Penny just stood there as Craig waved the DVD at her.
"What is this?"
"Looks like a DVD to me."
"I mean, who is Kris?"
"She's my girlfriend."
"Girlfriend?"
"Yes, what part of girlfriend don't you understand?"
"How long has this been going on?"
"Six or seven months, give or take."
"But why?"
"Why not? You don't seem all that interested in sex anymore. I could just bring men home instead and make you watch some live action instead of your stupid porn flicks. Maybe that would get you interested or maybe you could just be more useful for cleanup after."
Instead of saying anything, he just handed the DVD to her, walked into the den and turned on the TV. Penny went into the bedroom and called Kris.
"I'm not sure what to make of his reaction. He didn't get mad, he didn't beg or even ask me to stop, he didn't say ‘hey, that's great'. He just handed me the DVD and walked away."
"I think maybe the next thing is to do what you did with him before, only this time let him watch us for real. And I think it's also time to get a real crop to use on him. If he reacts to that the same way, or it turns him on but he does what you order him to, I think you will have your answer. Then we bring in my friend to seal the deal."
"I just don't know…"
"I know, and I won't push you. It is your decision to make. I just know that you aren't happy with the way things are right now, yet you don't really want a divorce. You didn't think you would ever be able to be with a woman, but you found out you could. I think you are capable of a lot more than you think you are."
During the next few weeks, Craig was pretty quiet, not mentioning the DVD or asking any questions. He still helped with the chores and if Penny asked him to do anything like pick up the dry cleaning, he did it without comment. He did not initiate sex and neither did Penny. He would go to bed before her and be asleep by the time she went to bed, or fall asleep on the couch. During this time, other than talking on the phone once, she did not see Kris. She wanted to be sure of her feelings and that any decision she made was with a clear head.
She had explained this all to Kris, who understood, even though she said she would miss her.
"Please call me as soon as you can and let me know what you decide to do… both about Craig and about us."
"I will, Kris. I just need to be free of distractions when I make this decision."
"I understand.
After three weeks passed, Penny called Kris.
"When can you come over?"
"Tomorrow after work?"
"Okay, around 6 then? Craig should be home a bit after that. Park your car across the street or down a house or two and wear something sexy."
The next morning, before she left for work, Penny changed the sheets on the bed, dug out some toys and the rope and set it all up. She put some wine in the fridge so it would be chilled that evening. She also set out about a dozen scented candles in the bedroom, then went to work. She got home about 5:30 and took a quick shower, then pulled out her sexiest camisole and a pair of matching panties, a garter belt, and silk stockings. She put on a silk robe over that.
Kris arrived a few minutes before 6 and practically knocked Penny over when she came in and kissed her.
"I have missed you! I have been worried that you were going to tell me you couldn't see me anymore."
"I have missed you too, Kris… more than I care to admit."
"So what's the plan?"
Penny opened up the wine and poured them each a glass while she explained.
"I have a note telling him to come up to the bedroom as soon as he reads the note, and that he should be naked when he comes in. We will be there, but when we hear him pull in, you go into the bathroom. When he comes in and sees the candles, he will likely figure it will be like the last time. I will tie him up again, then call for you to come out. I have a real crop to use on him this time. We can just play it by ear after that."
"I love the way you think. Are you sure you are going to be able to perform in front of him?
"Well, that's gonna be your job to make me forget he is there."
"Mmmmm. I will do my best."
They went upstairs and left the note on the hall table where he always left his keys. They went into the bedroom and lit all the candles. They were sitting on the bed kissing when they heard Craig's car pull into the garage. Kris went into the bathroom while Penny checked that everything was ready. A few minutes later, she heard Craig coming up the stairs. He walked into the room with just his briefs on and looked around at all the candles. Penny was still in her robe.
"What's going on? Oh, another one of your games, I see."
"Did you read the note?"
"Yes, and I stripped."
"I said naked, not just down to your underwear. Take them off, then turn around."
As he pulled off his briefs, she could see he was getting an erection already. She tied his hands behind his back, then pushed him down into the chair.
"Spread your legs."
He did as he was told and she tied his legs as she had before, then tied his arms to the chair. By this time, he was getting hard. Penny walked over to the bed and pulled out the crop. She stood in front of him and slapped his cock hard with the crop. He immediately went soft.
"Owwwww! What the fuck? That wasn't funny."
"It wasn't meant to be funny. From now on, you will only get hard when I give you permission. It is a right you will have to earn from now on. And when I tell you to get hard, you better be able to do it. Now just sit there like a nice little boy and watch the show. And keep quiet, or I will gag you as well."
She used the crop on his cock a few more times just for good measure.
"Kris, come on out now."
Kris walked out of the bathroom. She was wearing a red lace bra that did not hide much of anything and matching panties. Craig looked at her and started to say something, but Penny gave him a look and he stopped short. When his cock started to twitch, it got slapped a few more times.
"So, you're Craig. Penny has told me about you and your little problem. But don't worry; I have been keeping her satisfied."
Kris slowly undressed Penny and kissed her lips and played with her breasts. Then Penny undressed Kris and they lay down on the bed. After a few minutes under Kris's skilled hands and tongue, Penny forgot all about Craig and they spent the next forty minutes or so making love. When they finally came up for air, Craig had a raging hard-on. Penny grabbed the crop and walked over to him and slapped his shaft hard several times.
"You were a bad boy. I told you that you were not to get a hard-on unless I gave you permission. Since you can't seem to listen, you will not be allowed to touch me. Maybe next time, you will do better."
"Next time?"
"Yes, I plan to have Kris over here often. Sometimes we may let you watch. Maybe even let you service me after but you will have to earn that right. Now I am going to untie you. If you want, you may go masturbate to take care of your hard-on yourself. Then you can sleep on the couch or the guest room tonight. Kris will be sleeping in here with me."
"What?"
"You heard me."
Penny untied Craig and sent him on his way. He mumbled under his breath, but he left.
"Wow, for someone who wasn't quite sure how you were going to handle that, you did pretty well. And I get to sleep over, too!"
Over the next couple of months, they had several more ‘sleepovers'. Usually, they just let Craig watch, though she did let him clean her up after and play with her clit until she had an orgasm while Kris watched. She didn't tie him up any longer, just made him sit there. Once she told him if he wanted to masturbate while he watched, it would be okay, but he couldn't even get it hard enough to cum. In between, they had sex a couple of times, but it was becoming less satisfactory for her. Craig was not saying one word about leaving her though.
"I talked to my friend about helping you out in the next stage whenever you are ready. If that goes well, then he has another friend that he thinks might be more of what you will need," said Kris.
"I don't understand. What do you mean, what I will need?"
"You are or will be cucking Craig, Penny. You need a man to fuck you while he watches, and afterward, you may want Craig to clean both of you up. You may even want to peg your husband or make him take a cock in his ass. My friend is strictly straight, but knows several bisexual guys that would likely be glad to help."
"Oh, I don't think he would ever let a guy fuck him or suck some guy's cock."
"I think at this point, he will do whatever you tell him to. But we can test the premise of what he might or might not do next time we get together."
The next time Kris came over, Craig came in and took his seat, but Penny lay down on the bed and spread her legs. She told Craig to come over and get between her legs. He would be allowed to use his tongue and fingers to pleasure her. He half-heartedly started working on her. Behind him, Kris put on a strap-on dildo and poured a generous amount of lube on it, then pushed it between Craig's cheeks.
"What the fuck???"
"Shut up and just keep licking. Kris is just giving you some incentive."
"No one is gonna stick something up my ass!"
"Yes, she is. Now shut up and get back to work."
Craig stopped talking and got back to what he was doing with Penny. Kris slowly worked the dildo into his ass and then started fucking him. At first, he was trying to minimize the thrusts by moving his hips with Kris, but Penny just kept telling him to pay attention to what he was doing to her and not worry about his ass.
"If you do a good job, I might let you fuck me tonight."
Craig put a little more energy into pleasing Penny and pretty soon she was getting that feeling. She used her hands to hold his head as her hips jerked and bounced on the bed. When she finally stopped, she told him to get up and fuck her. Kris pulled out of his ass, and to Penny's surprise, he had quite a hard-on. Kris walked over the dresser and switched to a larger dildo. As soon as he entered Penny, Kris crawled up behind him and thrust the larger dildo inside him with one push.
The harder she fucked him, the harder he fucked Penny until he suddenly tensed as he exploded.
"Don't stop yet, Craig."
He kept fucking her and Kris kept fucking him, keeping him hard until Penny finally had another orgasm. She made him clean her up, licking up all the semen that had seeped out. The whole time, Kris continued fucking his ass until he was done. She finally pulled out and Craig got up and left the room. Penny and Kris went in and showered together, making sure to clean each other's pussy completely.
"Well, now we know the answer about him getting fucked in the ass. You need a strappy of your own to use if you ever feel like fucking him. And I think we are almost ready for the next step."
"The guy?"
"The guy. I can arrange for you to meet him whenever you are ready, and as I said, if you want a practice run with him, or with the three of us, I can arrange that. You need to be comfortable with him before you bring him home."