The doorbell rang, and my wife had run to the store to get more candy. I answered the door, and Kat, my neighbor’s daughter, said in a seductive voice, "Trick or treat?" She was wearing a very short, sexy white dress. The top captured the bottom half of her round, firm breasts just above her areolas. Her long black hair cascaded over her right shoulder, resting on her breast. She carried a plastic pumpkin full of candy.

She was twenty now, but I hadn't seen her since she was sixteen, when she was babysitting for us and I caught her eating another girl’s pussy in my bedroom while my two girls were asleep in the next room.

I am fifty-five with salt and pepper hair. I am still in pretty good shape but am a little soft in the middle. I was wearing the scarecrow outfit from the Wizard of Oz movie. My wife, Jen, dressed as Dorothy.

My mind went back to that night I caught young Kat with her fingers deep in a pussy and her mouth sucking a clit. I remember the other girl was a little chunky and had braces on her teeth. I let her pull her panties back up and leave the house.

I didn't let Kat leave the room or cover herself up. One strap of her sundress was off her shoulder, and her small breast was exposed. Her panties were still around her left foot. Pussy juice covered her mouth. Her eyes were wide, and her bottom lip was shaking. "What are you going to do, Mr. C? Please don't tell your wife or my parents. My dad will beat me and never let me leave the house."

She crumbled to the floor and hugged my legs. "Please, please, Mr. C."

I patted her on the head and reassured her, "I won't tell my wife or your parents. I don't mind that you were munching carpet; to each their own. But you did it in my house; my bed; right next to my girls." I let out a fake big sigh. "So you will have to be punished. We will go out to the pool house, and I will put you over my knee and spank you."

"Yes, thank you. I will take a spanking, just please don't tell," she sniffled. She went to cover her tit, but I stopped her.

"Pick up your panties and bring them. Leave your pretty little titty out." I instructed. She did as she was told and followed me out to the pool house, which doubles as a grandmother suite when my wife's mother visits.

I sat on the dressing bench and motioned for Kat to stand in front of me. I was anxious to see her fully nude body. I pushed her other strap off her shoulder, and her dress fell to the floor. Kat put one hand over her pussy and her other arm across her chest. Tears pooled in her dark blue eyes, as she had never been naked in front of a man before.

"Put your arms behind your back and spread your feet to shoulder width," I ordered. Her shoulders slumped, and she looked down at the floor. She did what she was told. She had a perfect body. Small teacup-sized breasts with barely any areolas and small, tiny nipples. Her hips and ass were the perfect shape with an ample seat. She had trimmed her black bush into a small triangle, and she had no hair on her labia.

My cock was tenting in my pants, and my heart was racing. "What am I doing?" I thought to myself. I almost let her leave, but I glimpsed a tiny drop of moisture on her pussy lips.

I pulled her onto my lap and rubbed my hand over her firm ass cheeks. I used my fingers to spread her cheeks so I could see her tiny starfish and her puffy labia. Kat flinched when she felt my cock twitching. My cock pressed hard against her belly.

My hand came down hard, repeatedly, on her ass cheeks. Kat whimpered and tried to be brave and not scream out in pain, even though her ass was stinging. She was very brave until her ass cheeks blistered, then the pain became too much. She loudly cried out in pain and outwardly sobbed. I noticed the blisters forming on her reddened ass, and I stopped spanking her. She stood up and danced around the room as a child does after receiving a spanking. Her mascara ran down her cheeks.

"Come stand in front of me again and assume the position," I barked. She did as she was whimpering and sniffing. Her chest rose and fell with heavy breaths. “I assume someone has fingered you before,” I inquired.

"Yes, sir, but only by girls and me," she admitted.

"I suppose you are a virgin and have never seen or touched a cock," I continued the interrogation.

"Correct, sir. Are you going to fuck me?" she asked in a whisper.

"Do you want me to fuck you?" I asked hopefully.

Kat gulped and thought about her situation and replied, "If that is what you need to do so you won't tell your wife and my parents."

I bent over and sucked her right breast fully into my mouth while working two fingers between her folds into her pink entrance. Her head fell onto my shoulder as I switched to the other tit and found her G-spot. Her knees buckled, and her pussy became dripping wet. I had her right on edge when I pulled my fingers out and pushed them into her mouth.

After she sucked my fingers clean, I laid her on the bench and pushed my face between her soft, young thighs. I took in her essence before licking her starfish. She squealed with delight as I rimmed her asshole. My tongue then slipped into her pink hole, and my thumb found her tiny love button. Her thighs crushed my face. She tasted so fresh and tangy. She covered her mouth with her hands as she screamed through an orgasm.

I had her sit up on the bench with me standing close in front of her. She knew what was next, and her body shivered. I unbuckled my belt and unfastened my pants. I pushed my pants and my boxers to the floor and stepped out of them. Kat had her eyes closed tightly. "Open your eyes and take your hands and explore my cock and balls," I demanded.

You could cut glass with Kat's nipples. Her body was giving her excitement away. She slowly unclenched her eyes and stared straight at my one-eyed monster. My cock was a decent seven inches and was smooth and not veiny at all. My wife says my cock is very handsome. My girth was not overly thick, but it was thick enough to stretch open pussy walls. I shaved my pubes and balls, as my wife does not like to get hair in her mouth while giving head.

Kat looked at my smooth pink head and the slit at the tip as it had pre-cum built up. She tentatively fondled my wrinkled sack and held my spongy cock at the base. She thought the feel of my cock was exotic. She slowly stroked my cock like she saw on her phone when she and her friends watched porn.

On her own, she lashed out her tongue over my cockhead, licking the pre-cum away. "That’s a girl; now put it in your mouth and suck it," I moaned. Her warm, soft lips surrounded my cock, and she slid me in a few inches. I watched in amazement as her cheeks sucked in. I would not last very long. My fingers entwined in her hair, and I guided her mouth up and down my cock. I would not try to make her deep-throat me. The head of my cock hit the back of her mouth a few times, causing her to gag. She looked up at me with her big eyes, and that's all it took. I filled her mouth with my creamy, thick cum. At my age, it didn't explode out anymore; it just gently poured into her mouth. She sucked hard on my shaft as she pulled off, cleaning my cock quite well.

She swallowed all my cum and looked up at me and smiled with pride. I urgently had to have this angel now. I bent her over the bench, resting on her elbows. I ran my fingers over her starfish before grabbing her fleshy hips. Her big blue eyes looked at me over her shoulder. I nodded to her and said, "Brace yourself, baby doll."

Her pussy was slippery wet, so my cockhead easily pushed into her pink entrance. Her muscles clenched over the head as she grunted. Her pussy was tight, and I didn't want to hurt her. I slowly pushed deeper into her hot, wet cunt. Fingers, toys, or some vigorous athletic activity had obviously previously broken her hymen. My balls rested on her clit. She was heavily panting and moaning. My cock felt warm, and it made her feel full inside.

"Oh God, Mr. C, your cock feels amazing inside me. I want to cum right now, oh, oh, fuck, oooh!" Kat came hard on my cock. I haven't even started fucking her yet. I pulled back until the head was at her entrance again. She panicked as she thought I was pulling out. I thrust back in, causing her to grunt. I began fucking her hard, using her hips as handles. Her small tits were bouncing under her, and she loudly moaned.

My cock hit every nerve in her sensitive pussy. She was having one orgasm after another. "Fuck me, fuck me, fuck me with your beautiful cock. Oh God, this feels so good. Don't stop, please!" Kat cried out.

After a good fifteen minutes, Kat’s legs were weakening, and she was drooling and not saying understandable words. I came inside her without thinking, and in her state, she didn't seem to mind. She collapsed on the bench, and I watched my seed drip from her pussy.

I let her take a shower and dress. She looked at me and said, "You're not telling, right?"

"No, baby, you are safe. No one will know what I saw or what we did," I assured her. I smacked her on the ass and sent her home.

Twenty-year-old Kat asked, "Can I come in, Mr. C.?" I looked her up and down. I had forgotten how perfect she looked. I stepped aside and let her in.

"I am just going to come out and say this," Kat said in her smokey raspy voice. "I am getting married next week to Linda. Yes, I am still a lesbian. I told her about what happened that night when you punished me and took my virginity. It was the only time I had a cock in my mouth or pussy. I told her I could not quit thinking about how good you felt inside me. As good as you made me feel, and though you gave me more orgasms than I have ever had at once, it did not change who I was because I love women. She told me to come see you to see if I needed one last good fucking. Seeing you, even in your dumb costume, has soaked my pussy, and I want to feel your cock inside me right now."

My cock pushed hard against my burlap scarecrow pants with hay sticking out of the zipper. "I would love to, Kat, but Jen will be home any minute."

"No, Mr. C, she is at my house down the street. She and Linda are probably naked right now and eating each other’s pussy. What you didn't know was that Mrs. C was munching on my carpet regularly when I babysat for you. She is a closet bisexual, and Linda saw her at the store and seduced her. Linda is tall and blonde with enormous boobs. She is very persuasive. She texted me she had her face in your wife's pussy, so we have plenty of time. So that was the trick, and now it's time for the treat."

Kat raised her skirt and showed me she had no panties on. She had trimmed her black bush the way it was years ago, in a little black triangle. She pulled her straps off over her shoulders, and her dress fell to the ground. Damn, just how I remembered her. She still looked sultry and innocent. Her breasts were a little fuller, and that was the only difference.

"Undress and lie on the couch, scarecrow," she demanded. I obeyed and was on the couch in less than a minute. She straddled my face and forced her wet pussy down hard. I lapped up her juices that were dripping from her pussy lips, then dove my tongue deep into her pink. She rubbed her clit while I munched away. She moaned and moved her hips up and down my face. She was vigorously fucking my face as she reached back and pumped my hard cock.

Kat came hard on my face and flooded my mouth with her sticky nectar. She slid down my body, leaving a trail of sticky cum. She wasted no time in lining up my cockhead to her pink honeypot. Her pussy was just as tight as I remembered. Just like last time when my cock first penetrated fully inside her, she shuddered and screamed. Her orgasm was earth-shattering. She rode me hard, and I held her firm, perky breasts like handles.

Her eyes rolled up in her head, and multiple orgasms spasmed through her body. I actually exploded my cum inside her. Usually, I can only dribble out my seed, but this time my load was massive and spread inside her needy pussy.

Kat collapsed on top of me. My cock was still hard inside her. She continued shaking, having small orgasms as we lay together. She whispered in my ear, "Trick! I am ovulating, and your swimmers are on their way to fertilize my egg. Linda and I want to be parents, and this is the best way we thought of. Treat! If this doesn't take, you will keep fucking me until I become pregnant. Double treat! Linda and I want to have babies together, so you will fuck her until she becomes pregnant. Triple treat! Linda is a cock-virgin, and her hymen is intact." My cum exploded inside Kat's pussy once again.

"Yes, Daddy," she moaned.