As we all lay on the bed in silence, I could feel that the atmosphere was becoming a little awkward, I felt I had to say something so I blurted out, ‘Wow that was really good’ and to my surprise, the other three all agreed. We made the same small talk and after Tori and Rex had freshened up they made their way back to their cabin after arranging to meet for drinks the following evening. Rex and I shook hands, the girls hugged, and as Rex gave Karen a kiss goodbye I took the opportunity to whisper to Tori that she was amazing.
After they had gone Karen and I cuddled up on the bed and I brought up what had just happened. I asked if she had enjoyed it, and how she felt. I had a number of other questions but needed to gauge her reaction first.
She said that it was different, that Rex’s cock was smaller than mine but had a huge head so felt totally different from mine, but she liked the feeling. She also said there was no jealousy so I took this as a positive.
I had a few things on my mind so thought no time like the present to ask, so I said, ‘You weren’t as loud as when we have sex,’ and she explained that she felt she had to hold back showing too much enjoyment as she didn’t want to hurt my feelings. I gave her a cuddle and said we had discussed this and I wanted her to have full enjoyment but said I also understood because I felt Tori was also holding back.
I then asked why she had not 69’d with Rex as she loved doing it. Again she said she was holding back because of me.
I would love to say that we then fucked each other all night, but I think we were both mentally drained, so we cuddled and fell asleep.
Next day was a sea day, so after sleeping in we went for breakfast and then found a couple of sun loungers to top up the tan.
After an hour or so I asked Karen if she thought it would be awkward if Rex and Tori did come for drinks, which she said perhaps to begin with but nothing too bad, so I asked if she would do it again if the opportunity came up, and if so would she let go more. She said she definitely wanted to try again, she wanted to feel Rex enter her again, hopefully try a few different positions. As you can imagine this was turning me on so I had to lay on my front for a while. Karen was asking me similar questions and I tried not to appear too keen but also wanting to try again.
The day dragged as I couldn’t stop thinking about Tori and whether or not I would get to spend more time with her.
Eventually, it was time to eat so we went to the restaurant had a lovely romantic dinner and headed to our favourite bar. Although no time had been set last time they arrived about 8 p.m. We arrived about 7.45, sat at a table for four, and ordered our drinks. Time went by and there was no sign of Rex and Tori, Karen told me to stop looking at my watch every ten seconds, they would turn up if they wanted to.
After another drink I had resigned myself that nothing more would happen so asked Karen if she wanted to go to the casino, ‘Let’s have one more drink here’ she said and this was the best decision she ever made as five minutes later I felt a hand on my shoulder and a gentle squeeze, Rex and Tori had arrived. I felt like a teenager again, my heart pounding, I stood up and offered Tori the chair next to me and Rex sat next to Karen.
The conversation flowed really well and we all had a few drinks. Tori’s hand kept resting on my knee and we caught a few knowing looks. I’m sure Karen and Rex were doing similar. Nothing had been said about last night and I was beginning to think that nothing would, I didn’t know how to bring it up.
We all ordered another drink and once the waiter had set them down Rex spoke up (of all of us he had been the quietest throughout the whole thing), he said that both he and Tori had discussed last night, and whilst they both really enjoyed what happened, the felt they both held back, not wanting to show too much enjoyment to each other. Karen, to my surprise, said that we had the exact same conversation. With that, Rex asked how we would feel about him and Karen going to one cabin and Tori and I going to the other cabin. I looked at Karen and she took a big gulp of her drink then looked back at me and gave a very subtle nod.