It's Halloween, and I stand in front of my mirror, considering my physique as I button up my black shirt, dressing to impress. It's been three weeks since I broke up with Ruth, and after much agonising, I'm finally ready to make my move. Tonight I plan to be honest about my feelings and tell Justin exactly what I think about him.
I've practised what I want to say repeatedly in my head for years, trying to work out the best way to get it out, but I'm nervous knowing our friendship is on the line by doing this. All I know is that I can't live this lie any longer and waste my time with those I don't like. It's becoming tougher to maintain this pretence, and watching him with others is killing me. The sooner this is out in the open, the better.
I finish dressing, put on my skull mask, then go downstairs to where the party has already started. My brother John has gone all-out tonight, draping fake cobweb over the bannister, ceilings and doorways. There are easily over eighty people crammed in here, and music is blaring from the living room where the DJ has set up. Squeezing past a group of girls from my year, I head inside the kitchen to grab a drink and spot Justin with his back to me, talking with Shaun.
"Hi, guys!"
"Oh, you've finally decided to join us," Justin says, turning to give me a wide, lopsided grin. "I was expecting something better with how long you've kept us, but that is the laziest outfit I've ever seen."
"I tried facepaint, but it looked shit. You want a drink?" I ask, holding out a beer.
"Not for me, I'm driving tonight," Shaun responds, patting me on the shoulder as he passes by. "I need to find Kayleigh. See you both later, okay?"
Justin, as usual, looks gorgeous, with his mussed-up jet black hair and easy-going smile reaching his warm, earthy-hued eyes. Taking the bottle from my hand, our fingers briefly touch, and the familiar sensation of butterflies flutters within my stomach.
"Hey, you got the ones I like? Thanks!"
"Of course," I smile, my gaze dropping to his doctor's outfit and the stethoscope draped over his shoulders. "I like your costume. So, does the stethoscope work?"
"Want me to try it out on you?"
"Sure. I guess we could..."
With him putting on the earpieces and me unbuttoning the top of my shirt, he places the cold resonator against my chest. Close enough that I can feel his breath on my neck, his expression turns thoughtful as he listens to my racing heart.
Should I tell him now?
"Hm, I think you may be sick," he laughs, oblivious to my turmoil as he steps back. "Or I'm just doing it wrong. You may want to get a second opinion."
With the opportunity slipping away, I fold my arms across my chest. "It's good you don't plan to be a doctor, then."
"Well, not officially," he winks, nudging me in the bicep. "I heard Rachel has a thing for roleplay."
"Rachel from our science class? I don't understand why you bother... She's turned you down six times already!"
"She had plans last time."
"Plans? She was getting off with David on my birthday," I scoff, irritated by the mention of her. "You need to learn when to quit because she clearly sees herself as out of your league."
Momentarily, Justin appears hurt by my snippy remark with his natural, easy-going smile dropping.
"You think she's out of my league? I bet you twenty quid I'll fuck her tonight."
"That's not what I meant... I just think you deserve better than that," I try to explain, backtracking slightly. "I hate seeing you pretend that you're okay when she turns you down."
Acknowledging my better phrasing, he nods. "Alright. If she turns me down tonight, I'll walk away. So, you want to go outside for a smoke? Grab your guitar or something?"
Deciding we have nothing better to do, we go out into the garden with my acoustic then find my brother John getting high with some of his friends and a couple of girls I invited. Joining them, we sit down on the patio steps, and I roll out two joints, handing one to Justin.
"Fuck, it's cold tonight! I should have brought a jacket," Justin complains, shivering beside me. "Give me your lighter."
"Do you want to borrow one of my hoodies?"
"Nah, it's fine. Just get close and let me steal your body heat," he grins, moving nearer.
Beside me, with his thigh pressed against mine, my heart starts thumping rapidly again, and my hands turn clammy. I wish I could put an arm around him to warm him up, but I'm not ready to tell him how I feel yet. I need more alcohol to take the edge off, so I take a swig from my beer and decide to put it off until we're alone.
After a few hours of smoking and drinking, while we sing along to my guitar, I become fuzzy around the edges, growing in confidence. We haven't sipped beers and messed around like this since the summer, and I've missed it. With John heading indoors with Sadie from my English class, latched to his arm, I know this is the best chance I'm going to get tonight.
"Give me a song, Justin. Hit me with anything you can think of, and I'll try to play it," I say, hoping to impress him.
"That Evanescence one! My Immortal," Rachel practically shrieks as she joins us, dressed as an angel, sitting down on a deck chair near Justin.
Peeved by her arrival, my tone becomes snarky in my response. "Since when was your name, Justin? Are you seriously trying to depress us, Rachel?"
"It's a good song. I bet you're just one of those posers who can't actually play," she says, reaching over to lay her hand on Justin's knee.
"Just play it for her, Matt."
"Fuck you," I mutter under my breath, beginning to play Weezer's 'Tired of sex' to ruin the mood.
"...Or just play whatever you want," he shrugs, moving to sit next to her. "So, have I died and gone to heaven because I swear I'm looking at an angel right now?"
As I watch him flirting badly with his latest fascination, my chest pangs as I miss my moment yet again. I'm usually sure of myself until it comes down to who I actually love. Then I clam up, uncertain of how to act or what I should say, like now because someone else has grabbed his attention.
I wish he could see me as something more.
Flicking his fringe out of his eyes, he glances over at me, giving me a carefree, broad grin as he notices me watching. Caught staring, unable to find the courage to express my feelings, I return the smile like I always do. Justin will never see me as anything other than a friend.
As Rachel climbs on his lap, I decide to leave, opposed to being the third wheel while they get off. "I'm going to the off-license."
In the bathroom, with my hands trembling in anger, I grip the sink and glare at myself in the mirror. I can't do this to myself anymore. I need to stop being a fucking wimp and worrying about the fallout if I'm rejected. This is my own fault for hiding everything for all of these years, and if he knows how I feel, perhaps he would be discrete rather than blatantly shoving it in my face.
I need to tell him.
Sick with the anxiety of knowing what I have to do, I splash my face to freshen up. I'm going to be outed and likely rebuffed at once, but at least, I'll be able to work on moving forward with my life. If anyone treats me differently over my sexuality, then that's their problem, not mine.
Stepping out of the bathroom, I grab my guitar leaning against the wall to return it first to my bedroom. However, before I've even turned the handle on my door, I hear whispering and giggling on the other side, so in a fury, I swing it open.
Like a deer in headlights, in reverse cowgirl in the middle of my bed, Rachel stops fucking Justin. Seething in rage at their audacity, I want to rip them apart, but I just stand there like a lemon, speechless as I survey the sight of them naked together.
Smiling, sweetly, Rachel brushes her touselled hair over a shoulder, beckoning me over. "You're back, finally. Come play with us."
I'm crestfallen at her words, realising that the threesome we'd promised to not speak about has been revealed by him.
"Justin, I need to talk to you," I reply, tearing my eyes away. "In private."
Shutting the door behind us, Justin, still undressed and in a dishevelled state, props himself up against my wall. He doesn't seem to be himself as he sniggers with laughter, entirely unashamed by his behaviour, half-cut and buzzing from whatever he's had in the past twenty minutes.
"So, you're joining us, yeah? Come on, I told Rach that you would."
"What exactly did you tell Rachel? That we had a threesome with Ruth? Have you forgotten about the chat we had in the car?"
"About pretending it never happened? Was it really that bad? It's not like we fucked each other," he scoffs, rolling his eyes at me. "Mate, I didn't think it would be a big deal, and she's well up for it. I don't want to let her down."
"It's a huge fucking deal! I felt like shit after! How could you promise something like that after how awkward it was last time? You haven't even spoken to me about it. I'm your friend, and you're planning things like this behind my back, thinking you can just spring it on me? Did you even consider how I would feel?"
"Come on, Matt, don't be like that. It's only meant to be a bit of fun. It's not like it will mean anything, and no one else has to know if you're worried someone will think you're gay."
"Is that supposed to be a joke? Fuck you, Justin, and get the fuck out of my house."
I'm livid as I step away, turning my back on him. There's no way I can consider talking to him when he only wants to use me to impress a girl. I don't understand why I even like him as a friend with how self-centred he is. The urge to find someone to release my frustrations with is surfacing, but I know it wouldn't be fair, and I'll be just as selfish as Justin to use them in that way. I'll grin and bear it, pretending everything is okay like I always fucking do because nothing will ever change.
With my mouth feeling dry and unable to return to my room, I head downstairs for water. From a quick scan of the house, most of the others seem to have left with how late it is, but I notice a girl dressed like a cat downing a drink near the sink when I walk into the kitchen.
"You'll make yourself sick," I warn as I open the cupboard for a cup, dreading my restless night on the couch.
Spinning around, she answers defiantly, "I'll be fine."
"If you say so," I shrug before turning on the tap.
"Don't you want anything stronger? I have Jack Daniels if you'd like to share with me?"
Her chestnut curls weaved with strands of copper frame brilliant green eyes that boldly challenge me. Warily, I skim over her black lace dress then realise she's absolutely tiny, barely reaching chest height.
"No, thanks."
"I'm not trying to get you drunk, you know?"
Does she think I'm shy of her?
However, no one has ever spoken to me that way, and inexplicably, I can feel my cheeks burn red. Without a word, I slide my cup across the kitchen island towards her and watch as she pours out an overly generous measure of half a pint, which she hands back to me.
"... Not trying to get me drunk... Jeez! How long have you been here?" I ask, wondering why I hadn't seen her earlier.
"Most of the night," she says, pushing an errant lock behind her ear. "I saw you outside with your friend earlier. I didn't know you were good at playing the guitar, Matt."
"Ah, we were just messing around," I reply, surprised by her familiarity. I don't recall having met. "Maybe next time, you could join us?"
I gulp back some of my drink as I search her face, trying to work out who she is. She reminds me of someone, but I cannot place her, although she must be from my sixth form to know about the party. I should ask for her name, but then she might be hurt when she clearly knows mine.
"I doubt your friend would like me around," she says, wrinkling her painted-on nose and whiskers.
"What makes you say that? He can be a massive jerk at times towards me, but he's never mean to women, especially when they're as pretty as you... Or has he already hit on you?"
"You think I'm pretty? I bet you tell all women that."
I've put my foot in it and opened my mouth without thinking. I wasn't even meaning to flirt. "Well, you are, but I'll shut up if you'd prefer?"
"No!" she suddenly yells, startling me as she grabs my forearm, sloshing drink down the front of my shirt. "I mean, I've never heard anyone call me pretty before, and I kinda like it."
"That's hard to believe. I'm sure you've had plenty of admirers tonight, especially with those adorable cat ears," I say, grinning as I give them a playful tug. "You're very cute."
Self-conscious from the attention, she starts touching her hair, smiling in shyness. "I may have had a few comments, but I had been hoping to talk to you."
"Me? That's... unexpected. Why didn't you speak to me earlier?"
"I was hoping that you'd approach me. I wasn't sure if you would, with you never noticing me before. I doubt you even remember my name."
"Oh, I'm sure I have. I'm terrible with names, but I recognise your face. You go to my sixth form, right?" I lie, hoping to stumble upon the truth. "You used to be in my class? I'm one hundred percent certain you're not in my science or mathematics class. Fuck, it's gonna be something like drama or media a few years ago. Yeah?"
"You're studying A-level mathematics and science?"
"Yes, why do you look surprised?"
"I just thought you'd pick easy subjects."
"I'm not sure if I should be offended by that?"
"You just seem the type. Scruffy, and artistic rather than-"
"Intelligent? You waited all night to tell me that? Ouch! Well, this is a definite first for me," I laugh, amused by her bizarre method of flirting. "So, have you ever managed to pick anyone up with these backhanded compliments? It seems like a risky tactic to insinuate that someone is stupid."
"I didn't mean it like that," she mutters, appearing annoyed, almost angry with herself. "Look, I'm not used to talking to guys..."
"I can tell," I tease, hoping to lighten the mood as I glimpse at the remaining alcohol in my cup. "So, were you lying and attempting to get me drunk? Because you're doing an outstanding job if you are. What is it that you want from me?"
"I was just trying to get you to open up. I heard you're hard to talk to and closed off, almost unapproachable."
"Open up? You sound like you could be dangerous if you're trying to get me to spill all of my secrets. Maybe I shouldn't drink the rest, and you can just ask me what it is you want to know?"
"Why were you arguing with your friend?" she blurts out without consideration.
I hadn't realised we'd been that loud, but we hadn't exactly been discrete about it. How much of our argument did she hear?
"You heard that, huh? He was asking me to do something I didn't wanna, but it's no big deal."
"I heard something about a threesome with some girl. How does that work? Did you have sex with your friend?"
"Definitely not!" I respond, stunned by her forwardness. "Are you asking me about the logistics of a threesome? Do you need sex advice, or did Shaun set you up for this? I wouldn't be surprised..."
"No, I was just curious about your friendship," she says, smiling at me as our eyes meet. "So, did you want to do it and make love?"
"Make love? Wow, you're just going straight for it. I admire your confidence, but it's best we don't. I'm not in the greatest of moods, so I'll only be using you if we fuck, and then you'll think I'm a jerk because I won't call you after."
"Please? It's impossible to speak to you at lunch, so I came here, tonight specifically, to see you. Whenever I think about you, my chest gets tight, and I feel sick. I just hope you will give me a chance. I love you, Matthew."
It takes a moment to sink in that this stranger is confessing to me. "Wait. You actually like me?"
With a nod, she moves nearer, and her arms wrap around me, her head sinking against my chest. I can't remember a single moment where I've been hugged since I lost my mother, but hesitantly, my arms coil around, and I crush her body against mine, needing the comfort. I didn't envision my night ending like this. I highly suspected an end to my friendship with Justin, maybe even a fight, but then I'd predictably chickened out. This girl, on the other hand, has put aside her fears and acted with the courage I've never been able to muster in an attempt to get what she wants.
Perhaps only one of us has to be left broken-hearted tonight?
My hand strokes her cheek, and I tilt her up to face me, with a desperate wish to recognise her, wondering what she sees in me. She's an absolute mystery, but from her story, it seems she's been admiring me for some time, right beneath my nose. How have I never noticed her before? Clear complexioned, with a voluptuous, natural pout, and mesmerising Eden-green eyes that I could get lost in. I feel like I need to know her further.
Chastely, my lips press against hers, and the sweetness of vanilla from her exposed neck hits me with a sense of familiarity again. I feel like I should find this unsettling, but instead, I find myself being drawn further into this enigma and becoming hungrier for the knowledge of what lies beneath.
With my hands running over the curve of her hips, our bodies instinctively mould to each other as I push her legs apart and lift her up on the countertop. My need to know her intimately is fuelled as she surrenders to my prying tongue, then in shyness at feeling me firm between her thighs, she breathlessly breaks our kiss.
"I've been dreaming about this moment for what feels like forever," she sighs before smiling wistfully and wrapping her arms around my neck. "Take me to your bed?"
I'm not sure what to say to her, with Justin currently occupying my room, but it's probably for the best that we don't take this further. I don't think I've ever bared the better side of me at school, and a small part of me is sceptical that she can actually like me from the way she's probably seen me behave.
"Not tonight, but maybe the next time we meet, we could get to know each other? You haven't even told me your name. Why don't we go on a date first? I'm free next weekend, so we could go to the cinema and have dinner together then see what happens?"
Unexpectedly, tears begin to stream from her eyes, and she jumps off the counter without answering me, fleeing from the kitchen. Have I wrongly assumed something and offended her?
The front door slams shut, so baffled, I chase after her, but I see a double-parked car pull off as I run down the front garden path. With no other sign of her up and down the avenue, I can only suspect that someone has come to pick her up.
If only she had given me her name.
-----
I arrive at sixth-form on Monday, determined to find the girl who had tried to seduce me, unable to put the thought of her to the back of my mind. For my own peace, I need to make sure she got home safely at the very least, regardless of whatever she thinks of me.
From replaying what happened Friday night, I can't find anything in my actions to have caused her upset other than the fact I technically turned her down. I wasn't in the right place for a start, and I didn't have enough time to process how to react. I doubt it would have been a mind-blowing experience for either of us, but did I wrong her by not fucking her? I'm pretty sure I acted honourably, so I can't understand it.
Unsurprisingly, when I bump into Justin at our first lesson together in science, he acts awkwardly with me. I suspected it with him disappearing at the crack of dawn the morning after, and from the way he turns away from me, he seems unwilling to discuss it. I definitely made the right call to not get involved, but I cannot concentrate on my lesson with flashbacks of both of them in my bed.
Every single time I finally work up the nerve to say something, I'm set back by someone coming between us. I was sure that the time was right, but I don't know anymore. Perhaps it isn't meant to be, and I need to learn to accept it once and for all.
Someone pats me on the shoulder, and I raise my head off my folded arms to see that the class is over. I've been so lost in my own thoughts recently that the days are turning into a blur.
"Matthew, is everything alright?" Mrs Robinson says, caressing the back of my hair. "If you're not in a rush, could we talk? I need to speak to you."
"I'm fine, Elaine," I say, shrugging her off me before slamming my textbook closed. "I'm going to be late for English, so if it's that important, then call me later, okay?"
"It won't take a minute, please? Gary is away this weekend, and I miss you..."
"Elaine, we can't keep doing this!"
"Why not? I thought we had fun together?"
"It stopped being fun when you began turning up at my house and telling me you were going to leave your husband," I snap, without looking at her, knowing I'll be tempted. "I'm not interested in you anymore."
I grab my rucksack then break into a sprint as I leave her behind. As much as I enjoy fucking Elaine, it has only been about the sex, and I have no desire to use anyone again. Outside of our liaisons, we have nothing in common, and I find her personality insipid. I'm craving more than physical intimacy in my life. I need someone who makes me feel alive, who challenges me, and keeps me on my toes. The kind of person who remains in my every waking thought the moment they're away from me.
Someone who isn't unobtainable to me like Justin.
Abruptly, I collide with someone's elbow as I fly around the corner, scattering her art folder and books across the ground. My mates, including Justin, immediately begin to jeer as she scrambles to collect her things, but instead of joining in with them, I help her by gathering up her life drawings, which I study, stunned by her talent.
"I'm so fucking sorry," I begin to apologise, with it being entirely my fault yet again. "I need to look where I'm going and stop running into you. Second time in a month, right?"
Suddenly, Chris throws a packet of crisps which hit her glasses, to further cackles of laughter from my classmates.
"Could you refrain from throwing wrappers at me!" she says, her breath ragged as she holds back her sobs in humiliation.
"Why, what are you going to do about it?" Justin challenges, glancing down at her prefect badge on her navy blazer. "You gonna report us?"
"Fucking arseholes," she grumbles to herself, snatching her artwork away from me as she kneels on the floor to sort through her things.
"What did you call us?" Chris snarls, using his size to intimidate her by standing over her.
Responding to the rapidly escalating situation, horrified by what I'm witnessing, I shove him back against the wall, caring little for his reaction. "Leave her alone, Chris. I fucking mean it."
His face blazes with fury, nose flaring as he considers retaliating. Then with a clenched fist, he punches the poster board next to him, deciding better than to provoke me, knowing I won't hesitate to beat the living shit out of him.
With him leaving, I extend my hand to help the girl up, but she ignores it and turns her face away, unwilling to acknowledge me at all.
"I really am sorry, you know, and my friends aren't usually like that," I explain, feeling terrible by associating with them. "Well, everyone apart from Chris, but I've never liked him, to be honest."
"Perhaps you should get better friends, who aren't bullies," she says, shooting me daggers from her startling vivid green eyes.
Instantly recognising her, I quickly block off her exit, knowing it has to be her.
"It's you! The girl I constantly bump into because I'm never paying attention to what I'm doing. It was you... I actually found you!"