Join the best erotica focused adult social network now
Login

Mystified as to Reader Reaction to My Latest Story

last reply
10 replies
228 views
2 watchers
26 likes

I honestly don't know whether I should pose this question here or somewhere else. If somewhere else is a better place, please let me know.

While I am used to getting a modest amount of reader reaction to the stories I post on this site, the reviews I do get are quite good.

But for my latest story, 'Adjust', written for the current (Oct/Nov 2026) Simulation competition, while the story has attracted 119 views in its first 24 hours, it has not attracted even a single like.

That has me completely mystified, as that has never happened with any of my stories, nor with any story I've read on this site.

It's main category is Science Fiction with bisexuality as an equal secondary category—both things I thought would be popular here. Without giving too much away, it's set in a post-apocalyptic dystopia where the main character can no longer live in his underground silo and pod any more. His Ai assistant locates one other survivor, but that survivor wants to be sure about the main character and reorient him for life with another male through three virtual reality dates which become assessments, training sessions, and tests.

I truly enjoyed writing and revising it over the course of a week, making sure everything from grammar to tense were correct and the plot, narrative and dialog flowed well; and thought that given my previous well-received bisexual story, Hedonism, Home and Family, that Adjust would be received well also.

So, if any readers care to give me negative feedback as to why Adjust is not working, I'd much appreciate it.

Here’s my thoughts: you needed a stronger title, first and foremost. I get why you picked it, but you are one of many on the home page, and need to stand out on an erotic site. Maybe something with an erotic feel to it, or a title that really grabs a reader. Second is I don’t think your cover helps either. I don’t think it’s sexy. Third, I’m seeing fewer comments across the board so far on comp entries. Not sure why.

I read it and enjoyed it! Many funny lines. An interesting storyline. Have you tried pimping it in the competition forum? Many post there when they submit.

And sometimes a story just doesn’t connect. If you like it, try not to ruminate, and move on to the next! smile

Hope this helps…

“A writer is a world trapped in a person” — Victor Hugo

❤️

It’s only been two days. It may be a bit early to gauge the response. Even many of my most consistent readers will take longer than that to get around to reading a new story from me.

That’s the very reason I don’t have any feedback to give yet. I haven’t read the most recent 8-10 submissions, including yours, though I intend to. Especially now knowing it features male bisexuality! I often try to represent that in competitions, sometimes being the only one to do so. My entry this time is a straight one, though it does hint at bisexuality, so I thank you for taking the baton, as it were.

I’ll read yours soon and have more to say, but in the meantime I’ll echo Kimmi’s comment that the cover doesn’t feel particularly compelling, as well as her suggestion to post a link in the forum thread to bring more eyeballs to it. I will add that the sentence structure of the caption is a bit confusing, and may not be grabbing reader interest. Also, this competition does seem to be getting less attention from writers than most, so that may also be true for readers.

Per the title of this thread, it is often mystifying why one story gets more of a response than others. Why has my recent Monster Sex story “Sexsquatch” gotten several times the response of the Horror one “Persistent Terror,” into which I put a ton of effort to try to make it scary? Both feature October hikes gone wrong (in different ways) in the mountains of Washington, although the latter admittedly features a lot more jump scares than sex, and includes interracial male bisexuality. Maybe that's why, or maybe the jump scares were over the top, seeming contrived to readers? I don’t really know. The occasional inscrutability of reader reaction seems to be the nature of the beast, so to speak.

Quote by KimmiBeGood

Here’s my thoughts: you needed a stronger title, first and foremost. I get why you picked it, but you are one of many on the home page, and need to stand out on an erotic site. Maybe something with an erotic feel to it, or a title that really grabs a reader. Second is I don’t think your cover helps either. I don’t think it’s sexy. Third, I’m seeing fewer comments across the board so far on comp entries. Not sure why.

I read it and enjoyed it! Many funny lines. An interesting storyline. Have you tried pimping it in the competition forum? Many post there when they submit.

And sometimes a story just doesn’t connect. If you like it, try not to ruminate, and move on to the next! smile

Hope this helps…

To add to what Kimmi said (and she's bang on), I do find s-f and fantasy don't always fly well on here. In this comp, you would think that would be different given the theme pretty much steers things to those genres but for some reason, people don't seem to find sff sexy. I know one of my lowest performing comp entries is a near future s-f piece I wrote for the "Punk" competition a few years ago.

On a difficult journey home, Kate finds love and sex in a fellow traveler.

Kate Meets Martin

And I first introduced Kate as a university student whose first time kind of sets the stage for her new story.

Kate Kissed Keith

Yep, sci-fi fares poorly on this site, sadly. And this competition is very slow on the uptake. Many writers don't read other entries until they have submitted theirs. It's a tough theme to meet head-on.

Have you read, liked and commented on as many of the other entries as you can? Have you pimped your story on your profile? In the competition forum post? In the self-promotion forum?

Other writers/readers don't sit on the competition page pressing refresh and waiting for new entries. People tend to check the category landing pages they like for new/trending work, and also authors they follow.

If you pimp your work, and take the time to read / comment on others, perhaps people will read yours too? You might get some followers out of it, which helps massively for reaching an audience in future.

And, as has been mentioned, your title, cover and strapline don't draw people in. Those are the three killer things you must get right if you want to attract readers. They're the only touch points (along with the first sentence or so) that you have with a potential audience and you have to grab people from the get-go.

"I'm on a beach." is a bit of a crap first line, frankly.

"I'm busy kneading the moderate, somewhat hanging and oscillating breasts of a nude Polynesian woman. She's poised at an angle over me, mounted, rocking herself steadily. We're on a beach." would be (a bit) better.

"The breasts of the nude Polynesian woman riding me sway, before I grab and knead them. She gasps, steadily rocking on my hard shaft. We're on a beach." is better still...

Over one million views on my stories can't be wrong, so please dive in and browse my 185 stories:


* 35 Editor's Picks, 93 Recommended Reads.
* 19 competition podium places, 12 other times in the top ten.
* 31 collaborations.
* A whole heap of often filthy, tense, hot sex.

Quote by KimmiBeGood

Here’s my thoughts: you needed a stronger title, first and foremost. I get why you picked it, but you are one of many on the home page, and need to stand out on an erotic site. Maybe something with an erotic feel to it, or a title that really grabs a reader. Second is I don’t think your cover helps either. I don’t think it’s sexy. Third, I’m seeing fewer comments across the board so far on comp entries. Not sure why.

I agree with what Kimmi says above and what the others have mentioned in their replies. But, for what they are worth, here are my thoughts...

The sci-fi and fantasy genre never seem to draw much of a following, as potential readers seem to just skip it. My competition story is in the same category, and I actually put in the author's comment that the story could have been in the much more popular teen genre. That was just to encourage readers. 😇

Do you read other competition story entries? Doing so may encourage other authors to read yours.

I've not read your story yet; I'm working upwards, and by coincidence, it's the next one on my list to read.

So, having said that, you will get at least another comment and another like. 😎

BTW: just to let you know, I read all the competition stories, like them (a few will get the favourite box also ticked) and leave a comment. 😊

Quote by wxt55uk
I actually put in the author's comment that the story could have been in the much more popular teen genre.

I probably would just put it in Teen and use "science fiction" as a tag. My above mentioned "Punk" story was in "Bisexual" (though the main character is probably a better fit for "pansexual"). I didn't actually even tag it "science fiction" but the one liner and the use of the tag "near future" kind of telegraph it.

On a difficult journey home, Kate finds love and sex in a fellow traveler.

Kate Meets Martin

And I first introduced Kate as a university student whose first time kind of sets the stage for her new story.

Kate Kissed Keith

What others said. I don't hate your title. Find the sexiest sentence in your story and make it your one-liner. Mostly thugh, read the other stories and comment! I just entred the comp and am only now reading stories. I'll get to yours and others will too. Coments are like karma - the more you leave the more you get. Good luck in the comp!

Tintinnabulation - first place (Free Spirit)
Comet Q - second place (Quick and Risqué Sex)
Amnesia - third place (Le Noir Erotique)

Quote by Ensorceled

Mostly thugh, read the other stories and comment! I just entred the comp and am only now reading stories. I'll get to yours and others will too. Coments are like karma - the more you leave the more you get. Good luck in the comp!

This is really, really good advice. I can't tell you how many times a fellow contest author has commented on my entry within a couple of days (or hours) of my leaving a comment on their story. It might be a competition, but it's a very friendly one.

Story stats aren't what they should be? Welcome to Lush!

Like all social/ creative spaces, Lush is subject to fads, fashions, and flavours of the month. Many writers here cater to those who want to read 'the popular stuff' - IF, breeding, teen, BDSM, spanking, cucks, cock cages... did I mention IF?

Personally, I write mainly poetry, sci-fi, fantasy, and historical stories. I'm told that these are not the most popular genres, and frankly I don't care. I'm only concerned with writing stories about topics that interest me, and that express who I am as an author. I find that many authors also write stories that I like to read. Many, but not all, and that's the way of the world.

I'm not going to tell you how to write or what to write about, but believe me when I say that I've been there many times and experienced all the same frustration. The trick is not to let it get to you and to realise that you can't please everybody. So concentrate on writing what interests you, and in time you'll attract a group of writers and readers who like and support your work. I've been here 17 years, and I'm still working at it. It takes time.

As others have said, a great start is to submit your story, then to read and comment on other entries. btw I have read your story; I liked it, and I'm going to leave a comment.

Kronokrator – Fantasy & Sci-Fi Story by Piquet | Lush Stories


Love Is Blind | Lush Stories - A poem of love and pain...