Quote by armagnac
If a fictional story written by me makes an impact on someone and triggers a certain sequence of physical events, then my writing becomes a "material force" whether intended or unintended.
For example, I write a steamy sex scene and someone gets inspired enough to proceed to have an intercourse with his/her spouse to their mutual satisfaction. Do I deserve a credit for providing that inspiration?
Let's now assume that I write a story on sex, jealousy and betrayal that somehow hurts an emotionally sensitive person. Although I may not be responsible for that person's actions, but hurting is real. Do I bear any responsibility for that hurting?
The answer could be "Yes" to both or "No" to both.
For example.
"Yes and I should never write anything anytime anywhere," or
"Yes and I do not care about someone getting screwed as a result of my writing,"
or just plain "No."
In sum, this is a matter of personal choice.
Q.E.D.
As with everything he writes, I think Armagnac’s observation is on the money. When a reader, here or elsewhere, says they were moved/excited/challenged by something we’ve written, we happily take the credit for that. What could be more thrilling for a writer than to hear that your words have purchase in the mind of another? Earned praise is a pleasure to own.
True, we are only partial owners of those experiences. The *right readers* are willing (some more than others) to play along with a story. We don’t inject our stories into passive readers with a hypodermic needle. They have to work with us: filling in whatever open spaces we leave, suspending disbelief, curating their own experience or imagination to complement and amplify what they’re reading. Good readers earn whatever pleasure they take in your writing.
“Erotica” can mean a lot of things to a lot of people. I was fired up, when I found this site, to dive in and read all the genres that get my motor cranking (wife lovers, swingers, cuckold, etc.). The keys in many of those stories happen to fit many of the locks in my fantasy world, so I’m very happy to explore alongside those authors. I very often ponder, though, the psychology of my obsessions. So many of my fantasies require me to push through a membrane of pain. Why not fantasize about something less conflicted?
And I guess that brings me back to Kimmi’s question. When I write about my fantasies, I play with my own pleasure and my own pain. When I publish those stories, I invite myself to play with and alongside others’ pleasure…and their pain. The “right readers” will know how and where and how much to safely and pleasurably add their own pain in the mix. But the unprepared, or unlucky, might find a key that unlocks the door to the wrong pain—the first awful betrayal, the deep wound, the true fear. Would I ever intend to hurt them? No. Did I create their pain? Of course not. Did I hand them the right key for the wrong lock? Yes. I did.
I like your question (and your follow up) because it doesn’t blame the reader for their own found pain (even if pain makes them blame you). I like it because we live in a time that is tragically devoid of soul-searching. But I’ve read a fair amount of your work, and many others in this thread, and I mostly like the way you write to explore your own mind(s). We all know exploration can reveal terrible things. Especially when we’re looking for them. But exploration has revealed every good thing we know.
[sorry if I’m blathering. My internal moderator has the night off.]