Join the best erotica focused adult social network now
Login

In which person do you prefer to read or write?

last reply
46 replies
5.7k views
2 watchers
3 likes
Active Ink Slinger
0 likes
I let the story dictate as to how it should be written. Do I want my readers to know how only one person feels, see things, and act in the story. Or all of the people in the story.
Advanced Wordsmith
0 likes
I usually prefer first person stories. I think a story teller talking about how they feel (whether fact or fiction) is easier to believe than a third party telling what happens as an observer. I don't understand how I can tell you what someone else is feeling.
Easily amused
0 likes
Quote by MadMartigan
All of them. At the same time. In the same story. With the same character.


Throw me the link to that story. I'll read it!

I used to be pretty much 3rd person only, and was even bizarrely snobbish about it being somehow better than 1st person. A friend suggested I try 1st person, thinking I needed less distance from the reader. It's been a revelation! My last several stories have been first person (including the one posted here) and it's made me a better writer.

Tintinnabulation - first place (Free Spirit)
Comet Q - second place (Quick and Risqué Sex)
Amnesia - third place (Le Noir Erotique)

0 likes
Quote by Ensorceled
I used to be pretty much 3rd person only, and was even bizarrely snobbish about it being somehow better than 1st person. A friend suggested I try 1st person, thinking I needed less distance from the reader. It's been a revelation! My last several stories have been first person (including the one posted here) and it's made me a better writer.


Okay, J., you were/are a better writer than most and definitely were/are a better writer than myself every damn day of the week, twice on Sundays.

Now, as to the question, I prefer to write in the the third person, although at least a couple, maybe most, of my stories are either first person or a sort of odd first/second person mix. Although Tension is by far the most read, and is a very thorough example of both my writing in the third person and my absolute inability to dismiss an inherent economy of words (read: I do well to submit a Flash of >750 words, total).
Want to spend some time wallowing in a Recommended Read? Pick one! Or two! Or seven!

0 likes
Like most others on here, my stories are a mixture of first and third-person narratives.

I have been known to start in the first person, only to swap to the third halfway in — and vice-versa, of course.


I've never much enjoyed reading second-person narratives but the other week read I read a short story by the author Lorrie Moore in which she employed that perspective, which really drew me in and that I found very funny.

It gave me an idea.

At the time I was struggling with the last chapter of my vampire romp, three chapters of which I had written in the first person. My character had been bitten and was fast on the way to becoming full-time Undead.


After the bite, having her chatter on in her previous neurotic way did not sit right with me. I mean, how rational can an almost undead person still be. It was only then that I realised the error of my way, being stupid enough narrating the story in the first person, to begin with.

But I couldn't be arsed to do a re-write. My solution was a compromise: second person, the narrator's voice as a detached observer, a diminishing presence, the scraps of consciousness of a once sassy human being.



If anyone is interested, this is what I did:


https://www.lushstories.com/stories/horror/-the-vampire-with-a-manga-girl-tattoo.aspx
Active Ink Slinger
0 likes
Generally the third person - but often using an experience I have experienced in the first person with some embellishment.
Sexy Seductive Siren
0 likes
My best stories have been written in the first person, based on my own experiences. When I've tried to deviate from that pattern, my stories have suffered.
Meagan
Active Ink Slinger
1 like
Depends on the story. If it requires multiple viewpoints third person is best. If I'm describing something I have experienced myself then first person is best as I can better describe my internal monologue that way.

I have read a couple of vanilla novels written in the second person. Found them difficult going and the style didn't work for me. I certainly wouldn't attempt to write anything in second person.
Active Ink Slinger
0 likes

I Write first person when I am describing what I have experienced, but when I write a fictional story I write in the third party. Oddly enough my made up stories rarely have an erotic thread, just the occasional tortured relationship which sex invariably screws up. Perhaps my under-mind is trying to tell me something!

Mary Poppins
0 likes

As I'm unsure how to properly construct a story, I just imagine I'm in it and base the story around how I believe I would feel. It really is the only way I know how to write and it seems to work for me. 

Be nice to each other

Active Ink Slinger
0 likes

 I agree with most authors here, I like reading first person.  As to writing, often the story - plot and characters - weave the tale incorporating both first and third person.  In reality, sex is absolutely first person. 

My Stories:

"Excuse Me, Mister" -bondage

"Pontiac Bonneville" - memories and Karma

Let's Give It to the Boy" - first time


Just posted a new story - "Pontiac Bonneville". Check it out at
https://www.lushstories.com/stories/love-stories/-pontiac-bonneville-.aspx
Or my first story, 'Excuse Me, Mister' at
https://www.lushstories.com/stories/exhibitionism/-excuse-me-mister-.aspx
Thanks,
Will
Active Ink Slinger
0 likes
Quote by JohnSwitch1959
Depends on the story. If it requires multiple viewpoints third person is best. If I'm describing something I have experienced myself then first person is best as I can better describe my internal monologue that way.

I have read a couple of vanilla novels written in the second person. Found them difficult going and the style didn't work for me. I certainly wouldn't attempt to write anything in second person.
And having said that, I prove myself wrong by using a combination of first and second person in "What Goes Around Comes Around"! I'm eating my words here; yum, yum!
Dirty Stop-out
0 likes

I tend to write in 3rd person but tend to write it as if it was from the main character’s perspective. In the 6 chapters of Charlotte Sometimes, the reader never leaves Charlotte so we don’t know anything else going on in the world unless observed by or told to Charlotte. 

I prefer 3rd person as 1st person feels too intimate to me when writing, but maybe I’m just weird

Read The Key my latest story and comp entry about a submissive who needs help to be a good girl

2 competition winning stories, 1 Famous story, a smattering of Editor's Picks, a handful of Recommended Reads and one Clitorides award are scattered amongst my stories.

One of a handful of writers to get the Omnium badge for writing in every category

Active Ink Slinger
0 likes

I find second person to be very weird. Like, "who are you talking to?"

First person, particularly when it's someone completely different from me, represents somewhat of a challenge, which I like sometimes.

Third person is somewhat of a default.

My novel, The Society, is available now in the Kindle Store: http://www.amazon.com/The-Society-ebook/dp/B00BPF9U2I
Wild at Heart
0 likes

I like third person. I feel it’s more cinematic.  

Active Ink Slinger
0 likes
Quote by deviantsusie

I tend to write in 3rd person but tend to write it as if it was from the main character’s perspective. In the 6 chapters of Charlotte Sometimes, the reader never leaves Charlotte so we don’t know anything else going on in the world unless observed by or told to Charlotte. 


This is an excellent point. It's a modern technique. It is called the "unreliable narrator" and contrasts with the "omniscient narrator," which has been the norm for most of the history of creative writing. An unreliable narrator reports facts from the perspective of the protagonist. When he reports on the mindset of other characters, it is only his inference of what that mindset is, and it may be incorrect. An omniscient narrator is effectively the local God in the world of the story and always tells the truth (in the sense that he says what the author wants you to believe). He knows precisely the mindset of everyone in the story. You can tell a story with multiple unreliable narrators, in which case you wind up with something like Rashomon, where you can see the same events differently through different characters' eyes. Rashomon with an omniscient narrator would have been little different than an episode of Perry Mason.

My novel, The Society, is available now in the Kindle Store: http://www.amazon.com/The-Society-ebook/dp/B00BPF9U2I
Rookie Scribe
0 likes

I am trying to write a story in third person but I think I use my own voice too much so I am thinking about writing it in first person and then convert over to third. That way I can focus on the character's voice more. Does this seem reasonable or stupid? Has anyone tried this method?