It might also mean that a lot of the readers are people who are not members of the site. Your settings may only allow for members to vote and certainly only members can comment.
If you really want more feedback, try a bit of advertising. Sure, mass e-mails are annoying but for every 9 people who throw your message in the trash, one might actually read your story. Stick a link in your forum signature and post lots here. In general, stay active on the site and get your name out there.
I've been on this site for a year and am pretty well-known (fair to say?) but I still struggle to get a lot of people to read my stuff and give feedback on it.
Perseverance!
Your profile says that you're single...
When I grow up, I want to be...
A househusband!
Seriously.
What are your big three's:
Me:
Three things I could do without:
1. Paying rent.
2. Unionists.
3. Facebook.
Three movies I want you to see:
1. Snatch
2. Sliding Doors
3. La Vie En Rose
Three things to fulfil a day.
1. Sleep.
2. Fun.
3. Fresh air.
Three people who changed my life:
1. My boss when I was a youth worker.
2. Nichiren Daishonin
3. My girlfriend.
For the record, none of the examples come from my own work. They were all made up arbitrarily as I was writing. I'm not saying they're good but they're typical of the things I see a lot in stories and so I thought they would be relatable.
Looking back over the Ethan Blake stories I have written, there are very few exclamation marks and all of them in dialogue. I never use more than one and I do not use the interrobang in my writing.
Aunt Julia by Norman MacCaig
Aunt Julia spoke Gaelic
very loud and very fast.
I could not answer her —
I could not understand her.
She wore men's boots
when she wore any.
— I can see her strong foot,
stained with peat,
paddling with the treadle of the spinningwheel
while her right hand drew yarn
marvellously out of the air.
Hers was the only house
where I've lain at night
in a box bed, listening to
crickets being friendly.
She was buckets
and water flouncing into them.
She was winds pouring wetly
round house-ends.
She was brown eggs, black skirts
and a keeper of threepennybits
in a teapot.
Aunt Julia spoke Gaelic
very loud and very fast.
By the time I had learned
a little, she lay
silenced in the absolute black
of a sandy grave
at Luskentyre.
But I hear her still, welcoming me
with a seagull's voice
across a hundred yards
of peatscrapes and lazybeds
and getting angry, getting angry
with so many questions
unanswered.
Maybe not my favourite but certainly a good'n and the first I thought of.
Are you allowed to have three Scottish people posting in a row like this? Och, we'll just see what happens.
His profile is a very interesting read and his cat ears are enviable. Plus, he's Scottish.
Okay, I know I'm becoming a pain in the arse now but...
With the motivation being to not have stories appear on the front page for a day and then disappear into the abyss, never to be rated or commented on again, how about some sort of historical stories feature.
This could take the form of, 'On This Day in Year Dot', and have a link to all the stories posted on that date. Or you could, say, the top 20 stories that were posted in the same month as the current one but from previous years, like 'May's Finest'.
I just feel like if your story isn't EP standard, but still good, and you don't have hundreds of friends, it can be difficult to get anyone to read older work. Any variation on this theme would help.