I've never had anal but it sounds interesting only because it is different. Plus, a woman's ass is just about as good as it gets. The shape of her hips and rear is very attractive.
Byron Lord covered it. But I'd like to add the tempting intimacy of sharing the forbidden.
Well for one it is tighter, and i think that the primary reason is the unconventional nature of it. I've only ever done it once, but it was intense. We don't do it often because my wife isn't as comfortable with that area yet. I do believe we are going to try soon though.
I will also add that it is not just about being tighter, the feel is not the same, tight or not. I try to explain it like taking your index finger and pointing it out. Then take your other hand and wrap your thumb and index finger around the base of the extended finger. That is a vagina and cock. Now take your "wrapping" hand and grip it with 3 fingers. THAT is anal! It is not simply how tight they are, but how they grip and the "length" of the gripping.
I would like to say that for me, tighter is not the issue. Just how tight do things need to be? I have a problem with trying to last a long time when in pussy and the feeling is awesome. For me to do anal is not about tighter (not trying to peel a banana), it's about giving her a pleasure and feeling she does not experience every day. It is also a way to share and bond in a different and special way. Sex should be all about making her feel the best multi-orgasmic sexual experience of all time and it should only be better with each sexual experience.
Because it's erotic, naughty, "forbidden" and all that.
Personally, I'm not that much into anal. Or I'd probably be more into it if my girl craved it herself. Seeing her enjoying something doubles my own pleasure. But occasionally some animalistic urge just takes over and you want to put your cock in her inviting asshole, even though her pussy is perfectly good.
I can how that might put you off it lovewhenuswallow, having been on the receiving end of a barium enema many years ago.
Personally, I'm not that interested in anal sex and wouldn't actively seek it out but with the right person in the right circumstances, I wouldn't rule it out. They'd pretty much have to ask for it, though.
not interested in that also. It hurts and i didn't allowed my partner to continue giving me that a year ago.
Is there still any taboo surrounding it? Maybe that's a reason. I love having anal with my girlfriend. Feels amazing, and we both derive great pleasure from it.
Yet another reason is that it can be an emergency form of contraception. Not that I recommend sex without a condom with someone not your regular partner.
The condoms available in East Germany were not exactly the sort of thing you would want to trust for contraceptive purposes.
LOVE IT, its naughty, taboo to some people. She has got to be into it, if not then its pointless to me, I love when a woman asks for it, guess its the "Lady in the streets, freak in the sheets" kind of thing. But the simple answer for me... I love it when she is down.
The tightness is often a thing guys like.
I have had one girlfriend who liked anal, because it was easier for her to get a bigger orgasm.
But personally i like the pussy, like to give my women a nice cream-pie and Anal is just something that happens if she wants it, it's not something i go for, with any women i meet.
The feeling of giving a women anal is pretty good, it's tight, warm and you feel everything inside her ass.
When we lose the right to be different, we lose the privilege to be free.
Charles Evans Hughes
Both the American people and nations that censor the internet should understand that our government is committed to helping promote internet freedom.
Hillary Clinton I love this quote, no country in the world has put more into censorship, control and surveillance, then USA the last 10 years. lol
Funny enough, I'm really not trying to be ladylike in the bedroom. That takes all the fun out of it. 
