This is an aspect of Lush I've tried and failed to understand! Obviously, what a writer thinks is their best work is as subjective as what they think other people's best is...I think A Christmas Carol was Dickens best, but he thought it was David Copperfield.
Let's be honest, you can game the system by loading it with certain tags....if, anal, first time etc.
I thought this tale of an old man growing obsessed with his actress neighbour deserved more love, but if I'd finished it in time and entered it to the obsession comp I wrote it for, it probably would have, so thats on me! https://www.lushstories.com/stories/voyeur/the-girl-in-killer-rabbits-from-hell
This one is my personal favourite and is sort of mid table in terms of engagement. Take a trip back to ancient Egypt with https://www.lushstories.com/stories/historical/takabuti
The Girl in "Killer Rabbits From Hell"
A new neighbour sparks a dangerous obsession
Voyeur