Part 2:

I struggled with the decision if I should tell my 17-year-old cousin girlfriend, Jess, about my affair with my 16-year-old ex-girlfriend, Michelle. I knew it was the right thing to do, but it could potentially ruin my relationship with Jess. She meant the world to me. I couldn’t deny my feelings for my ex-girlfriend. I mean, she really couldn’t get enough of my cock! I couldn’t stop thinking about them over the weekend.

The weekend passed, leaving me with a mind racing with indecision. My lover's cousin seemed distant and unreachable, making matters worse. On Monday, Michelle intensified her efforts to convince me to continue cheating on my cousin. She knew all my weaknesses and triggers. It was spirit week, and she arrived at school in her cheerleader uniform. While that alone would be problematic, she had her hair styled in pigtails, which she knows drives me wild. I loved using them during her deep-mouth hugs, which she so expertly gave me.

Throughout the day, she would take every chance to rub against me in the hallways or at my locker. The last time she was at my locker, she asked me to meet her in the gym during the next study hall. My study hall was in the middle of the day. I struggled with giving into any of her requests, but I gave in and texted Michelle I was on my way. As requested, I met her in the gym. As I entered the doors, she grabbed my hand quickly and abruptly headed towards the back side of the bleachers. Since there was activity in the gym at the time, I guess she didn’t want to get us in trouble.

“Jeez, Michelle, what’s up? Why are we here?” I asked, feeling concerned.

“You’re such an idiot sometimes,” she replied while squatting down and grabbing at my zipper.

“Michelle! Are you crazy? We’re at school, and I can’t do this anymore! "I exclaimed, feeling worried.

Michelle remained completely unfazed as she handled my belt and reached into my jeans. She grabbed my dick and maneuvered it around my leg, eventually pulling it out of my briefs and exposing it to the open air.

“God, I love this cock!” she exclaimed while licking her lips before taking it into her mouth.

“Fuck, Michelle! For real, you don’t listen!”

She pulled off quickly and laughed at me.

“OK, then make me stop, bet you won’t!”

She instantly went right back at it, and all I did was melt.

She had me by the balls…literally!

I glanced around to make sure no one was watching, but we were in a secluded spot under the bleachers, out of sight. I also thought about the need to be quiet but quickly realized the gym teacher was blowing his whistle and shouting drills at the class, so I wasn’t too worried about that either.

As a distracting whistle blew, Michelle forcefully thrust my cock down her throat, causing me to grunt in response.

I gazed down at the most stunning girl in the school. Her eyes fixed on me as I thrust my entire member in and out of her throat. Her mouth was wide open, and her throat bulged out with each thrust. She reached down and inserted three fingers into her clearly wet pussy. She wasn’t even wearing panties! She pulled off abruptly and decided to ask me a question. I was thrown off a bit as she left my cock bouncing in the air with loads of spit dripping down the head and shaft.

“So, you mentioned your girlfriend is an anal-only slut? Did she tell you why?” she asked, as she reinserted my cock while looking up at me, waiting for a response. It was challenging to respond to questions given the situation.

“Uh, well…” I had to think quickly. The real reason would violate our rules! I couldn’t tell her that I don’t want to potentially get my first cousin pregnant! So, I opted for the next best thing that came to mind.

“Okay, so she mentioned that her vagina is very small and shallow. Besides that, she enjoys the sensation of taking it all deeper into her ass than she can ever take in her vagina. She finds the taboo aspect of it turns her on more than usual and even more enjoyable, and she even tells me that she cums harder from it.”

Michelle came up for air, accepting the answer.

"Well, that makes a lot of sense, actually,” she said while taking both hands and starting to stroke me. She stared at her hands barely fitting around it. She switched it up to a double hand job so she could talk for a moment. She spat on the head, continuously making it wet while talking.

“I’d like to meet her. I'd love to learn from her. I’m always eager to improve. I’d love to acquire the anal skills she must possess. Besides, you won’t feel so guilty about cheating if she’s with you when you fuck me! Anyway, we can discuss that later.”

Satisfied at the time with my answer, I realized her desire for my dominance over her. I grabbed her handlebar pigtails and pulled them towards me, causing her mouth to descend further down my cock. She coughed and spat out the sides of her mouth as I held her head in place until she nearly passed out. I released her, and her head flew off, allowing her to breathe for the first time in what felt like over a minute. She smiled at me and sucked on my cock one last time, ensuring that the wetness was to her liking. She pulled it out of her mouth again, letting it drip wet, and she quickly stood up, turning around and bending over.

Her remarkable flexibility, honed through gymnastics and cheerleading training, was evident. She gracefully bent over in half, her head resting on her feet. With both hands, she reached around and spread her ass cheeks apart. It was truly awe-inspiring to witness her extraordinary abilities.

“Pound my pussy for now, baby! Just like my daddy does,” she exclaimed.

Her incestuous words were intoxicating. I was both shocked and captivated by her words, yet I knew she genuinely meant them. She adored her father and her father’s cock!

I drew closer, my dripping wet cockhead finding the entrance she had so generously opened for me.

I thrust forward, penetrating her spread pussy.

“Fuck yes! It’s perfect! I needed that fat cock spreading me!” she practically screamed as I entered her.

“Fuck me, Matt!”

I grabbed her waist and began thrusting deeply into her gaping opening, yet tight vagina. She was so wet, and the angle was incredibly intense!

I continued pounding her pussy as she grunted in a bit of pain each time I hit her inner wall.

Then, I bent over her and reached down to pick her up from under her legs while staying inside her.

I lifted her in a full Nelson position, her head now pointing up, her arms locked to her sides. I picked her up and began fucking her, just like we’ve seen in pornography. I manhandled my ex, lifting her up and down, penetrating her pussy in the deepest position we’d ever done. I grabbed her pigtails and used them as leverage. I bent her in half, and she seemed to relish every moment of it.

“Oh my fuck! Matthew! What are you doing to me!? You’re tearing me apart! Please don’t stop! It hurts so good!”

I was drenched in sweat from my workout. Despite her petite and delicate frame, her body was still causing my arms to burn, but I didn’t mind at all. My cock throbbed and pulsated inside her.

"Yes, fuck me like that! Fuck me just like that! Fuck, it’s so deep!”

“I’m so close, babe! Where do you want it?”

“I’m not your scared little girlfriend, silly. Breed me, you fucking idiot! I want your cum inside me! Give me a cream pie! I want you to pump that load into me like you mean it!”

“Fuck, baby, I’m…”

She began to spasm on my cock, and her pussy clenched down hard. As her pussy came, I couldn’t hold it in any longer and ejaculated deep into her. My cum oozed out of her as she pulled herself up off my still-stiff member. Her orgasm milked my cock for all its worth.

“You’re the best baby,” she said.

“Thanks, baby. Your body feels incredible!” I complimented her.

She looked incredibly sexy. Her red hair was tied up in pigtails, and her cheerleader uniform was hiked up over her waist. Even her top was disheveled. As she got dressed, my cum ran down her leg, and she left without wearing panties. Just before she left the bleachers, she reached down and used her index finger to scoop up the cum from her leg and inserted it into her mouth.

“Mmm, I’m so glad you’re a big cummer! Now, I’ll have access to a delicious snack for the rest of the day!” she exclaimed.

“Now, Matthew, when can I meet your new girlfriend? I need to learn her ways!”

“Look, Michelle, I doubt you’ll ever meet my girlfriend. She lives a couple of hours away, and why would you want to? You’re the one I’m cheating on her with!”

“You don’t have to tell her about our recent affair. I just want to compare myself to her, and if she’s down, we can both use this tool of yours,” she said, picking up my now limp but girthy cock.

I must admit, it sounded incredibly enticing.

“I’m not sure, but I promise to call her.”

That night, I called Jess, my beautiful 17-year-old cousin. We caught up on our days, discussed our plans, and shared our usual conversations. I gathered the courage to ask her something.

“Hey Jess, what are you up to this Friday?” I asked.

“Anything you want to do, babe.”

I wanted you to come to my school and pick me up. I have a confession to make.

“Oh, Matty, what’s going on?” she asked.

“Well, my ex-girlfriend, Michelle, seduced me the other day, and I ended up having sex with her. I’m so sorry about that.”

“Matty, my body and mouth are hours away from you, baby. You need to relieve the tension in your balls! If you don’t, they’ll explode! I understand your needs. I assure you, I’m not angry. But what does that have to do with Friday?”

Her words threw me off a bit.

“My kind of ex, Michelle, wants to meet you. She wants to learn the ways of anal from you.”

“I’m at a loss for words,” she said, followed by a moment of silence.

“Oh no, I messed this relationship up,” I thought to myself.

She continued, “I’m honored that she wants to meet me, and even more that she wants to learn tips and tricks for anal with you… Set it up, Matty, and I’ll see you two on Friday at your school.”

I was very surprised that she didn’t freak out!

We said our goodbyes and ended the call. I immediately called Michelle and explained that she would be coming to school on Friday. I couldn’t wait to discover her plans for that day.

Friday arrived with great anticipation. I refrained from masturbation and any physical contact with Michelle to ensure a substantial load for my baby. As school let out, Michelle and I exited the building hand in hand, brimming with excitement for the upcoming meet.

Parked beside my car was my stunning 17-year-old cousin. She was absolutely breathtaking. Michelle approached the car where Jess stood and extended an embrace. I was definitely curious about how the encounter would unfold; my ex-girlfriend, known for being the school slut, and my cousin, who only loved anal sex, embraced each other and immediately began conversing.

After about five minutes, I suggested that we all take a ride to Michelle’s father’s house, our sexual safe haven. Since her dad clearly didn’t mind us having sex, we used her house frequently. So we decided to head that way.

We drove to her dad’s house in two cars. He wasn’t home, and I didn’t see his motorcycle. We got out of our cars and went inside, into the living room. We all sat on the couch, and the girls couldn’t stop talking to each other. It was surprising, honestly; they seemed they could have been best friends for years. I asked them if they wanted a drink, but they declined. I went into the kitchen to get myself a drink. When I returned to the living room, I noticed that the girls had stopped talking, but I heard another sound—the sound of two pairs of lips coming together in a passionate kiss.

Sure enough, I stumbled upon my cousin and my ex/current lover passionately making out on the couch. Michelle was quite assertive, but Jess matched her intensity. Watching those two was incredibly erotic. I almost dropped the glass in shock as my two sexy lovers explored each other’s mouths with their tongues. Clearly there was an attraction between them, which made me happy for obvious reasons, but firstly for self-preservation. I mean I really could have fucked this thing up, but I guess we were all the right people for the relationship we seemed to be getting ready to have.

They soon lifted each other’s shirts off, and Michelle started to suck on Jess’s perfect C-cup breasts the moment they were free. The girls moaned in unison, going back and forth between each other’s tits and making out. The sight was almost too much to bear. Jess realized I was now standing there.

“Oh, sorry, Matty. Your friend here has such soft lips. Have you had a chance to get them onto your cock?”

She knew the answer, but it was her way of getting us all going. I simply smiled.

“Yes, I certainly have! This week, Matty here has stretched my jaw a few times!” Michelle answered for me.

“Then, Matty, come over here and let us stretch both our jaws for you!”

I drank my water and strolled over to the couch. The girls didn’t stop making out until I stood in between them.

“I missed you, baby,” Jess said to me.

“I missed you more,” I replied.

Jess stood up, and I kissed her on the lips.

I instantly felt Michelle drop to her knees. She first fumbled with Jessica’s large buckle. Jess and I never broke the kiss. Jess simply helped by moving her hips to allow her new friend access to removing her pants. Sure enough, her pants were off, and, in typical fashion, my slutty cousin wasn’t wearing panties.

“Mmmm, perfect!” Michelle exclaimed while reaching her hand out onto her new lover's mound. She rocked her hand back and forth on Jess’s clit, causing her to moan.

Jess moaned into my mouth as she was being handled by her newest lover. This broke our kiss. It was at that moment that we realized I was overdressed. We looked down at Michelle, and all she had on were the ribbons in her pigtails. Michelle moved her way up Jessica’s stomach using only her lips and tongue. Kissing and licking around her belly button and across her smooth, tight skin. Eventually, we stood there in a three-way kiss until Jess broke free to remove my clothes. Once my shirt was off, she traded roles and kissed her way down my chest, stomach, and finally into my pelvic area. She removed my pants, and to her satisfaction, I was also not wearing underwear. Jess picked up my cock and stroked my heavy member while massaging my balls with her other. Pre-cum started showing at the tip of my head.

“Oh my god!! Matty, your balls must be so full! Your load is overflowing into my hand already! I can’t wait for all your cum to shower onto us.” Jess exclaimed while licking the white buildup at the tip of my cock.

“Come down here with me; he tastes great!” Jess directed Michelle.

Michelle let my kiss go with a gentle bite, stretching out my bottom lip. She lowered her body and got onto her knees next to her new teacher and sex partner. Jess continued stroking my cock while grabbing its base and guiding it into Michelle’s eager mouth. Michelle wasted no time at all and bobbed her head vigorously, matching Jess’s strokes. Jess had the perfect grip on my cock and nearly sent me over the edge when she began to twist and stroke in sync with Michelle’s mouth movements. Michelle sucked hard on the tip, releasing a popping sound similar to a wine cork popping out of a wet bottle. Jess seized the opportunity and now sucked it into her mouth. I could have blown right there but had to try to keep this thing going!

Michelle, speaking directly to Jess, said, “Matthew here tells me you’re an anal-only slut.” Jess continued her assault on my cock, humming “mhmmm” and nodding her head in confirmation. Michelle licked her fingers and lowered her hand down the small of her lover’s back, expecting to find her tight yet eager hole. To her surprise, however, once she was there, she ran into something hard: the jewel-looking end of a butt plug that had been installed by its owner prior to her drive-over. Jess pushed the plug out to meet Michelle’s fingers, allowing her to get a hold of it. She slowly removed the plug only to realize the massive size of it! Once the plug was removed, Michelle inspected the plug with her tongue and cleaned the plug, then turned her attention to the slightly gaping hole it came from. She then placed the plug on the coffee table next to a bottle of lube she had hit out earlier that morning. Michelle pushed her middle finger and her index into Jess’s ass, realizing that her fingers were too small for the experienced and recently stretched sphincter.

“Damn! I desperately want to be able to take things up my ass like you. Please teach me!”

She escalated quickly from two to four, pushing and rotating in and out of her ass. This action caused Jess to push her head deeper onto my lap. Michelle fingered her new friend’s ass while taking her other hand and used it...