Marie's unannounced homecoming made the week between Christmas and New Year's a bit awkward. The look of disbelief on her face etched in my memory along with the feeling of my erect cock having just filled Zoey's pussy. Marie went to her room and after the door slammed, Zoey and I got off the couch and got dressed.
She pulled out a gym bag that was tucked between the couch and wall and slipped on a pair of sweatpants and a t-shirt over her perfectly nude body. Somehow, she looked good in it. I watched as she exited the living room to go after Marie.
I sat there on the couch, taking stock of my current situation. My cock was just starting to come down. I guess it still aroused me to be caught, even if it was my own daughter. I collected my things and went to my room to change.
"Well this holiday just became interesting," I thought as I entered my bedroom.
A few days later, the storm settled. Marie was talking to me without any sarcasm or judgment in her voice. In fact, she seemed to be getting along really well with both me and Zoey. The two had plans for New Year's Eve and so did I.
My next door neighbor, Tabitha, asked me out. Normally, this doesn't happen. That is, women normally aren't the ones asking me out on a date. I knew Tabitha was divorced, but I had seen her dating guys who were a bit younger and driving fast cars.
During our most recent conversation, Tabitha had confessed to wanting to go out with me but had seen Zoey around the house and thought we were an item. I assured her it was not like that at all and even went as far as telling her it was more a "friends with benefits" type of relationship.
Needless to say, Tabitha's interest skyrocketed. I won't lie. I was just as interested in her. Tabitha was 35, stood around 5'5" and had a perfect set of 36C breasts and a firm, round ass. Her long, dark hair highlighted her piercing blue eyes which could make any man's knees buckle. She was that gorgeous.
We met in my driveway on New Year's Eve. She wore a short, low-cut black dress. She wore a small jacket given the fact it was cold out. I didn't think it was possible for her to look any better. I was wrong. I helped her into my '66 Mustang. It was a project car I had spent years working on and was my pride and joy. I only took it out on special occassions.
Such was this night.
Our plan was to get some drinks and have dinner before going to a New Year's party at a popular club. As the night progressed, we talked about our relationships, our life goals and interests. After the second round of drinks following dinner, the conversation turned to sex.
"So, how long have you been sleeping with college co-eds?" Tabitha asked.
The question aroused me. Normally, the women I dated weren't so direct in asking about my sexual preferences.
"Not long," I replied. "It's been a very recent thing and just the one girl."
"The blonde girl," Tabitha said. "I saw her go into your house on Christmas Eve."
I spent the next several minutes recapping the events that transpired going back to Thanksgiving and being very direct with my words. Tabitha's eyes grew wider. The tip of her tongue gliding along her lips as she took in the visual I presented her.
"I'm not gonna lie," she said after I concluded my story. "That sounded hot and makes me want you even more."
I felt my cock start to rise in my pants.
"I know we planned on watching the ball drop, but we've seen it before" she said. "How about we go back to your place and you play with someone closer to your age?" Her hand had found it's way to my thigh as she gave me an evil, seductive smile.
I paid the check and we sped home. Tabitha and I were entangled in each other's arms as we moved towards the door. Her lips were full and soft. Her taste was delicious. I unlocked the door and began unzipping the back of her dress.
Tabitha placed her hand on my crotch and began rubbing the raging erection in my pants.
"Mmmmmm....," she said as she pulled her hand back to remove her dress. "Somebody is horny."
I watched as she let her dress slide down her body. She stood there, wearing a black thong. Her lucious tits begging to be touched. Tabitha walked over and kissed me deeply. After breaking the kiss, she pulled me by the tie and led me to the bedroom.
She closed the door behind us and sat on the bed. She pulled me closer and undid my pants, freeing my cock. She held my erect member in her hand and looked up at me. She smiled.
"No wonder Zoey came back for seconds," she said before taking it into her mouth.
I closed my eyes and let out a soft moan.
I began untying my tie and unbuttoning my shirt. I took in Tabitha's sexy, naked body as she sucked my cock. She looked incredible. I dropped my shirt to the floor and helped Tabitha to her feet. I kissed her. I could taste my cock on her lips. My hands made their way down her body, stopping at her waist. I pushed her thong down and she stepped out of it when it hit the floor.
She went to lay on the bed. She watched me remove the rest of my clothes as she rubbed her wet, shaved pussy. I could tell she was ready to be fucked. Her pussy glistened, inviting me to taste it.
Crawling onto the bed, between her legs, I kissed her thighs before my tongue traced its way to her bare pussy. Teasing her lips, I could taste her sweet juices that had begun dripping from her wet, hot hole. Tabitha grabbed my head, her hands clenching my hair as she moaned in delight.
"Oh fuck, baby....yes!" she squealed.
She continued holding my head in place as my tongue danced circles around and inside her pussy. I took my hand and began massaging her mound as I watched her tilt her head back, her moans reacting to the various touches I was giving her body.
"Oh fuck....I need your cock in me," she panted. "I'm so horny. Please, fuck me now!"
I don't know if it was possible to get any harder than I already was at that point. I pushed myself up and moved up on the bed. Her warm naked body felt good against mine. Her erect nipples pressed against my chest as I kissed her lips; our tongues meeting one another.