Join the best erotica focused adult social network now
Login

First Of Firsts For Hailey

"Joe, Britt, and Carman find a fourth for their group."

15
2 Comments 2
1.3k Views 1.3k
4.9k words 4.9k words

Author's Notes

"This is a continuation of the saga with Joe, his sister Britt, and their girlfriend Carman."

Britt, her brother Joe, and their girlfriend Carman (yes, they are a throuple) were excited for Saturday's frat party. On Thursday, Carman asked Britt if she wanted to shop for a new outfit.

After the last frat party (refer to Cumming at a University Near You story), the throuple had decided to move in together, but that had not happened yet. Since it had been a while since the two girls had been together alone, Carman's suggestion to go shopping on Thursday felt like the perfect opportunity, and Britt jumped at the chance immediately.

After class on Thursday, Britt rushed home to get freshened up and wait for Carman. Joe was there and asked, “Hey, what’s the rush?” as Britt burst through the front door.

“Oh...nothing really, just freshening up before Carman gets here. We are heading out to the store to shop for some new outfits for the party on Saturday,” explained Britt.

“Umm, okay, sure. There's nothing special about this; it’s just a repeat of the last frat party. I’m sure you have plenty of nice outfits to wear,” Joe said.

“Yeah, I know, but it’s been a while since Carman, and I have hung out just the two of us, and we really want new outfits. Wait a minute...why am I even explaining myself to you?”

“I don’t know, sis,” laughed Joe.

“Well, fuck you, bro! I don’t have time to explain myself to you. Carman is on her way over, and I need to get ready.” Britt said with a loving but sarcastic smile and tone.

“ Fuck me?... I’m sure you will,” said Joe with a tantalizing smile.

As Britt turned to walk towards her bedroom, she flipped Joe the bird. She then spread her legs slightly and bent over at the waist. Using her extended middle finger, she traced it down the crack of her ass and through the plump folds of her pussy. Britt could already feel the heat building through her tight yoga pants.

Britt looked at herself in the mirror and thought to herself, ‘I need to get laid.’ While washing her face and straightening her hair, Britt decided she was going to bring a dildo with her. She thought, ‘If the opportunity presents itself, she and Carman can have a bit of fun in the dressing room.’

Just then, Britt heard Carman coming through the front door, and Joe telling her that she was in the bathroom getting ready.

“I’ll be out in just a moment,” announced Britt.

Britt ran over to her bedroom, grabbed her favorite smaller dildo from the nightstand, stuffed it in her handbag, and made her way to the living room.

“Heya,” said Britt as she hugged and kissed Carman on the lips.

“Ready to go?” asked Carman.

“Yeah, bye Joe, be back later,” Britt gave Joe a hug and a quick peck.

“Bye, Joe,” said Carman, but she leaned in tighter for her hug and gave Joe an open-mouth kiss, darting her tongue around.

At the store, Britt and Carman found a couple of outfits each to try on. Britt found a cute mini skirt with a loose-fitting blouse top, and a short tennis skirt with a form-fitting tank. Carman found similar outfits but in different colors.

They headed to the dressing rooms and asked the attendant if they could be in the same room, as they wanted to help decide the best outfit. The attendant took them to the last room in a long hallway. The room was twice as big as the other rooms and had a full floor-to-ceiling door.

‘This was perfect,’ thought Britt. She had been getting hornier and hornier by the minute, knowing that she had the dildo in her bag and just imagining Carman in the outfits she had selected.

Now in the privacy of the dressing room, Britt took a seat on the bench. “You, try on your outfits first,” she told Carman.

“Ok,” said Carman as she hung the clothes on the other hook.

Carman turned towards the mirror and started taking off her clothes. Britt knew she wasn’t wearing a bra and could see her perfectly perky tits with her erect nipples on display in the mirror. Carman then grabbed the waist of her leggings and started pulling them down. Britt saw she was wearing her favorite red lace thongs.

As Carman bent over to take off her leggings, Britt ran her finger up Carman’s pussy slit from front to back. Carman gasped slightly as she looked back, biting her lower lip. She instinctively spread her legs, giving more access to her love. Britt slipped her finger past the edge of the fabric covering Carman’s pussy.

Britt, already feeling the heat was now feeling the wetness increase as she fingered Carman. She circled around Carman’s clit and slipped a couple of fingers into her hole. At the same time, she placed her thumb on Carman’s asshole, applying slight pressure.

Britt then pulled out the dildo from her bag. She held it up to her mouth and wrapped her lips around it as she sucked on it. Carman turned around. “You brought that with you?” asked Carman.

“Yeah, I have been so horny lately and need to get laid,” said Carman as she positioned the base of the dildo on her crotch like it was a strap-on. “Here, sit on it so I can fuck you,” directed Britt.

Carman turned back around and watched in the mirror as she slowly lowered herself down on the dildo. Britt held the dildo in place with one hand and played with Carman’s tits with the other.

Between the riding of the dildo, playing with her own clit, and Britt playing with her nipples, Carman started cumming in no time flat.

Once her orgasm subsided, Carman and Britt traded places, but before Britt could get in position to take the dildo in, Carman stopped her. “I need to taste your pussy right now, bend over, and let me eat it from behind,” Carman demanded.

Britt bent over, and Carman spread her out, giving her direct access to her dripping pussy. “Holy fucking shit, girl, you are already dripping wet. You have pussy juices stringing from your pussy to your thigh!” exclaimed Carman.

Using her tongue, Carman licked up the strings before diving deep into Britt’s pussy. She licked circles around her clit and stabbed at her entrance as deep as her tongue would go. Sensing Britt was about to cum. Carman grabbed the dildo, still wet and frothy with her own juices, and pushed it all the way to the hilt into Britt’s pussy.

This drove Britt over the edge, and her orgasm hit like a freight train. Britt’s knees buckled under her, taking her to all fours on the floor.

After recovering, both girls tried on their outfits and agreed that the tennis skirt and tank top were the best look.

They realized they had been in the dressing room a lot longer than they should have and were scared the attendant was going to be mad. As they opened the door, they didn’t see the attendant anywhere. They quickly exited the dressing room area, leaving the miniskirts and blouses on the returns rack.

The next few days passed without any excitement.

It was now Saturday afternoon, and the frat party was starting in a couple of hours. Carman had spent the day over at Britt and Joe’s apartment, swimming in the heated pool and relaxing in the hot tub.

While getting ready, Britt decided she didn’t like the look of the tennis skirt with the sewn-in liner. Carman agreed, and she too decided to cut out the liner. When Britt put the tennis skirt back on and bent over, it completely showed off her ass and pussy.

“Well, I guess everyone who looks will get a good view then,” chuckled Britt. Both girls decided to have fun and not wear any panties.

A few hours into the party, Britt searched for a place to sit, but the room was packed, and every chair was taken. Scanning the crowd, she spotted Carman perched on a frat brother’s lap. “There you are! I’ve been looking for you,” Britt said.

“Yeah, I met Jameson here. He’s a new pledge, and this is his pledge, brother Troy. We got tired and decided to take a break as soon as these chairs were free,” explained Carman.

Britt eyed Troy; he was just her type: olive complexion, fit, and very good-looking.

Carman knew he was Britt’s type. “Why don’t you sit on his lap? I’m sure he wouldn’t mind.”

Clearing her throat, Britt leaned in to whisper to Carman, “I know you remember I am not wearing underwear.”

“Oh, I remember, and I am also not wearing underwear, remember?” Carman reminded Britt. “If you could see under my skirt, you would see that I am sitting here with Jameson’s cock buried in my pussy. So I suggest you do the same for Troy.”

Britt stepped back, biting her lower lip, and looked at Troy. Britt took a seat on Troy’s lap and could instantly feel the bulge growing. Britt leaned back and whispered to Troy, “I’m not wearing anything under this skirt, and I really need you inside me right now.”

Troy shifted his position slightly as Carman lifted her weight off of him. Luckily, her skirt hid Troy’s movements of unzipping his fly and pulling his now fully erect cock out. His cock sprang out, coming to rest at Britt’s opening.

Britt lowered herself slowly, feeling Troy’s girth stretch her as she descended. She began to wonder if she would ever reach his base. Finally, he was fully in her. Britt looked over at Carman, and Carman gave a knowing wink.

A new party mix kicked in, the heavy bass setting a pulse for the room. Carman and Britt caught the beat, bouncing rhythmically as they fucked Troy and Jameson.

Soon, Britt started to feel the orgasm building inside her. She looked over at Carman and noticed she was already into her orgasm. It then happened to Britt. She felt the wave of ecstasy surge over her; her pussy gripped Troy’s cock tighter with every thrust he made.

It was then she felt Troy stiffen up and try to pull her off his cock. Britt wasn’t having it; she needed to be filled with his seed, she needed to feel his cock explode inside her, throbbing, pumping, draining his balls. Britt sat down further, not getting off his cock.

When Troy’s cock finished twitching, Britt leaned back into his chest, gave him a peck on the cheek, and said, “Thank you, I needed that and it felt like you did too.”

Britt looked over to see Carman straddling Jameson’s lap, lost in a heavy embrace. Pulling back from the kiss, Carman caught Britt’s eye. “Let’s get out of here,” she suggested. “Let’s go back to Joe.”

“Yeah, let’s go, we’ve had enough fun tonight and ruined these poor boys' night,” laughed Britt.

As the two girls stood up, a load of cum dripped from each of their pussies, landing on the guys. “Oh, sorry, boys, looks like we made a mess,” teased Carman.

Jameson then asked,” Who is Joe?”

“Yeah, he’s my brother and her boyfriend,” answered Britt without letting on to the true nature of their relationship. “We’ll meet up with you guys sometime and introduce you.”

“Wait a minute, is your brother Joe Ryan, and your Brittney Ryan?” asked Troy.

“Yep, Troy, you just fucked Joe’s sister, the one your senior alumni brother warned you about on orientation night,” laughed Carman.

Laughing too, “Fucking stop it, Carman, leave these poor boys alone,” Britt said.

Their walk home looked like a classic college "walk of shame," yet Britt and Carman felt victorious. There was a thrill in the secrecy—having been creampied right under everyone's noses without anyone being the wiser. As they walked, they could both feel what was left of the cum inside them working its way out.

Britt swiped her finger through her folds, gathering a dollop of cum. Before she could do anything with it, Carman grabbed her hand and sucked Britt’s finger clean. Remarking, “Savory but slightly sweet. Troy must eat a lot of pineapple.”

Carman then fingered out a bit of cum from her pussy and offered it up to Britt, who eagerly took it. Britt savored the flavor for a moment, pretending to be a sommelier of cum, “There is a sophisticated salt-forward minerality here, followed by a lingering, nutty finish reminiscent of smoked almond. It’s a bold, full-bodied selection that demands to be savored slowly, ideally paired with the quiet, smug satisfaction of a secret well-kept. Truly, a vintage that prioritizes depth over volume.”

Both of the girls laughed so hard as they continued their walk home. The longer they walked, the more cum dripped from their pussies. As they approached the apartment building, they heard Joe calling out to them, “Hey, Britt and Carman, hold the door. for us.”

The girls turned around and saw Joe walking with a girl they didn’t know but had seen at the frat party. “Oh, hey, Joe,” said Carman.

“Who is this young lass?” asked Britt in a playful but seductive manner.

“This is Hailey, and this is Carman, and this is Britt,” said Joe, making the introductions.

“Hey, so you guys are Joe’s roommates?” asked Hailey

“Yeah, actually, I am, but Carman here is our friend and lives in those apartments over there.”

Joe then stepped up to Carman, taking her in a tight embrace and kissing her on the mouth. He then stepped over to Britt and did the same.

They could see the intrigue written all over Hailey’s face; she looked completely mystified. “See, Hailey, we’re in an open relationship throuple,” Joe explained.

“Look, I can see you're confused, and we would love to explain everything to you if you would like to come up to the apartment. But if that's not your thing or you need more time to take it all in, that's cool too,” said Joe.

QueenAlice
Online Now!
Lush Cams
QueenAlice

“Yeah, no pressure at all, and if you want, we can walk you home to ensure you get home safe,” offered Britt.

“Well, umm, this is a surprise, and certainly didn’t see my night going like this when I left my dorm...But, fuck it! Do it for the plot!” Hailey said with a tinge of nervousness.

“Are you sure? Like, we don’t want you to feel pressured into anything,” said Carman.

“No, it’s cool, I mean, we are just going to talk, and you guys are going to explain how this all works. And shit, I think I might be getting turned on just by talking about this and all,” Hailey said with more confidence.

“Ok, awesome, and if at any time you don’t feel comfortable and want to leave, we won’t be judging. We know we’re in a non-conventional relationship, and it’s certainly not most people's cup of tea.” Joe said.

Once in the apartment, Joe went to the kitchen to gather the ingredients to make drinks for everyone. Britt, Carman, and Hailey sat in the living room and got comfortable.

Hailey, excited but nervous about what she was about to learn about herself, started the conversation, “So...how did this thing become, well, a thing?”

Britt sat for a second, deciding where to begin and how much to disclose about her and her brother, “Ok, so, Joe and I, umm...”

“Yeah, they were neighbors from back home, and when Britt was accepted into university, Joe offered his spare bedroom. The families are close, and Joe has always seen Britt as his brat little sister,” interrupted Carman after sensing Britt was at a loss for words on how to explain their situation to a stranger.

“So I guess one thing led to another, and you guys are living together now, and well, you end up in bed together?” inquired Hailey.

“Yeah, it’s actually a pretty funny story. As I was saying, Carman and I attended a frat party at Sigma Nu with Joe at the beginning of last semester. While there, one of the brothers asked Carman and me if we wanted to participate in a gloryhole he had set up in his room.”

“Wait, a gloryhole at the frat house? Like a hole where dudes stick their dick through a hole, and you suck it? Or, like, where the girl is just lying there hidden from the waist up and naked from the waist down, getting fucked by the different guys? Like what kind of party was this?” asked Hailey, appearing to be very interested as she leaned in, waiting for the answers.

“Yeah, it was a pimps and hoes themed party, and James had cut a hole in the wall of his closet, big enough for guys to stick their dicks through. Carman and I decided it would be fun and went into the closet. We sucked a couple of dicks and were getting super horny,” continued Britt.

Carman then jumped in, “Then we decided that the next dick that was stuck in we would fuck. And, well, that was Joe’s, but at the time, we didn’t know it was Joe.”

“Yeah, I didn’t know either,” Joe said. “I was just told by one of the brothers about the gloryhole, and it was available for me to use,” Joe continued. “Fuck it! I said and went it. I mean, like, what dude wouldn’t jump at the chance to get their dick sucked? Right?”

“Like, when did you guys put two and two together that you guys just sucked your roommate’s dick?” Hailey said, pointing at Britt, “And wait, did you fuck Joe too?”

“Yep, we sure did. We both sucked and then fucked the mysterious dick sticking through the hole. When Joe blew his load, the first wad landed on Britt’s tits. Britt then directed the aim at my face, and I took the next few loads into my mouth and down my chin,” explained Carman.

“Oh, that sounds so hot,” Hailey said as she groped at her own tits.

“It was, I’m not gonna lie,” said Britt. “Carman licking the cum off my tits, and I licked the cum from her chin.”

Britt moved to sit beside Hailey on the couch. Britt then took Hailey’s hand and placed it on her own tits. A burning desire was growing in Hailey’s eyes. Hailey started massaging Britt’s tits on top of the thin fabric...

To continue reading this story you must be a member.

Join Now
Published 
Written by Spearmintpangolin
Loved the story?
Show your appreciation by tipping the author!

Continue Series

Cumming at a University Near You
Previous Story

Cumming at a University Near You

Get Free access to these great features

  • Create your own custom Profile
  • Share your erotic stories with the community
  • Curate your own reading list and follow authors
  • Enter exclusive competitions
  • Chat with like minded people
  • Tip your favourite authors

Comments