It was December, and a woman on an adult website I belonged to wrote about her office holiday party. It seems that she found herself in a dark utility closet with two of her male co-workers. It wasn't a tale told to titillate, just to relate an experience she'd had. I'd had two guys at once before, and while I always enjoy that, it was a different aspect of the story that intrigued me. The author told about the thrill of being with two guys in the dark. She couldn't tell who was doing what to her, and that really added to the excitement of the event.
The idea of it captured my imagination. Not knowing whose hands were whose, whose lips were whose, whose cock was whose! The very thought of it got me wet!
I mentioned it to a few people online, and I was wholeheartedly encouraged to pursue something similar. Personally, I didn't think it would be too hard to keep track of two people, so I needed to change the concept somewhat. I figured either I'd need to add someone (I'd never been in more than a threesome before) or somehow ensure the anonymity of the guys involved. I soon had a plan.
New Year's Eve was always an exciting night at our house. Katie and I threw a party every year, and it was always a good one! It was coming up soon, and would be the perfect opportunity to do this. Katie thought I was crazy when I told her what I was planning, but also excited and curious, and she agreed to help. I went back and forth on it over the weeks leading up to it. At times, I was convinced that the whole thing was stupid, or I'd be too overwhelmed by the idea. At other times, even the slightest thought of it would make me highly aroused.
Soon enough, it was the 31st of December. Our party was in full swing, but I was so nervous! There were lots of familiar faces. Friends, co-workers, even some family of me and Katie were having a good time. There was plenty to drink and other recreational substances abound. Plenty of people were there that I would've been happy to fool around with, both guys and girls, but it was the guys I was interested in that night. There were a few former lovers there that I wouldn't mind sleeping with again, and a few others who I hadn't slept with but would like to. Some were there with dates, though, and that could be problematic.
My gaze settled on Andrew. It had been almost a year since he fucked me, but he was good, and he'd made it clear that he wanted more. I'd lost interest in him for a while, and then he got a girlfriend, so we hadn't hooked up in months. He was also at the party with a few friends, none of them girls. With my target acquired, I just had to build up my courage. Booze helped on that front.
Sufficiently tipsy, I approached Andrew. I turned on my flirting skills as we talked, being sure to remind him of a few key incidents from our past. When I felt like I had him right where I wanted him, I leaned in close and quietly told him, "Hey, I have to keep schmoozing with the other guests here, but why don't you come up to my room after midnight?"
My heart was pounding, but there was no hesitation before he said, "Yeah, sounds good!" I kissed him to seal the deal and nibbled his lip to give a little promise of what was to come before I broke away back to the rest of the party. Step One was complete. A little more to drink and I was ready for Step Two.
Mike was another former lover who also seemed to be without a date. I already had Andrew ready to go, and it would've been a fun night with just him. That wasn't my plan, though. There'd be no turning back once I made that next step. Luckily, Katie was there to offer encouragement and alcohol, and she was soon shooing me off in Mike's direction.
Again, I relied on my flirting skills and my past with Mike to draw him in. His interest was clear as he kept making slight advances toward me. I let him maneuver me into a corner and press close to me. He leaned in to kiss me and I let him, but soon broke away. I gave him the same excuse and invitation as before. "Hey, I have to keep schmoozing with the other guests here, but why don't you come up to my room after midnight?"
I didn't tell him that I'd already invited someone else, just like I didn't tell him or Andrew that I would be inviting more. Mike had actually got me pretty aroused, and now that two guys were invited to my room, it was pretty much past the point of no return. Even though I didn't know if Mike and Andrew would be interested in sharing, at this point I had to go with the assumption that they would. I needed at least one more, though.
I didn't need to seek the next one out. Alex approached me as I was getting myself another drink. He and I had flirted at work quite a bit, but it had never gone beyond that. He was a little nervous as we talked and flirted, and I got the impression that he'd spent the night so far building up enough courage to actually ask me out. He surely wasn't expecting the result that he got! After agreeing to a date a few nights later, I told him that he should also come up to my room after midnight. He seemed confused but also intrigued. I giggled, kissed him on the cheek, and told him, "After midnight. Be there." I then scurried away.
The more guys I asked, the easier it got. The more I drank, the easier it got. I was also getting more and more horny. The events between this point and midnight are a little fuzzy, but reliable reports from Katie and others state that I was getting less and less selective about which guys I talked to, and more and more brazen in my approach. By the time midnight rolled around, I'd invited almost every guy at the party to come to my room (some of them more than once), and I'd gotten quite physically friendly with a few guys in the process. In some cases, I'd slipped between a guy and his girlfriend to ask him. The girlfriends were not pleased, and many of them left the party. Most of them took their boyfriends with them.
It must have been clear by this point among the crowd what my intention was, but I was oblivious to any reaction to it.
Just before midnight, I slipped off upstairs. I taped a sign I'd made earlier to my bedroom door, then went inside. The sign said:
RULES
1. Keep the door closed at all times.
2. Do not turn on any lights.
3. Do not speak once you're inside.
4. No clothing allowed. Undress outside or immediately upon entering.
5. Don't be selfish.
Once I was inside, I stripped off all of my clothes. I turned off the light, and even unscrewed the bulb so that no one would intentionally or accidentally turn it on. I made sure the curtains were open. A streetlight a few houses down cast a little bit of light in through the window. I knew some kind of light would be useful, but my bed was positioned so that I wouldn't be able to see much more than silhouettes, but people looking the other direction should be able to make out a little more.
I stretched out on my bed, lit a joint, and waited. The anticipation was killing me, and I was already so aroused that it was hard for me to not get started early. When I heard everyone counting down from ten, followed by all the "Happy New Year" cheers, I extinguished my pot and waited.
Katie's biggest method of helping me out that night was to post herself outside my door, and make sure every guy actually stopped to read the rules before coming inside. This also helped those few who hadn't figured out the plan by slowing them down enough to realize they weren't the only one coming to my door.
If I thought the anticipation was already unbearable, it was nothing compared to the feeling when I started hearing people gather outside my door. I heard Katie directing attention to the rules, but there was also some muffled conversation. Katie later told me there was some hesitation as the guys weren't sure about committing once it was clear that this was to be a group activity. Some guys did back out and leave. I never let Katie tell me who stayed and who left, nor even who was brave enough to come in first.
The door opened, and I closed my eyes to help keep me from identifying who was coming in. I was laid out naked on top of my bed in very dim light, but I could still feel eyes roaming over me. I could hear the sounds of clothes being taken off.
"Is she asleep?" someone asked quietly. The voice was familiar, but I couldn't quite place it.
"I don't know. I don't think so," came the whispered reply. At least two guys were in the room with me.
"Just waiting for you," I said. "And no talking."
"Sorry."
"Shut up."
There was some shuffling around and then, finally, contact. A hand cupped my left breast. I moaned softly as he massaged it. I placed a hand on his arm and followed it to his shoulder, then down his chest until I found his semi-erect cock. I began stroking and felt him getting harder.
Suddenly, my other breast was taken in hand, cupped and lifted to someone's lips. My back arched slightly as he sucked on my tit. I placed my free hand on the back of his head. My other nipple was being gently pinched by the first guy.
So far, the experience was very similar to the other times I'd had two guys, but the anonymity was really arousing!
I tugged on the cock in my hand, now completely hard and erect. He got the hint and moved to his side, letting me guide his cock to my mouth. His hand left my breast and held the back of my head. His other hand quickly replaced the one that was on my tit.