Continued from Neighborly Love Part 5: 

Lexi finally arrived home and was relieved to find no cars in the driveway. She pulled into the garage, shut the door behind her, and rushed inside. The dogs, always happy to see anyone who came through the door, happily greeted Lexi with wagging tails. She hurriedly pushed them away and desperately removed the wet clothes from the washing machine. Lexi ripped off her old sweatshirt and threw it, along with her cum-stained blouse, into the wash. They were quickly joined by her shorts and panties as Lexi stripped naked in the washroom. The evidence of her naughty morning would soon be washed away.

A steamy shower later and Lexi was cleansed of her dirty deed. The hot water felt so good as it careened down her skin. Lexi hung her head in the shower and allowed the water to run. Think. She needed time to think. 

Later that afternoon, Lexi heard her husband’s car pull into the driveway. When Jake popped through the door, Lexi gave him a peck on the cheek and told him she needed to run to the store to pick up a few things for dinner. Lexi still felt a bit strange from her activities in the bookstore and needed to get out of the house to be away from her husband.

While she was gone, Jack picked up Lexi’s iPad to scroll the internet. When he opened the browser, the most recently visited webpage was still active. It was a pornographic website.

Jake smiled from ear to ear. “Well, well, well, Ms. Lexi. Just what have you been looking at you naughty, little slut?” Jake laughed and was curious to see what his wife had been viewing on her iPad. He hit the “history” button and the webpages shocked him. Gangbangs. Big cocks. Cock queens. MMF. Cheating wives. Spit roast.

Jake could feel his dick coming to life when he saw the porn his wife was viewing. “Damn! Lexi sure likes some nasty shit!” thought Jake and it got him highly aroused.   

Jake put down the iPad and proceeded to the master bedroom. Just as he had developed a habit of checking his wife’s iPad, Jake also liked to check the contents of Lexi’s sex toy bag to see if she been giving them any action. Upon removing the contents, he found the new black dildo Lexi purchased earlier in the day.

Jake had always purchased Lexi’s sex toys and was surprised to find a new addition to her collection. He was shocked she had purchased such a large dildo. He repacked the bag and put it away in the exact position he found it. Lexi’s new dildo made Jake incredibly horny and he thought he would try his luck that night. While Lexi was at the store, their daughter called to say she would be spending the night with one of her girlfriends. Jake and Lexi would have the house all to themselves.  

Later that night, when he lay in bed next to his wife, Jack rubbed Lexi’s ass, hoping to initiate sex. Lexi quickly pulled away and did not say a word. Jake was taken aback by this reaction and asked if everything was ok.

Lexi rolled over and said, “Jake, we need to talk.”

Jake reached out to touch his wife and she stopped him with her hand.

Lexi looked annoyed and said, “Jake, stop it.  I’m serious.”

Jake sat up and asked what was wrong.

Lexi looked at Jake and said, “I know what is going on.”

Jake looked surprised and replied, “What are you talking about?”

Lexi crossed her arms and retorted, “You know, your little fling with Sara next door.”

Jake was flummoxed and his stomach dropped as he thought, “How in the hell did she find out?” He stammered a few words before finally getting out, “Sara? We can’t stand each other. You know that.”

Lexi rolled her eyes and huffed, “Jake, cut the shit! I saw a video of you two fucking! You goddamn bastard! How could you do this to me!”

Jake was at a loss for words. After a few seconds, he blurted out, “Video? What video are you talking about? I am not in any video.”

Lexi grabbed her phone from the nightstand. She glared at Jake and said, “Oh really? Well, why don’t we watch your little video? You are always pestering me to watch porn, so let’s watch some porn!”

Jake reached for Lexi’s phone and she violently slapped it away. “Get your fucking hands away from me!” Lexi hissed.

Lexi streamed her phone to the television on the wall and played the pet-cam video of Jake and Sara’s sexual escapade. Sara was on top of Jake riding his cock while he sucked on her tits.

Jake began to speak, but Lexi drowned him out by turning up the volume to maximum. The television speakers blared, “Umm, oh Jake! Fuck me, Daddy! Oooh, your cock feels so good in my tight little pussy!”

Jake said something but Lexi could not hear him over the television. Frustrated, Jake made his way to the television and manually turned it off.

Lexi sneered at her husband and said, “What’s the matter, Daddy? Don’t want to watch yourself on TV?”

Jake felt like he had been hit by a truck. While he searched for words, Lexi beat him to the punch.

“So, how long has this been going on? Tell me!” asked Lexi.

“About two months…” Jake’s voice trailed.

“Two months! Jesus Christ! So, this video wasn’t just a onetime fling?” Lexi barked. “How many times have you and Sara fucked?”

“Lexi, I am so sorry,” pleaded Jake.

Lexi screamed, “How many times! How many times did you fuck her, you son of a bitch!”

Jake looked at the ground and quietly said, “I don’t know. A dozen times, I guess.”

Lexi’s head nearly exploded! “A DOZEN TIMES!” Suddenly, any guilt she had about fucking Alan next door, her threesome in the hotel, and her glory hole visit vanished into thin air.

“So, did you actually play golf today or were you out fucking your little slut?” Lexi growled.

Jake quickly responded, “I was golfing. Honest. Call any of my buddies. They will tell you.”

Lexi laughed, “Sure, like I would trust any of your friends.” Lexi then used the remote control to turn the TV back on. She picked up her phone and said to Jake, “Since you like porn videos so much, I have one I want you to watch.”

Jake panicked, thinking, “Does she have another video of me and Sara? How the hell is she getting these videos?”

Jake looked across the room at the television on the wall. He was expecting to see another video of him and Sara but was shocked at what appeared on the screen. His naked wife was on her hands and knees with a man fucking her from behind while she sucked on a cock.

“Lexi, what the hell is this?” Jake said with confusion in his voice.

Lexi glared at Jake and said, “If you want to have any chance in hell of saving this marriage, you are going to watch this entire video.”

Jake attempted to speak, but Lexi cut him off. “Not one fucking word Jake. Not...one…word. We will talk after you watch this video all the way until the end.”

Jake swallowed his words and did as Lexi commanded. He watched the man Lexi was blowing shake his cum onto her face as she was being spit roasted. The man behind Lexi was fucking the shit out of her, slamming her like a jack hammer. Lexi appeared to be enjoying every minute of her fucking as she moaned endlessly and grabbed the bedsheets like her life depended on it. When the man behind Lexi pulled out, Jake saw that he was hung like a horse. He winced when he saw the giant cock point at Lexi’s face and unleash spurt after spurt of cum onto her skin and into her mouth.

The video came to an end and Lexi turned off the television. “So, yeah. After watching your video with Sara, I decided that I deserved a little fun for myself.”

Although Jake had been sleeping with his next door neighbor Sara for the better part of two months, he was furious after watching the video of his wife having a threesome. “Fucking hell, Lexi! A threesome? Who the hell were those guys?”

Lexi nonchalantly said, “I don’t know. Just some guys I picked up at the hotel bar during my business trip. I never even caught their names.”

“You fucking whore!” Jake snapped.

Lexi’s face was expressionless as she fired back, “Oh yeah, I forgot to mention that I also fucked Alan.”

“Alan? Alan from next door?” Jake asked.

Lexi smiled. “Yes. Alan. Sara’s husband Alan. He was the one who showed me the video. You two never noticed that the pet camera was live streaming your little fuck session. I guess you were too busy sticking your dick into Sara.”

“Jesus, Lexi!” Jake could not believe what he was hearing.

Jake shook his head and stared at the floor, his world turned upside down in a matter of minutes. The room went silent.

Lexi broke the awkward silence when she said, “Jake, I have always been faithful to you. I have NEVER cheated. When I saw the video of you and Sara, I just lost it. I wanted to KILL you. I fucked these men for revenge. I never would have done this if you had not cheated on me.”

“But Lexi, two men? A threesome? You were being spit roasted, for God’s sake!” Jake pleaded.

Lexi looked at her husband. “It just happened, Jake. It’s not like I was looking to have a threesome.”

“And you let him cum on your face. You never even let ME cum on your face!” Jake snapped.

Lexi took a deep breath and said, “Look, Jake, let’s not get into things we don’t do to one another. In your little video, you did plenty of things with Sara that you never do with me.”

Jake was upset with Lexi but felt shame at the same time. He knew that his wife had always been faithful to him and he was the one who shattered their trust. In fact, his tryst with Sara from next door was not the first time he had strayed from his marriage. He so badly wanted to scream at the top of his lungs about what Lexi had done, but he couldn’t.

Jake swallowed his pride and said, “Lexi. I am sorry. I really am.”

Lexi saw that Jake was looking remorseful. Her attitude towards him softened a touch. “Do you love her, Jake?”

Jake took his wife by the hand. “NO! Absolutely not! I love YOU, Lexi,” Jake said with desperation in his voice. “I don’t know what I have been thinking these past few months.”

Lexi held Jake’s hand and stared at him intently. “Jake, if we are going to get through this, I think we need to get everything out in the open. I want to ask you some questions and I need you to promise to answer them truthfully. Ok?”

Jake smiled like a scolded puppy and said, “Yes, Lexi. I will answer anything you ask with complete honesty. I would also like to ask you questions. Can we both be honest with one another?”

Lexi loved seeing her husband squirm and almost felt sorry for him…almost. “Ok. I can do that. But no matter what we say, neither of us can get mad or start another fight. We are doing this to clear the air. I will go first since you are the one who created this mess.”

Lexi asked, “Where did you first fuck Sara?”

Jake said, “In our pool.”

Lexi thought, “Our pool? Jesus! I hope you cleaned it after, you bastard.”

Jake said, “Ok, my turn. Did you enjoy fucking Alan?”

Lexi said, “No. It was awful. He came in like two minutes.”

Jake felt a sense of relief hearing this. He abhorred the thought of his next door neighbor fucking his wife, but thought turnaround was fair play.

Lexi asked, “Did you ever fuck Sara in our bed?”

Jake said, “No.”

Lexi was relieved. Had they done so, she wanted to burn the bed and get a new one.

Jake asked, “Did you enjoy having two men at the same time?”

Lexi replied, “Yes.”

Jake asked, “Did they both fuck you?”

Lexi said, “Yes, multiple times.”

Jake winced inside at hearing this but remembered their agreement. No judgement. No getting angry.

Lexi said, “My turn. Did you ever fuck Sara in the ass?”

Jake answered, “Yes, many times.”

Lexi asked, “Did you like it?”

Jake said, “Yes, very much.”

Lexi had never allowed Jake into her ass. She felt a touch of sadness knowing that her husband experienced this act with another woman. Perhaps she would remedy that situation, she thought.

Jake said, “One of the men in the video you showed me looked to have a big dick. Was he bigger than me?”

Lexi responded, “Yes. He was fucking huge. His cock was much bigger than yours.”

This hurt Jake very much and he took a deep breath while looking at the ground. Lexi could see that he was hurt and felt both vindication and pity.

Jake asked, “Did he make you cum?”

Yes. I had at least a half dozen orgasms that night.”

Tears began to well in the corners of Jake’s eyes. “Jesus Christ! Six orgasms? Fucking two strangers? Spit roasted with a cum facial?” Jake’s mind was cracking. He finally broke down and began to cry.

Between heavy sobs, Jake pleaded, “I am sorry, Lexi. I am so fucking sorry. Please forgive me! I love you!”

Lexi enjoyed seeing Jake grovel. She had accomplished her goal. Unfortunately, things could never be the same for their marriage.

Lexi took Jake by the hand and softly said, “Jake, you are my husband and I forgive you.” She kissed him gently on the head and took him into her arms. They held each other in silence for what seemed an eternity but was only seconds in reality.

Lexi broke their embrace and looked at Jake. “Baby, I forgive you but I have some conditions moving forward if we are going to save this marriage.”

Jake felt relieved to hear that Lexi had forgiven him and was ready to comply with any of his wife’s demands. He looked at her and said, “Anything.”

“Firstly, I need to know that you also forgive me for the sex I have had with other men.”

Jake quickly replied, “Yes, I forgive you. I know you would not have done any of this had I not slept with Sara.”

Lexi smiled upon hearing this. Having her husband’s forgiveness was very important to her. She moved on to her next condition. “Secondly, I need to tell you something. While having sex on my business trip, I discovered that I like big cocks. Jake, your dick has always kept me happy and satisfied, but I never knew the feeling of being filled the way Tom’s cock filled me.”

Jake’s face went slightly white upon hearing this and he retorted, “Tom? I thought you said you did not know their names?”

Lexi smiled sheepishly. “Well, I lied about that. But everything else I said was true.”

Lexi continued her second condition. “Jake, I like big cocks. Now that I have experienced one, I cannot go without them. I love your dick. I always have. However, if we are going to stay together moving forward, I need you to allow me an occasional fuck with a large cock.”

Jake had a look of confusion. “What are you saying? You want an open marriage? You want to fuck other men?” Jake had known his wife for nearly 20 years. This was so out of character for Lexi.

“Not all the time, Jake. Just an occasional fuck from a big cock to scratch my itch. Baby, I love you but you just do not have the size I need. I know it is not your fault. Well, actually it is your fault. I would have never known the feeling of a giant dick had you not cheated on me,” Lexi said matter of factly. “We will stay happily married. Everything will go on as normal. I will just get fucked by a big cock every now and then.”

Jake sighed, resigned to his fate. “This really means that much to you?”

Lexi sternly said, “Yes it does. I need this, Jake, and you are going to let me have it.”

Jaked nodded his head. “Ok, Lexi. Ok. You can do this, but our daughter can never know.”

Lexi giggled and bit her lip. She was so excited that she now had her husband’s permission to enjoy an occasional big dick. Lexi kissed her husband on the lips and said, “Thank you, Baby. Of course, this will be our little secret.”

Jake reached out and held his wife’s hand. “…and Lexi, one more thing. If you are going to fuck the occasional man with a large cock, I want something as well.”

Lexi nodded and said, “Ok, Baby, what is it that you want?”

“I want to keep fucking Sara. I love you, but I also like her a lot. You are my wife and the mother of my child. I will never leave you. If our marriage is moving to this new chapter and you are going to fuck other men, I want to fuck other women as well,” replied Jake.

Lexi could not believe where their marriage was headed. Just a few short weeks ago she and Jake were the epitome of suburban bliss. Now they were having an open marriage?

Lexi pursed her lips and said, “Ok, Jake. Ok. You can fuck other women so long as it remains strictly sex. If things move towards love, you need to promise to end things immediately. Also, you can never bring them to our home.”

Jake smiled and said, “Thank you, Lexi. The same goes for you as well. None of the men you fuck can ever come to our house.”

“Of course, Jake. I would never do that,” Lexi calmly said.

Jake and Lexi stared at each other for a while.

Jake broke the ice and said, “So are we cool? Do you still love me, Lexi?”

Lexi smiled and leaned towards her husband. “Yes, Baby. We are cool.” She closed her eyes and kissed her husband on the lips. “I love you.”

That night, Jake and Lexi made love like never before. Passionate would be an understatement in describing their feelings for one another that night. In spite of everything, their marriage now seemed stronger than ever.

Both Jake and Lexi were excited to see what the future held.

To be continued…