At 76% for, this looks a slam dunk in favour.
Quote by nicola
I'm pretty sure our excellent team of story mods, will be able to figure out these most important and intellectually challenging categorisation conundrums (ccc)![]()
At 76% for, this looks a slam dunk in favour.
Quote by NymphWriter
I think Historical will get "muddied" by lesbian, gay male, and other elements that some would say aren't historical.
Quote by nicola
I'm pretty sure our excellent team of story mods, will be able to figure out these most important and intellectually challenging categorisation conundrums (ccc)![]()
At 76% for, this looks a slam dunk in favour.

"What is the quality of your intent?" - Thurgood Marshall
Quote by nicola
I'm pretty sure our excellent team of story mods, will be able to figure out these most important and intellectually challenging categorisation conundrums (ccc)![]()
At 76% for, this looks a slam dunk in favour.
You can’t truly call yourself peaceful unless you are capable of violence. If you’re not capable of violence, you’re not peaceful. You’re harmless.
Quote by clum
I think my whole sex life is now categorised as "historic".
Quote by Magical_felix
Please don't be sacrilegious. It's offensive, kiera.
I mean't it.
Quote by Poppet
I actually do have a serious question though. I hope it doesn’t come off stupid. Now I know we’re not allowed to write about having sex with famous people. Like actors, actresses, sports people and all that.
So are we going to even be allowed to have sex with Joan of Arc, Cleopatra, Helen of Troy so on and so forth? I’m not sure what the reason we can’t have sex with people like Angelina Jolie or Brad Pitt, so I want to know what is and isn’t okay for this genre.
Quote by Magical_felix
You can't even spell Jehovah's Witness... What in the fuck with you... I mean't really?
Quote by Magical_felix
Quote by clum
Are we allowed to do Jane Austen fanfic? (That's a serious question).
Quote by nicola
Historical fan fiction like this, *should* be ok I think. A lot of people are at it (which doesn't necessarily mean it's legal to do so).
Quote by clum
Yeah, I know we don't generally allow fanfic for legal reasons, but I was reading somewhere lately that you can do pretty much whatever the hell you want with stuff like Shakespeare, Austen and Dickens, but it wasn't anything official.
I'll do a little digging myself.
Quote by cooldaddy
Nothing to do with the thread, but what's with Magical felix always picking up on Kiera? So she got her spelling wrong, - so what? She's not the first and won't be the last. And he should talk, - on page 1, -
Kiera, "I assumed you meant something........."
Felix, "I assumed you MEAN'T something"
Why the apostrophe? In this case it means you have shortened two words into one, ie don't = do not. Can he tell us what two words go to make mean't. In my dictionary it is spelled as meant.
Sorry folks, for butting in.
Quote by nicola
I'm pretty sure our excellent team of story mods, will be able to figure out these most important and intellectually challenging categorisation conundrums (ccc)![]()
At 76% for, this looks a slam dunk in favour.
Quote by stephanie
As an avid fan of general historical fiction, (though NO EXPERT on copyright law...) I'd make a layman's observation. (Or two!)
If it's a REAL PERSON (either still living or with a legally active estate...) you can't feature them in a way that might possibly cause offence or insult. (So YOU CAN'T fuck Bono or say how you met Bill Clinton in a New Orleans cat-house...) You CAN write about a U2 concert or refer to Clinton's record.
If it's a REAL PERSON who is deceased and NO LONGER has an active estate, (King Edward the VIIth is a good example, as is General George Custer or Marie Antoinette...) you basically have carte-blanche.
If it's a FICTIONAL CHARACTER, (Sherlock Holmes, Dracula or Biggles!) you're pretty much okay! (Incidentally, ALL THESE CHARACTERS STILL HAVE ACTIVE ESTATES, that is, you CAN'T write a BRAND NEW Sherlock Holmes book, but YOU CAN feature him as an ancillary character in an original novel.)
EXCEPT...
Common sense must prevail. If, for example, you write a story where you portray Winston Churchill as a raving gay, you're going to get flak. (Oddly, you can have Tiberius fuck a pig and no-one will bat an eyelid... Although, to be fair, he may well have actually done that. He was FUCKING WEIRD!!! Google, 'Tiberius Minnows' for confirmation...)
It's a MOD'S call and GENERALLY they get it right as I say... (Maybe worth mentioning here that that is ONE OF THE MANY THINGS you can't TEACH a Moderator. They either INSTINCTIVELY feel it or they don't... A GOOD MODERATOR will be able to explain WHY something QUITE SIMPLY RINGS HOLLOW...)
Finally, GREAT TO SEE the support for this category among my fellow members!
xx SF
Poppet: "So? Can I Expect Some Input From You On Our Spanish Civil War Epic Collab???"
Mysteria27: "And our 80's-set Mafia Don collab?"
Me: "oh shit..."
Quote by Mysteria27
Mysteria - Nope it will never happen
Poppet - I know right..Been waiting for ages
Stephanie - I really don't like to write
Both - WE KNOW!
Hugs,
Mysteria
xo
Quote by stephanie
I DON'T like WRITING!!!
(I truly REALLY REALLY don't!!!)
I'm just VERY GOOD AT IT!!!
(Imagine a GREAT CHEF who's secretly ANOREXIC...) Or a CHILEAN TORTURER from the 1970's JUNTA who hates hurting people. Or a PILOT afraid of HEIGHTS! A SINGER with stage-fright... A comedian who can't make himself LAUGH!!!)
Actually, I CAN make myself laugh!
But I OWE both of you for ideas and talent and input and encouragement and friendship and talking and help and ELECTRICITY and MAKING ME BETTER and general coolness...
(So bear with me!)
Both are GREAT stories!!! (Seriously, I WILL...)
xx SF