Jess and I had been dating for almost a year. Everything in our relationship was great and her ability to charm just about every person she met, made me the envy of my group of friends. I knew I had a few very jealous male comrades and quite frankly, it made me feel great. And they really only knew the tiniest bit about her.
Our sex life was as fun and adventurous as always and Susan joined us regularly for threesomes. She had undergone quite the transformation and was a much more self-assured lover now. I was pretty sure that most of her focus was on Jess rather than me but I was not complaining. I found her gangly, pseudo-supermodel physique a huge turn-on and enjoyed both our physical and intellectual interactions.
Plus, there was something incredibly erotic and entertaining watching her and Jess go at each other. There were times when I’d just sit in a chair with a glass of wine and watch the two of them play.
While I was very protective of Jess and our relationship, I never saw Susan as a threat and there were times when I secretly had entertained thoughts of us in some sort of threesome relationship but was not sure how something like that would even work. As usual, I found myself getting ahead of myself and consequently filed that idea away for the time being, not wanting to disturb anything about our relationship in its present state. The old saying of “Don’t fix it if it ain’t broken” was very applicable here. I was not about to mess with what was a very nice situation.
Considering our somewhat libertine ways, the conversation about an open relationship came up at one point. I was relieved to hear that Jess was just about as uncomfortable with that concept as I was. We did agree that we would allow ourselves to play with others, as long as we did it together. That seemed appropriate considering that in some way that was how our relationship was founded in the first place.
One Sunday morning, while lounging around, talk turned to how we first met at Terry’s party and how we ended up as participants in that crazy sex game he had arranged.
At one point she brought up the incident when Terry sucked my cock and commented on how I did not seem that freaked out about it at the time.
She asked if I had ever played with other guys and though I gave her a very diluted version of my experiences with guys, I did admit that I had always had a curiosity for cocks. She really perked up and kept drilling me about it. Even though we were completely open with one another, this line of questioning made me somewhat uncomfortable and I found myself trying very hard not to reveal things that I thought she might not want to hear as opposed to being completely open.
I was overthinking again.
Inevitably she finally asked if I’d ever consider having another guy join us.
Deep down inside I just did not want to to imagine another guy sticking his cock inside her while I watched but I knew that admitting that to her straight out would be the height of hypocrisy, considering that I was perfectly content sticking my dick into Susan when we played with her.
Maybe Jess was just more open-minded than I was.
I also told her that whereas I did have a thing for a nice cock, I really was not attracted to men. It was the truth. Playing with a buddy was one thing, but it was more about addressing basic horniness and a sense of exploring the forbidden and unknown.
I had never had the same reaction to a hot-looking guy walking past me on the street as I did when a cute girl passed by. The dynamic between a couple of buddies was fascinating to me but there was never any real physical attraction.
It was becoming obvious that Jess had already decided that a second cock was going to be part of our play at some point and in typical fashion she had already come up with a solution. She caught me a bit off guard when she suggested that we find a transsexual to play with us.
I had always had a fascination with she-males as they addressed both of the things I liked, the outward appearance of a girl but with a male attachment.
Playing with one had been a recurring fantasy of mine and now my girlfriend not only permitted but also encouraged the idea.
I tried not to look too pleased when I told Jess that I would go along with her plan.
Naturally, the first question that came to my mind was whether she already had someone in mind. That’s usually how it went, with her being several steps ahead of me. When I asked her, she said that she did not and that we would have to start from a blank slate.
Even in a town like San Francisco, finding a she-male suitable to our specific situation was not going to be easy but I also knew that Jess would find a way to see this through in some way. Time for me to hang on for the ride.
There was a great nightclub and bar that I used to frequent when I was single, a cool underground space that featured music, food and a very diverse, hip and fun crowd. I was always amazed at how many shemales, transvestites and cross-dressers frequented the place. I told Jess about it and suggested that we might try to go there to find someone to play with.
We decided to go that very Sunday evening. Saturday nights were mayhem with three deep at the bar at all times but while Sundays still drew a good crowd, the scene was much more relaxed.
As we walked down the long stairway to get to the lower level, Jess was already reprimanding me for having never taken her there. She instantly loved the place.
I made some stammering excuses that did not sit well. The reason that I had not taken her there was because, in some sense, I had always considered it as my place, where I used to hang out in my single days. Somehow I wanted to preserve that memory strictly for myself.
The fact that I had gotten a little more than close with a couple of the female bartenders who still worked there, also acted as a bit of a deterrent.
There were several groups of she-males there that evening but they seemed fairly cliquey and hung out amongst themselves. Unfortunately, most of them were dressed and made up in an over-the-top style that bordered on comical in some instances. The heavily made-up bombshell look.
Jess and I agreed that that was really not our thing at all.
There was one particularly stunning, very tall goth girl that immediately caught my attention. Between her high-heeled boots and tall spiked hair, she stood as tall as me at over six foot four.
I had always been attracted to that style and fashion sense and dressed in a very subtle goth style myself, a sort of elegant dark look which Jess actually appreciated but when she saw me make fairly significant eye contact with the girl, she stopped me in my tracks and told me that that was a bit much for her.
I kept the fact that I was quite disappointed in myself.
There really were no other prospects that evening. But there was no great urgency, so we decided to just keep looking. Something would come our way.
The club did offer the best prospects so we focused our energy there. It had also become one of Jess’s favorites and ended up going regularly. A couple of uncomfortable hurdles involving my past single days had to be crossed but I was also happy to be hanging out there again.
A few weeks later we were having cocktails at the bar when we noticed three girls sitting also sitting at the bar, a few stools away from us.
They looked fairly plain. Two of them seemed to be a couple and they definitely had a lesbian air about them, leaning toward the more butch side.
The third girl was kind of pretty in a way that was hard to pin down. She was wearing a simple, knee-length, sixties-style sundress and some suede Chelsea boots. Her shoulder-length hair was parted on the side and looked to have been dyed a dark blueish tint but it was hard to tell for sure in the dimly lit club. She was wearing generally very subtle make-up except for some very dark eyeliner that made her large, pretty pale blue eyes really stand out. It made her look exotic and kind of dorky and quirky all at the same time.
I found her quite cute and pretty.
At some point, her two friends departed. Jess gave me a kick and nudged me.
The girl took out a notebook and started to write and draw in it while continuing to sip her cocktail. When she finished it, Jess jumped into action and quickly ordered another one and a couple more for us.
She looked surprised when the bartender suddenly placed the drink in front of her and she made an inquisitive motion. The bartender pointed at Jess, who gave her a little wave.
She looked confused and asked why we had bought her a drink. Jess said that we were just getting ours refilled and we might as well get her one too since she was by herself. She smiled and thanked us and continued to draw in her book.
I knew it was just a matter of time before Jess would escalate matters to the next level. The girl seemed shy and absorbed in her drawing but when Jess asked her to join us, she slid over to sit next to us.
When it turned out that both of the cocktails she and I were having had the same, fairly exotic French liqueur in them, Jess took that as the perfect catalyst to start the conversation. We introduced ourselves and found out that her name was Alexis.
I figured that Jess had some idea about our new acquaintance but I was still trying to ascertain her true gender by gathering any clues I could.
Her voice was soft but a bit raspy. She had very smooth-looking hands with long slender fingers and short nails that were painted blue. Her boots looked large but not completely out of proportion to her frame. The slinky dress she was wearing revealed small, perky-looking breasts but that was not conclusive proof of anything either.
At this point, she was still an enigma to me, though I was leaning towards thinking that she was just a typical, alternative-leaning city girl.
Jess went to work with her prodigious social skills and charm and was soon extracting all sorts of information.
She was an art student, originally from the East Coast, lived in the city and was single.
The conversation took off and we talked about art, music and life in the city in general. There were a lot of overlaps with things we liked and were interested in.
It was getting late and things in the club were winding down. Alexis was getting ready to leave and thanked us for the drink. Before final goodbyes could be made, Jess asked Alexis if she would like to join us for brunch this coming Sunday.
From the look on her face, Alexis was as blindsided by the invitation as I was. We never really had brunch. I’d usually grab a coffee and pastry and Jess would wolf down a bowl of cereal in the morning, so inviting a stranger to brunch struck me as weird.
I could see her struggling with the decision and was honestly quite surprised when she accepted. Jess smiled and gave her a big hug. I finished my drink while they exchanged numbers. Chalk one up for Jess.
On our walk back to her place she made her case as to why she thought that Alexis was a shemale. I was not convinced yet but if Jess was going to do her thing in her usual fashion, it might not be a lot later than Sunday before I had some definitive proof in front of me.
Sunday morning came and we met Alexis at a small cafe. She was waiting outside when we arrived, wearing a similar outfit to the one she had the other night.
She was also wearing a small leather choker around her neck giving her otherwise cute girl look a bit of a sexy edge. Even in broad daylight, I could not detect anything that would have given me a clue. She just looked like a pretty girl to me.
The sunlight did reveal that her hair had a definite blueish color to it. It did not look gaudy but did impart a bit of exoticness to her look.
We settled in at a table. The girls ordered Mimosas while I opted for straight sparkling wine. The conversation pretty much took up where it had left off the other night.
Alexis told us that she had just recently moved to the West Coast from Rhode Island. She intimated that situations at home sought her looking for a drastic change of scenery and even though she was still just settling in, she felt very much at home here.
Jess offered to show her around town and they were already making shopping plans. It was quickly becoming obvious that the two of them were hitting it off quite nicely. I found Alexis quite charming and figured that even if nothing else happened, we had at least made a cool new friend.
As brunch came to an end, Jess asked Alexis if she had any plans for the day.
When she said that she did not, Jess immediately asked if she wanted to come over and hang out with us. We’d tear apart the Sunday newspaper, drink some wine, and listen to some music.
I was pleasantly surprised when Alexis immediately accepted the invitation.
We got back to the apartment and settled in. It was a warm day and I opened a bunch of windows to allow a bit of a breeze, put on some music and got a bottle of wine and glasses while the girls were getting comfortable on the couch.
The afternoon was getting warmer and warmer and Jess decided to get more comfortable by changing into some shorts and a tank top. She had also taken off her underwear by the looks of it.