“Yeah, she's still fooled about you.”
“About me?” Ashley gasped, “What about you. You're the one that's got the hots for my stepbrother. Does she know about that?”
“No and I'm not going to tell her. Besides, you're not being fair. I just asked if you could fix me up with him.”
“Right and you bought that nothing little girl skirt just to wear to church. You don't have to tell me what you're thinking.”
“Okay, already, so I've got a crush on Brad. So what's the big deal.”
Ashley was not about to have her friend know that her own feelings for Brad were not strictly platonic. “Nothing, I guess.” Then she really lied. “Besides he's not even going to be home Saturday night, at least not until real late. Got a date or something.”
Jill was disappointed to hear that but she was not going to admit it to Ashley. “That's not why I was coming over anyway.”
“So, uh... what time are you coming over?”
“Say uh, sevenish, when we're done with dinner. Okay?”
“Yeah, and one more thing – bring some real pajamas, you know, like the flannel kind.”
“Okay, I think I can find some. Sounds like fun, kinda like the slumber parties we had a few years back.”
“That's sort of what I was thinking. See you at seven.”
Somewhere around seven, the doorbell rang. Brad had gone to pick up Jarrad. Ashley was home alone. She went to the door and ushered Jill in. “C'mon, let's get changed.” Ashley was sure she'd never get Jill to wearing just pajamas after the guys had 'unexpectedly' shown up.
“Uh, you mean the pajamas? Right now?”
“Yeah, right now. I got a couple of movies for us to watch. It'll be kind of sexy, in just our pajamas.”
“Yeah well, I did bring 'em with me but they're kinda worn and got a couple buttons missing. Is Brad still here?”
“Gone. Just you and me. You ready?”
“Yeah, I guess so. I don't know how sexy it's going to be, sitting around in the den in some old pajamas, but if that's what you want to do...”
Ashley nodded her head enthusiastically, grabbed Jill's arm and tugged her toward the bedroom. When they got there, Ashley stripped off her clothes and put on a pair of pajamas she had previously dug out of her closet.
Jill stopped with her bra and panties still on. “You mean you're not going to wear any underwear?”
“Of course not,” Ashley responded enthusiastically. “It's sexier that way – almost naughty.”
Jill didn't respond. She just looked at her friend with a 'what?' kind of look.
“In those baggy pajamas it'll feel like you're naked. C'mon, strip! You'll love it.”
Jill unhooked her bra but didn't remove it immediately. “Yeah, but what if Brad comes back, or something like that?”
Ashley's face instantly lit up. “We can always hope, can't we,” she said cheerily.
A smile slowly came across Jill's face. Shrugging the bra off her shoulders she quipped, “If my mother only knew the things you get me into, no way she'd let me come here.” She hooked her thumbs in her panties and pushed them down.
Ashley watched, thinking how much like Jill she looked. They not only looked like sisters but could probably pass for twins. She noted too that Jill was wearing a bra that was just a little too small, nicely firming and exposing a lot of skin. Both were probably a 'C' but preferred 'B' size bras.
When Jill had finally gotten her pajamas on, Ashley opened the door to the backyard and motioned in that direction.
“Hey, what the hell,” Jill protested. “I thought we were going to watch a move.”
“Time enough for that,” Ashley replied. “C'mon, it's nice out.”
“Yeah, but it's still light too.”
“So... what's to see?”
“Well there is that house over back and if there's anyone upstairs they can see right into your yard.”
“And...”
“Well, we're just wearing pajamas.”
“Which is way more than we were wearing the other day.”
“Yeah, well I thought somebody was watching us then too.”
“C'mon, quit being a prude. If they wanna look, let 'em look.”
“Okay then, but just for a while.” Ashley stepped out the door. Jill followed her to the pool deck. They pulled a couple of lawn chairs together and sat down.
Only two buttons held Jill's top together – one between her breasts and another near the bottom. Ashley reached over and undid the bottom button and quickly spread the top apart exposing a portion of Jill's stomach. “What do you think you are doing?” screeched Jill.
Ashley was already unbuttoning a number of her own buttons. When she had undone all but the one between her breasts, she spread her own top apart like she had done with Jill's. “I just want to make sure if someone is watching, they don't get too bored.” She leaned back in the chair and spread her legs invitingly.
*****
“Bro, you ain't going to believe this,” Brad said as he followed Jarrad into the house. Jarrad had just opened the door to let Brad in. It had been planned that they were going to go out and see if they could hook up with a couple of girls and bring them back to Jarrad's house.
“What, you got the clap or something?”
“No, no, nothing like that.”
“What then? Spill it!”
“You remember Jill Larsen, Ashley's sorority sister?”
“Yeah, hot little bitch. Graduated with us. A little uptight maybe, but what about her.”
“Well, she's staying with Ashley tonight and Ashley wants us to come over and party with them.”
“Now wait, hold it just a minute. Are you sure Ashley wants me to come over? I thought I was banned from your house.”
I'm not sure what's she's thinking but... “Yeah, we discussed it and well, maybe she got over being mad. You up for it?”
“Shit yeah, but uh... you making it with your sister?”
“No, of course not,” Brad lied. “Stepsister anyway, not sister.”
“Well, I'm not sure it makes any difference, but... So you're going after Jill then? You okay with me and Ashley?”
That was a tough one. Brad would have rather it been the other way around, but he couldn't admit that to Jarrad. “I guess so but you treat her right, okay?”
“Oh yeah, I will, she says no, it's no. I'll behave myself, I promise.” Jarrad was ecstatic. Ashley was easily the hottest girl he'd ever been with, even if he hadn't gotten into her pants yet.
“So grab some clothes then,” Brad urged. “You're staying at my house tonight and bring some swim shorts. Don't know what Ashley's got in mind but she has promised we'll have fun.” Brad was following Jarrad to his room.
“I seem to remember your folks getting upset about you and Ashley having friends over when they were out of town. You sure this is going to be okay?” Jarrad asked as he hunted through his drawers for some extra clothes.
“They don't seem to care much now we're all eighteen, least not so long as we don't make too much of a mess. Don't worry about it. Just get a hurry on.”
*****
“Ashley said they'd be out by the pool,” Brad said as they entered the house. Jarrad dropped his extra clothes in Brad's room as they went through it on their way to the backyard. “Yep, there they are, by the pool.”
The girls had their backs to the house and didn't see the guys at first. Jill picked up on their approach from the corner of her eye. Jerking her head toward them she screeched, “Oh my god no.” She grabbed her pajama top and hastily tried to close the only additional button.
“What's wrong?” Ashley asked, turning in the direction of the house. She spotted Brad and Jarrad.
“Your brother and he's got someone with him. Quick get buttoned up.” She continued fumbling with the one additional button, trying to get it closed.
“What?” Ashley snapped. “It's just Brad and Jarrad. Both have seen me wearing a lot less. And you, you got nothing to worry about. Leave that button alone.
Just as Jill got the button through the button-hole, it broke loose. “Guess I don't have any choice now,” she said. “Shit, shit, shit. Why'd I ever let you talk me into this?”
“Quit worrying about it,” Ashley commanded. “I had no idea.” Not much anyway. “I thought Brad was out on a date. And Jarrad? I have no idea what he's doing here.” Oh boy is that a lie, but he sure does look good. ”Hey stranger, what brings you here?”
“My buddy here told me there was a coupla hot chicks at his house and we should go keep 'em company.”
“Uh, yeah right.” Ashley was on the other side of Jill from Brad. She shook her head from side to side and pointed at the back of Jill's head. “But Brad, I thought you had a date tonight.”
Brad had forgotten to tell Jarrad that Jill didn't know anything about the two of them showing up. “Uh, yeah, well I got stood up... so I went over to Jarrad's... and well I didn't think you'd mind if we came over here to hang.”
Jill was still kind of shaken by the whole thing but kinda glad Brad was back so soon, and Jarrad too, but... “I'm glad you guys decided to join us. I just wish I'd known so I could have been wearing something other than this worn out pair of pajamas.” She was looking at Brad.
Brad hesitated long enough to take in the whole picture. That has got to be the same pajamas she was wearing two years ago. And I thought they were sexy then. “I think they look even better now than they did a coupla years ago.”
Brad looked over at Ashley. Like Jill, she had only one button holding her top together, but unlike Jill, she had plenty of buttons that could have been buttoned. She also had the top button on the bottoms undone. As he raised his eyebrows, silently questioning his stepsister, she responded by tugging at the top and bottom of her pajamas, making sure she was showing as much skin as the remaining button would permit.
It was beginning to get dark. “We were about to go inside and watch a movie.” Ashley offered. “You guys want to join us?”
Jarrad licked his lips. “I think we could be talked into that,” he allowed. “What do you think, Brad? You game too?”
Brad had mixed emotions. He sure was looking forward to cuddling up next to Jill. He was pretty sure she wasn't wearing anything under the pajamas. But he was absolutely sure his stepsister wasn't wearing any either, and he didn't like the thought of her and Jarrad fooling around too. “Uh yeah, I guess so,” he replied noncommittally.
*****
The girls returned to the house through Ashley's bedroom. As soon as the door and curtain were closed, Jill began stripping off her pajamas.
“What are you doing?” Ashley quizzed.
“Putting my other clothes back on. We are changing aren't we?”
“I wasn't going to, and I don't know why you think you should.”
“We're going to sit out there watching a movie with Jarrad and Brad and you don't think we need to change?” Jill expressed astonishment.
“Yeah, and why not?” Ashley cheerily responded. “It'll be fun.”
“Fun?”
“Yeah, fun. It's not like we're pairing off and going to separate bedrooms, it'll be all four of us in the den.” Hot! “Nothing serious, just some playing. You do want to have fun, don't you?”
“Uh, well, I suppose so, but you think it'll be okay? I mean like I'm not even wearing underwear.”
“And neither am I. Kinda naughty huh?” Ashley grinned a conspiratorial grin.
“Yeah, sorta.” Jill grinned too.
“So get those pajamas back on... that is unless you'd rather go naked.”
“Ha ha, very funny,” Jill said, still grinning as she pulled her pajamas back on.
*****
When the girls got to the den, Brad and Jarrad had already staked out the ends of the couch, leaving just enough room between for Ashley and Jill. A nervous shiver went through Jill. “We could sit in the chairs,” she whispered anxiously to Ashley.
Ashley didn't respond verbally. She took Jill by the hand and led her to the couch. She pushed her down on the couch next to Brad, then squeezed into the empty space next to Jarrad. She turned and whispered to Jill, “Lighten up a little. This is going to be fun.”
Jarrad used the tight seating arrangement as a quick excuse to slip his arm around Ashley's shoulders. He's not wasting any time, Ashley thought to herself. Jarrad grabbed Ashley's shoulder and pulled her toward himself. He let his arm dangle over the front of her shoulder, lightly touching the top of her breast. Ashley pulled herself upward, allowing his fingers to close on her nipple.
Ashley's pajama-top was being held together by only one button, one button too many as far as she was concerned. They were only a few minutes into the movie when she reached to undo the button. As she did so, she looked to her left and saw that Brad's hand was resting on Jill's thigh, inches from her pussy. “Brad, get the light, will you please.