAME STORY were posted in Sci-Fi it might disappoint readers who were looking for a more of a WILLIAM GIBSON hit... (Look it up!)
(A TIME TRAVEL story set IN THE FUTURE is SCI-FI, NO QUESTION!)
Ultimately and AS ALWAYS if there is a QUESTION about category placement it will be resolved by the experienced and capable Mod Team who do that sort of thing every day.
(So WE don't have to worry our talented little heads about it!!!) All WE have to do is WRITE.
Thank you. I am STEPHEN, VOICE OF REASON...
(Available for After Dinner speeches...)
xx SF
Quote by stephanie
How we COMPLICATE things...
Here's my![]()
I think that a Time Travel story COULD, (if obviously taking place in the past...) be posted under HISTORICAL. That is, IF THE OBVIOUS ACCENT OF THE STORY CONCERNS HISTORICAL DETAIL RATHER THAN THE MECHANICS (?) OF THE TIME TRAVEL PROCESS ITSELF...
Indeed, if THAT SAME STORY were posted in Sci-Fi it might disappoint readers who were looking for a more of a WILLIAM GIBSON hit... (Look it up!)
(A TIME TRAVEL story set IN THE FUTURE is SCI-FI, NO QUESTION!)
Ultimately and AS ALWAYS if there is a QUESTION about category placement it will be resolved by the experienced and capable Mod Team who do that sort of thing every day. (So WE don't have to worry our talented little heads about it!!!) All WE have to do is WRITE.
Thank you. I am STEPHEN, VOICE OF REASON...
(Available for After Dinner speeches...)
xx SF
Quote by Magical_felix
Okay so what about a story where Joan of Arc travels through a worm hole in the back of a church and ends up in 2015. The story would be about her, a historic figure and not really about the time machine... We'll just call the wormhole a miracle. By the power of a miracle she travels through time.
Or better yet how about Joan of Arc uses miraculous time travel to see where she will be captured by the english and avoids burning at the stake and instead goes and loses her virginity somewhere? Would this story go under Historic? Or would that now be fantasy?
Remember that the category is Fantasy & Sci-Fi. Not just Sci-fi. Or would miracles be considered supernatural? Because that's a category too.
A writer could argue that if a modern day person traveling back in time counts as historic than a historical figure traveling to our time should count too if the main character is the historic figure.
Quote by Magical_felix
Okay so what about a story where Joan of Arc travels through a worm hole in the back of a church and ends up in 2015. The story would be about her, a historic figure and not really about the time machine... We'll just call the wormhole a miracle. By the power of a miracle she travels through time.
Or better yet how about Joan of Arc uses miraculous time travel to see where she will be captured by the English and avoids burning at the stake and instead goes and loses her virginity somewhere? Would this story go under Historic? Or would that now be fantasy?
Remember that the category is Fantasy & Sci-Fi. Not just Sci-fi. Or would miracles be considered supernatural? Because that's a category too.
A writer could argue that if a modern day person traveling back in time counts as historic than a historical figure traveling to our time should count too if the main character is the historic figure.
You can’t truly call yourself peaceful unless you are capable of violence. If you’re not capable of violence, you’re not peaceful. You’re harmless.
Quote by Magical_felix
Okay so what about a story where Joan of Arc travels through a worm hole in the back of a church and ends up in 2015. The story would be about her, a historic figure and not really about the time machine... We'll just call the wormhole a miracle. By the power of a miracle she travels through time.
That's Supernatural/FANTASY/Sci-Fi by virtue of the fact that the PRIMARY ACCENT of the piece IS NOT HISTORICAL.
Or better yet how about Joan of Arc uses miraculous time travel to see where she will be captured by the English and avoids burning at the stake and instead goes and loses her virginity somewhere? Would this story go under Historic? Or would that now be fantasy?
AGAIN that's fantasy BECAUSE THE PRIMARY ACCENT OF THE IDEA is NOT historical but Supernatural/FANTASTICAL.
Remember that the category is Fantasy & Sci-Fi. Not just Sci-fi. Or would miracles be considered supernatural? Because that's a category too.
Miracles go under SUPERNATURAL/Fantasy/Sci-Fi.
A writer could argue that if a modern day person traveling back in time counts as historic than a historical figure traveling to our time should count too if the main character is the historic figure.
Incorrect. The IMPLICATION of an HISTORIC category is that we are dealing with a time that is PRE-NOW... Anything else again is Supernatural/Fantasy/Sci-Fi...
Good Will ---|--- Three Alarm <= Both almost famous, give them a read and get them one step closer!
Quote by RavenStar
Fantasy for sure. Miracles aren't necessarily fantasy but so far, time travel is. Also, by historical definition, it is a fantasy that Joan of Arc did any time traveling.
Quote by stephanie
Don't FUCK with me Hun I'm really good at this...
(They didn't FIRE me because I'm shit, Jack!!!) *LAUGHS!*
xx SF
Quote by Magical_felix
(Just copying and pasting my response to RavenStar because I knew you would say fantasy, I think it's fantasy as well.)
I agree, it's fantasy.
On the flip side of the coin, logic would say that anyone traveling to the past is also a fantasy. So let's say the story is about a time traveller that by whatever plot device you want - a miracle, a time machine, fairy stones or whatever - wakes up during Joan of Arc's campaign against the English. Let's say the whole story takes place in the past but the traveller is definitely from our time. The fact that he is from our time definitely has to come in to play at one point during the story or else what is the point of the time travel? Maybe he warns Joan about her capture? Maybe he knows modern military strategy? Maybe he teaches her that the men of the future like to eat a girl's ass? Something. Something will have to come into play to justify the time travel element.
Now is that historic? Or is that fantasy?
Quote by stephanie
The FACT that the story is MAINLY CONCERNED with a PAST historical situation and setting cites the story in the THE HISTORICAL CATEGORY.
Quote by sprite
where are Bill and Ted when you need them?
Quote by Magical_felix
But so was my example of Joan of Arc traveling in time within the dates of her English campaign but you called that fantasy. That story is mainly concerned with a past historical situation and setting. That story would have even less of the present day in it because there wouldn't even be a time traveller from our time in it. Everything would be as you say, concerning the past but you called it fantasy.
Paradox... The scourge of time travel plots.
Quote by stephanie
Let's try this again...
IF WE ARE TALKING PRIMARILY ABOUT Joan of Arc travelling in time and then changing her own history then we are in the realms of fantasy.
(It's NOT ROCKET SCIENCE!)
Think about it?
(The FOCUS then is NOT on the historic setting but on Joan's FANTASTICAL journey in order to CHANGE her own history and so then the ACCENT is surely on that element?)
This is frankly a sophistic argument... (Tell them, Liz...)
xx SF
Quote by Magical_felix
On the flip side of the coin, logic would say that anyone traveling to the past is also a fantasy. So let's say the story is about a time traveller that by whatever plot device you want - a miracle, a time machine, fairy stones or whatever - wakes up during Joan of Arc's campaign against the English. Let's say the whole story takes place in the past but the traveller is definitely from our time. The fact that he is from our time definitely has to come in to play at one point during the story or else what is the point of the time travel? Maybe he warns Joan about her capture? Maybe he knows modern military strategy? Maybe he teaches her that the men of the future like to eat a girl's ass? Something. Something will have to come into play to justify the time travel element.
Now is that historic? Or is that fantasy?
Quote by stephanie
The FACT that the story is MAINLY CONCERNED with a PAST historical situation and setting cites the story in the THE HISTORICAL CATEGORY.
Quote by stephanie
This is frankly a sophistic argument...
Quote by nicola
Is everyone high or on something today? I guess it is Saturday ... Personally, I'm enjoying a rather crafy Pinot Noir.
![]()
Quote by Magical_felix
I will be indulging in a decent red blend in about 5 hours... After that time travel will no longer be discussed. Time travel and paradoxes make my brain confused.
Quote by stephanie
VALID POINT... Let's look ONCE AGAIN at the nuance of category.
The FACT that the story is MAINLY CONCERNED with a PAST historical situation and setting cites the story in the THE HISTORICAL CATEGORY.
Story Mods do this every day... It's NUANCE... (Erotic Poem or Love Poem???) They call it and in my time and indeed in my experience since, 99.9% of the time that crew call it right.
xx SF
*EDIT!* *GIGGLE!*
Good Will ---|--- Three Alarm <= Both almost famous, give them a read and get them one step closer!
Quote by NymphWriter
There are stories all over this site that can be classified as fantasy, sci-fi, supernatural, BDSM, and much more but the AUTHOR chose to put it where he/she did. No one questions these stories and why they are where they are at. We saw this challenge with the amazing This is Hardcore comp we just had not too long ago. There were many debates about what was hardcore & what was more BDSM. I'm sure some of the stories could easily fit in either category without a problem.
Yet... have some minor time travel and it seems everyone looses their shit. Okay... not everyone... but damn.
Steph hit the nail on the head when he said these are NUANCES. If you get so hung up on one minor plot device... then you've got a bigger problem. Someone earlier said if the story focus was about someone "fucking Cleopatra"... then it would work. If someone went to change the past... it would not. If your hang-up is how they got there... let the authorz... and maybe the Mod who takes the time to verify the story address that. Not some critic.
Quote by RejectReality
I'm honestly not trying to be a dick. This is a feedback thread about creating a new category, and I'm just trying to articulate my opinion on it.
I don't see the need to muddy up the waters of a Historical category with Sci-Fi&Fantasy when there are already two categories for those stories.