Quote by NickiC
I did not answer your question...PJ Harvey.
acutally, PJ Harvey totally rocks - i can respect that

Quote by She
Those bunch of dead people did something under their 30 years of life more than you and I could do in our lifetime, not to mention their fucking talent, which you have to agree to.
They lived in different music era, its not to compare to, but their popularity can be measured, easily, and I dont think Mr.Kanye can fill the stadium of 100.000 people which granfathers Rolling Stones did on their tour in the begining of century outside the USA of course.![]()
Quote by PrincessC
The urban dictionary isn't what I'd call a source worth quoting but you are right in the sense that it is used in many different ways to mean different things. Since I love rock music I wouldn't call Kanye a rock star but if society wants to use that term to describe him then so be it I guess.![]()
Quote by PrincessC
Rock Star denotes the Rock genre. Kanye makes noise which some people do seem to find appealing but it is definitely not rock!
Though somebody mentioned that the term "rock star" has transcended genre and has been used to refer to some musical icons that are not necessarily rockers, it doesn't mean that they are correct in their usage of the term.
Also, while Jimmy Page is still alive he holds the title of biggest rock star on the planet. I mean seriously, who doesn't like Led Zeppelin.
Quote by LadyX
That taste is subjective. My daddy's parents thought Marvin Gaye and Diana Ross were worthless musicians. Not to say that Justin Bieber = Marvin Gaye; I'm just saying, new rock stars rise up, then everyone that treasures previous generations of rock stars declares them worthless. There weren't too many 50 year olds that thought a whole lot of the Beatles when they showed up either.
Speaking of the Beatles, not sure how you feel about them, but John Lennon did once declare them to be bigger than Jesus. If that ain't calling your own shot, I don't know what is.