Quote by JourneyYoung
if you tag something "novel" you basically lose out on what the top-level category for the story actually is.
Yes, and that's the primary driver behind the proposal. "Novel" carries no weight at the URL level, both for potential readers and for search engines. The only way to determine genre is via tags or reading the whole thing. And as you say, tags aren't sortable. Yet.
But if you were to put chapter 7 in the Facesitting category, you attract people who camp on categories to find new stories, and it's a strong signal to search engine spiders that the story is about that topic, allowing better results for people who search outside of the site (i.e. potentially bringing in more specific traffic from people who don't know about the site).
The predominant arguments against ditching it seem to be:
a) People who combine chapters into one submission can't easily categorise the various story arcs in one genre. That's a valid concern, except multi-chapter submissions are a bit of a hack to get round writing too-short chapters. Even a chapter of 1-2K words is still a chapter and could be a discrete unit, published separately. And according to the story length poll, combining chapters with the intent of beefing up the word count may harm your chances of people reading the entry.
b) Authors don't want people to dive into a chapter in the middle of the story and would prefer it was read from chapter 1, in series. This is impossible to achieve on the web. That's like saying you wish people would always land on the home page of your website and navigate from there to find what they want. Every page of a website is potentially a home page when search engines allow you to jump in anywhere. It's your job as a website content creator (or story teller, in this case) to make sure they land on something relevant and to inform them it's a multi-chapter piece and might not make sense without the earlier bits.
Interestingly, the above phenomenon is not unique to putting the stories in specific categories vs putting them all in the Novels category. If someone searches for a set of keywords, and chapter 11 pops up in the search results, would you as an author want to stop them reading it and force them to start at chapter 1? No. It's conceited to think that you would. The only way you can mostly guarantee that outcome, would be to publish it all in one loooong story (a single URL) and omit anchor points at chapter junctions.
We do have the same issue with Microfiction and Flash Fiction: neither of them indicate genre. And it is annoying. But the difference there is that each offer a specific and defined challenge for authors, while the Novels category doesn't. And we don't allow chapter series in the Micro and Flash categories.
End of the day, the site needs to connect readers with content they want to read. So any and all signals we can use to achieve that is a win.