Quote by Lynkeus
Today is the 80th birthday of the great director Martin Scorsese.
A reason to remember that Scorsese made 4 of his greatest films in equal partnership with his screenwriter (and director himself!) Paul Schrader.
Well - via the detour Scorsese/ Schrader I get to what I actually wanted to remind you of:
This same Paul Schrader published his now classic essay "Notes on film noir" in 1972 - and that's also a 50th anniversary!
Above all, I would have wished that one or the other of our authors would have taken a look at the text before hastily submitting their story to the Noir Erotique competition... 😉
Just a small sample:
"Film noir is not a genre (...) It is not defined, as are the western and gangster genres, by conventions of setting and conflict, but rather by the more subtle qualities of tone and mood."
"There is a love of romantic narration. (...) the narration creates a mood of temps perdu: an irretrievable past, a predetermined fate and an all-enveloping hopelessness. (...) one can only take pleasure in reliving a doomed past."
I think Schrader is very limited in his definition of Noir.. specifically in terms of time and geography. Also, you are quoting notes on Film Noir.
While you note "There is a love of romantic narration", the essay also notes
The majority of scenes are lit for night.
As in German expressionism, oblique and vertical lines are preferred to horizontal.
The actors and setting are often given equal lighting emphasis.
Compositional tension is preferred to physical action.
These are all cinematic conventions. I think it would be a very dull competition if everyone set their story in the United States between the late 1940s and the late 1950s.