Join the best erotica focused adult social network now
Login

Love, Hate, Indifference

"When honesty goes too far"

67
14 Comments 14
2.3k Views 2.3k
2.5k words 2.5k words
Recommended Read

Author's Notes

"They say the opposite of love isn't hate, it's indifference. But they never tell you how you get there."

I found out about the affair in a way that people don't write stories about.

It wasn't a lipstick on the collar, a text that popped up during dinner, or a neighbor dropping hints over the fence. It wasn't a grand confrontation, no shouting under the moon, no dramatic throwing of clothes into the street. It was smaller, like a splinter you can't see but feel every time you move.

It started on a Tuesday morning, in a therapist's office that smelled like lavender oil and stale coffee. We were there for us, or so I thought, to fix the slow leak we'd both felt in our marriage. It had been six years, and I told myself that six years is too short to give up, even if we felt like we were in separate apartments with a shared kitchen.

Mara sat across from me, twisting a silver ring on her finger, the one I'd given her in a cabin on a rainy October day when we'd both believed this was forever. She had that look, the one that told me she was building up to something. Her eyes were swollen from the tears she'd shed before we left the house, and she wouldn't look at me.

The therapist was a soft-spoken woman named Carla, who wore flowing skirts and nodded like she understood every secret the world contained.

"I think there's something I need to say," Mara whispered.

And then she did. She didn't say it all at once, but in fragments, like broken glass on the floor. It was a name first, then a timeline, then the word affair like it was an apology in itself. She had been seeing someone else, for three years. Not just seeing, but loving, she said. Not just loving, but doing things with him that she never did with me.

It was that last part that broke me.

I always believed that if she ever cheated, I'd leave. That's what we tell ourselves, right? That we're strong enough to walk away, that we won't be the fool who stays. But when you're sitting in a chair you've sunk into for forty minutes already, when your wife's tears are falling into her lap, when her hand reaches out for yours and you pull away, the world doesn't feel as clear-cut.

My first question was not "Why?" or "Who?" but "What did you do with him?"

I don't know why I asked that. Maybe I thought if it was just sex, it would hurt less. Maybe I thought if I knew, I could measure the betrayal, contain it. But it wasn't just sex, and it wasn't something I could contain.

She didn't want to tell me. But therapy is about honesty, she said, and so she told me.

They went on trips I didn't know about, under the pretext of work. She said she tried to break it off many times but didn't know how. He made her feel alive, she said, and that was like acid poured onto an old wound I didn't know was open.

And the details. God, the details. She told me she did things with him that she never did with me, things I had asked for, gently, over the years, that she had always declined, telling me she wasn't comfortable, telling me it wasn't her. Anal, threesomes with both two men and two women - never with protection, she even told me that she regularly gave him a rim job. It was as though my wife had been replaced by a third-rate porn star- desperate for validation and clinging to sex as her only self worth. I felt ridiculous because when she'd denied me I believed her, and I respected her boundaries, because I loved her, and I wanted her to feel safe with me. Silly me.

She did those things with him. The telling of the acts didn't hurt the most, it was the why. She said she didn't want to feel judged... by me... her husband. I'd wiped her ass after a back surgery but she had just confessed that she could never do those things with me because I was on a god damned pedestal.

I left therapy that day without saying a word. I got into the car, turned on the engine, and sat there while the air conditioning blasted into my face, trying to drown out the heat rising in my chest. I don't even remember what was on the radio; it wasn't on my usual NPR but one of her ridiculous country stations playing hard knocks songs by guys whose only interaction with hard work was passing the Kubota display at the local hardware store.

I sat in the car, nursing the last bit of self-respect with a lip full of Skoal - I told her I'd quit but always snuck one every now and then. Now I didn't care. She came out a few minutes later, her eyes pleading, but I couldn't look at her.

"We need to talk," she said.

"I can't," I replied, and drove off.

I went to a diner, ordered coffee I didn't drink, and watched people outside live their ordinary lives. A mother with a toddler, a couple holding hands, a man walking his dog. All those people, unaware that my world had just fallen apart in a lavender-scented room.

She tried to call me. She texted, Please, please, we need to talk. She came home that night to find me sitting on the floor, the ring box in my hand, the same one I had used to propose to her six years ago. She knelt beside me, tried to touch me, but I pulled away.

"I'm so sorry," she sobbed. "I don't know why I did it. I love you. I love you so much."

I wanted to scream at her. I wanted to ask how she could say she loved me when she had given parts of herself to another man for three years.

"You did things with him you wouldn't do with me," I whispered.

She cried harder.

"It wasn't about you," she said, over and over, as if that was supposed to make it better.

But it was about me. It was about us. It was about every time I had looked at her and thought we were okay. It was about every time she cut our conversations short to answer a text. About every time she'd been more honest about her wants and needs with someone other than me.

I didn't leave immediately.

That's another thing they don't tell you about infidelity. It's not always instant. Sometimes, it's a slow unraveling, a careful dismantling of a life you built together. Fundamentally, leaving your old life takes time.

I slept in the guest room that night. I don't know why but I was hard as a rock. I masturbated thinking about her doing all of things she'd done with others that she'd never do with me. I didn't last long. In the post-nut clarity, my cum staining the sheets, I felt lower than ever.

The next morning she came in before I was awake. I stirred, feeling like I needed to pee only to discover her head bobbing on my cock. She was taking me all the way down her throat, gagging, every so often stopping to rim me - something she'd never done before. I wanted to cum so badly. Instead I reached down and lifted her head off. She slid up me slowly, making sure she brushed her ample cleavage up the length of my body. She tried to kiss me but I pushed her off and rolled her over. I slid the full length of my eight inches into her. She was soaked so I went in effortlessly. I pumped hard and fast for several minutes - no love, just rage fucking her as hard as I could.

FerKitty
Online Now!
Lush Cams
FerKitty

She made sounds she'd never made before and her mouth was pure filth. "Fuck me with that big cock, motherfucker! Cream this pussy! Fuck me like the slut I am!" That last one got me.

I pulled out and plunged into her ass. She's didn't cry out - apparently she was accustomed to anal, just not with me. She kept taking it, letting her expansive sexual vocabulary flow freely. She always had amazing curves so the sight of my cock in her ass put me over the edge. I came hard, one big load followed by five spurts into her ass. I pulled out and without asking she cleaned me off.

I knew this was her attempt to begin asking forgiveness, a promise that this and more could be mine if I gave her another chance. However, I felt nothing, other than post coital bliss. She was merely an object, the same as she'd been for someone else. And I didn't care.

------

We went to therapy again. She wanted to fix it. She wanted to earn my trust back. She said she would do anything. She cut off the other man, blocked him, changed her number. She gave me her passwords, her phone, her location. She cooked dinner, left notes in my lunch, told me she loved me every day; and every day she tried hard for a repeat performance of the morning after. I never let her.

Every time I looked at her, I saw her with him. I saw her doing those things she said she wouldn't do with me, the things I had once fantasized about sharing with her. I saw her giving herself in ways she had denied me, and I felt like a stranger in my own marriage.

Three months later, I told her I wanted a divorce.

She didn't scream or argue. She just sat there on the couch, her eyes wide, her mouth opening and closing like she was searching for words.

"I thought we were getting better," she whispered.

"I can't," I said. "I can't get past it."

She cried, quietly. She didn't try to stop me. She nodded, wiped her tears, and asked, "What do you need me to sign?"

It was the most painful kindness I have ever received. Cold comfort is almost worst than pain.

The divorce was straightforward. She would keep the apartment. We'd rented it in a nice but not luxurious area. I work from home and my significantly larger salary would allow me to live wherever I wanted. We had no kids, no shared debts, nothing that would legally tether us beyond what we already had in our hearts. We split the furniture, kept our respective cars, divided the savings account down the middle. We didn't fight over who got the couch or the plates or the cheap IKEA bookshelf we bought when we first moved in together.

The last day, when the papers were signed, she asked if she could hug me.

I let her.

She smelled like the lavender detergent she always used, and the floral Anthropologie perfume she new I loved. She sobbed into my shoulder, and I held her because despite everything, I still had feelings for her. I probably always would. Not love. That had died; but the genuine affection you have for someone you've shared formative experiences with. Or maybe it was trauma bonding. Who knows.

"I'm so sorry," she whispered again, and I knew she meant it.

"I know."

I moved the last of my stuff that afternoon - the last of my clothes, my books, the photo albums I couldn't bear to leave behind but also couldn't bear to look at. She stood by the door as I left, tears streaking down her face, and I gave her a small, sad smile before I walked away.

It was raining, because of course it was. That's par for the course during summer in Charleston, South Carolina. The sky was gray, but in the sweet summer rain - the smell of ozone mixing with the flowering plants - the world felt washed clean. And I felt the shell of her betrayal that had consumed my personality begin to wash away.

Months passed.

People say time heals, but what they don't tell you is that time doesn't heal everything and not all at once. It gives you enough distance to stop the bleeding and the space to breathe without pain.

I saw her once, by accident, at a coffee shop we used to go to together. She was alone, reading a book, her hair tied up in that messy bun I always loved. Our eyes met, and for a moment, we were back there, in that office trying to work things out, before everything fell apart.

She smiled, a small, sad smile, and I nodded before walking away.

Sometimes, I lie awake at night and think about the things we didn't share, the parts of herself she kept hidden, the parts she gave to someone else. I think about the nights I held her, unaware that her mind was somewhere else, with someone else, and I wonder if it was all a lie.

But I know it wasn't. Love doesn't always die when betrayal happens. Sometimes it lingers, a ghost in the room, a reminder of what could have been.

I don't hate her.

People think I should, but I don't. Hating her would be easier, cleaner, but it wouldn't be true. I loved her, and in many ways, I still do. But I can't be with her. I can't pretend that the things she did didn't happen. I can't be the man who swallows betrayal and calls it forgiveness.

If I could tell her one thing now, it would be that I hope she finds herself. That she learns why she did what she did, that she learns how to love someone fully, without keeping parts of herself locked away. I hope she finds peace.

As for me, I'm learning how to build a life again. Alone, but whole.

I go on walks along the beach in the evening, feeling the wind on my face, the world still turning, the fading light of the sheltering sky still beautiful. I sit in coffee shops and read, sometimes glancing up at couples holding hands, and I feel the ache, but I let it pass.

I'm learning that healing isn't forgetting. It's remembering without letting it destroy you.

In the end, I don't regret loving her. I don't regret the six years we had, even if three of them were shadowed by lies. Because in those years, I learned what it meant to love, what it meant to hurt, and what it meant to let go.

And maybe, one day, I will learn what it means to love again, without fear, without the ghosts of the past whispering in my ear.

Published 
Written by EdwinSx
Loved the story?
Show your appreciation by tipping the author!

Get Free access to these great features

  • Create your own custom Profile
  • Share your erotic stories with the community
  • Curate your own reading list and follow authors
  • Enter exclusive competitions
  • Chat with like minded people
  • Tip your favourite authors

Comments